Looking at early modern midwifery treatises with the eye of an art historian, Lianne McTavish has seen in these works something overlooked by previous scholars: what she calls ‘the display of authority’. Her study focuses on some twenty-four such treatises published in French between 1550 and 1730, by twenty-one different midwifery practitioners, both female and male – and one of its points is that female-authored works had rather more in common with male-authored ones than we might have supposed.
This focus on display – judiciously linked to such topics as physiognomy, portraiture and courtly culture – gives us a new perspective on early modern childbirth and produces a feast of interesting findings. Male practitioners concealed their instruments and their emotions, but put the afterbirth on show in the crowded lying-in chamber; Louise Bourgeois, looking back on her delivery of the queen in 1601, vaunted her impassive face which had concealed the dynastic good news that the baby was a boy. The ideal ‘surgeon man-midwife’ (as the male practitioner is termed throughout) was supposed to embody both male and female attributes. Medical pamphlet warfare was associated with an etiquette of pseudo-anonymity; male practitioners consistently invoked their own personal experiences of childbirth – or rather, those of their wives, sisters or mothers – as if to compensate for their not being capable of giving birth themselves.
Perhaps the strongest sections are those dealing with pictorial material – author portraits and diagrams of the foetus in utero. Especially rich and revealing are the readings of a series of male portraits – Mauriceau, Viardel, Portal, Peu – in Chapter 4 (extending somewhat McTavish's article in Social History of Medicine in 2001). Here McTavish's art-historical skills yield rich rewards, as for instance in the superb unpicking of the complex author portrait prefacing Mauriceau's 1668 Traité des maladies des femmes grosses et accouchés. (It is a pity, however, that the portraits of Fournier, Amand and Dionis have not been considered.) But the final chapter, on images of the unborn foetus, is also excellent. Such depictions were commonly in tension with the content of the accompanying text: the illustrated foetus was free to move within a capacious womb whereas the verbally described foetus was cramped and ‘curled up in a ball’ (p. 182). Drawing on Peirce, McTavish convincingly characterizes seventeenth-century pictorial images of the foetus as diagrams rather than icons or symbols. This argument, like much of the final chapter, is pitched against Karen Newman's posited visual genealogy of the ‘rights-bearing’ foetus (Fetal Positions, Stanford, 1996), but McTavish's substantive findings transcend this polemical purpose.
The book is well organized and presented: each chapter has its own concluding passage; notes are helpfully positioned at the ends of chapters; the numerous illustrations are reproduced competently, if not as lavishly as some American publishers manage to achieve; the index is sufficiently detailed to enable the reader to track particular themes and individuals. Taken as a whole, McTavish's enterprise raises interesting disciplinary issues. A historian, as distinct from an art historian, would treat such a set of books not as a unitary object of study but rather as so many separate sources of evidence – in short, as documents rather than as texts – and would link them with one another only obliquely, by way of the historical actions and events to which they (supposedly) attest, rather than directly as McTavish has done. McTavish notices the difference early on: ‘my study features seventeenth- and early eighteenth-century obstetrical treatises as a genre of writing and representation rather than one source of information among others; in that sense it is a literary and art-historical project rather than a traditionally historical one’ (p. 12). Yet this is accompanied by another and very different package of ambitions, also articulated in the opening chapter: for instance, ‘I am interested in how men-midwives began to appear at deliveries’ (p. 1) and ‘I find that bodies, particularly those of midwifery practitioners, were crucial to the exchange of information and establishment of identity in the lying-in chamber’ (p. 16). And the title of the book – ‘childbirth’, not ‘childbirth treatises’ – signals historical rather than textual reference.
The result is that we actually have here two books, in an unresolved tension with each other: one historical (concerned with past events, particularly with change over time, and therefore positing the past as an arena of differences), the other ‘literary and art-historical’ (dealing with the content of texts, and regarding these as ‘largely homogeneous during this period’ (p. 14)). And it has to be said that the historical book falls short of the high standard set by the art-historical one. Little is offered on the genesis and reception of the treatises – a necessary consequence of treating each as the context for the other, which of course sunders them from external connections. Change over time is often flattened out – as for instance in the fact that what is called ‘the controversial status of male midwifery during the early modern period’ (p. 123) is treated as homogeneous throughout the period, and in the related failure to bring into focus Philippe Hecquet's 1708 attack on male practitioners. And the weakness of the historical dimension perhaps makes intelligible the otherwise puzzling omission of any discussion of what male practitioners called themselves – surely an integral part of their self-presentation, yet erased as a theme by the blanket designation ‘surgeon man-midwife’ (chirurgion-accoucheur) or occasionally ‘man-midwife’. A historianly emphasis on practice and on historical change might, one suspects, have brought this into focus.
McTavish writes, towards the end of her introduction (p. 13) that her goal ‘is not to displace other accounts of early modern midwifery, but to add another layer to them’. It may be disputed, as I have suggested, that an ‘account’ has been offered here, but the author has succeeded brilliantly in adding ‘another layer’ to our understanding of the subject. The book deserves to be a central point of reference in the history of childbirth for many years to come.
