Gesture and Power is an historical and ethnographic study of the multiple resonances between religion and politics in the Lower Congo region of the Democratic Republic of Congo, based on archival research and fieldwork in Kinshasa and the small town of Luozi. While its subject matter directly speaks to a long-standing line of anthropological inquiry, Yolanda Covington-Ward contributes to existing scholarship by foregrounding the importance of everyday embodied performances in the production and contestation of spiritual and political authority. Moreover, in and through her explicit focus on body politics, she highlights the profoundly gendered and racialized dynamics of mundane performances, and illustrates the complex ways in which race and gender affect the interactions between these performances and broader structures of power. This explicit focus on race and gender is not only a refreshing contribution to the history and anthropology of religion and politics in the region, but also intimately connected to Covington-Ward's self-consciously reflexive methodology as an African American female ethnographer.
The book focuses on a series of performative movements and events from the 1920s to the present, attesting to growing nationalist sentiments and racial identification among the BisiKongo people. The different chapters successively zoom in on: (a) prophetic movements in colonial Belgian Congo (known as kingunza); (b) forced choreographed dancing and singing (or animation politique) meant to glorify Mobutu's Zaire in the 1970s and 1980s; and (c) contemporary ritual practices of the religious and nationalist movement BDK or Bundu dia Kongo (the ‘gathering of the Kongo’). By bringing together these different historical threads, and by combining archival sources with personal memories drawn from ethnographic interviews, Covington-Ward convincingly reveals the cultural continuities that underlie the long history of everyday performative encounters in the Lower Congo. She shows how, for instance, spirit-induced trembling, dances, and mundane gestures spring from a collectively embodied history – without ignoring individual agency – and highlights how bodies operate as tools of resistance against state and missionary power, but also as sites for discipline and control by political and spiritual authorities.
Covington-Ward's major contribution lies in unearthing the often-unspoken bodily ways in which memories and histories are (re)made, by analyzing how prophetic movements, Mobutism, and BDK ideology rely on a largely shared repertoire of embodied cultural performances. Anthropologists and historians will also be particularly interested by her original account of the gendered logics of coerced animation politique and the sexualized performance of nationalism under Mobutu (Chapter Five), and by her fine historical contextualization of the ideology and ritual practices of the BDK, whose proponents strive for the restoration of the precolonial Kongo Kingdom (Chapter Six). Beyond the book's strikingly original combination of topics from different time periods, Gesture and Power also stands out for its focus on a rural area (Luozi) that remains rather marginalized within contemporary Congo Studies.
However, on a more conceptual level, Gesture and Power does not always live up to the claims it makes. While Covington-Ward coins the concept of ‘performative encounters’– combining J. L. Austin and Judith Butler – so as to provide ‘a theoretical framework for understanding how the micropolitics of the body in interpersonal encounters can affect macro-level social and political structures’ (11), it is unclear what new theoretical insights this concept offers to anthropologists and performance scholars. Moreover, neither her shift to the everyday nor her deliberate focus on bodies and embodiment pose a new ‘challenge’ for scholarship within these disciplines and beyond, as Covington-Ward seems to claim in her conclusion.
The introduction often reads as a dry enumeration of definitions of terminology and textbook-style summaries of work by Western scholars, some of whom are set up as straw men against which Covington-Ward defines her own approach. Particularly in the case of Bourdieu, this is quite surprising because, despite the introductory distancing, subsequent chapters are very Bourdieu-like in their analysis of embodied cultural performances and history. Furthermore, while Covington-Ward acknowledges that Kongo cosmologies fundamentally challenge ‘Western conceptions of the willful intentions of an individual person’, she does not allow her analysis to be affected by a substantially altered conceptualization of agency and performance, while she safely reduces emic concepts to mere ‘data’ rather than deploy their inherent theoretical potential (6).
Finally, under the guise of reflexivity, Covington-Ward's approach and writing often explicitly emphasizes her own presence in the field. While sustained attention to one's positionality as a researcher is, of course, indispensable to produce honest accounts, many ethnographic vignettes actually tell us more about her own frustrations, hardships, and anxieties than about the people around her. As a result, while her transatlantic reflections on cultural performance remain one of the book's major strengths, the sometimes uncritical focus on personal experiences, although potentially interesting, risks obscuring rather than ethnographically specifying (and historically contextualizing) the frictions and resonances between American and Congolese racial politics.
