Since the end of the Cold War, countless publications have emphasized the stark dividing line between Europe and North Africa. While the northern bank of the Mediterranean was perceived as the land of prosperity, democracy, safety, and individual rights, the southern bank was the area of conflict, extremism, poverty, and authoritarian rule. This perception has led the European Union often to renege on its own declared liberal-democratic and inclusive values to set up barriers to the movement of people from the southern bank, supporting authoritarian rulers to ensure stability at the borders and implement economic policies that increased the wealth gap. More recently, worries about immigration have characterized every European policy vis à vis North Africa. The stark separation between the two banks of the Mediterranean however does not reflect the reality of their relationship, and it never did. This edited volume is a particularly welcome contribution to the literature attempting to challenge conventional wisdoms about the supposedly separate trajectories of the two areas. The premise of the book is that the construction of the “the other” as separate, alien, and dangerous does not reflect the contribution that North Africa has had in making Europe and, conversely, what Europe represents for North Africa in addition to what we already know about the legacy of colonialism.
The book makes two specific novel contributions. First of all, it uncovers the way in which colonial policies in North Africa fed almost directly into the ongoing project of integrating the industrial and agricultural sectors of North Africa with European markets. Bringing to light how colonial history fed into the contemporary European integration project, which the European Union personifies, testifies to both the linkages that predate any genuine conceptualization of a united Europe and the extent to which North Africa is actually a full participant in European history. The second crucial contribution, and the most interesting one, draws from the case of the Muslim minority in the city of Melilla to argue that European democracies benefit from the social and political mobilization of migrant minorities because they might actually strengthen the democratic process itself. This is an argument that the Italian writer and journalist Roberto Saviano made years ago when talking about sub-Saharan migrant workers in the south of Italy. As new citizens of the country unencumbered from the social malaise and historical legacies that may affect native Italians, their political mobilization in favor of legal equality, individual citizenship rights, and economic justice has arguably revitalized Italian democracy. This point stands in contrast to the dominant perspective on immigration questions in scholarship and policy-making circles, with their emphasis on securitization.
The book also examines how the European Union as well as individual European countries have reconciled, or not, the inherent contradiction between their stated values and their actual foreign policies. The chapters focusing on the EU relationship with Algeria, on Libya, and on transnational justice highlight how fear of “the other” has forced Europe to rely on authoritarianism and “strongmen” presidents on the southern bank to keep Islamist extremism in check and to prevent further migration into Europe. This is not a particularly novel point, but it provides further substance to the idea that even the ‘othering’ of North Africans as sworn cultural and economic rivals is part and parcel of the construction of Europe. What is more problematic, and the book points to this issue indirectly in the introduction, is that the EU's unwillingness to take its values seriously in relation to North Africa empowers the more overtly racist discourse of the European far-right. This has yet to translate into widespread sentiments of enmity coming from North Africa towards Europe. However, the chapter on cultural representations of Europe in Tunisian and Algerian songs and novels illustrates how disillusion about Europe and life in Europe is seeping into North African popular culture.
In conclusion, this edited volume is a powerful and interesting account of the intertwined fates of North Africa and Europe and it demonstrates that re-writing separate histories only serves political projects that are divisive and ultimately rely on a construction of an ‘other’ that may not exist.
