The twentieth century was indelibly marked by Stalin's political struggles, choices, obsessions, and their legacies. The very notion of socialism cannot be entirely separated from his vision of the revolution, one imbued with messianic, quasi-religious beliefs, shrouded in a Marxist determinist jargon.
The main problem for those who want to understand the Stalin phenomenon is its questionable “inevitability.” For some interpreters, among them Isaac Deutscher, Stalin was an almost fatal phenomenon born out of the inner chemistry of the Bolshevik political culture. But was he really Lenin's most faithful disciple? Was he a genuine Marxist, one really endowed with a theoretical perspective, a Weltanschauung, or rather an improviser with doctrinary pretenses? No one has more contributed to the concoction, fabrication, and sacralization of Leninism, but to what extent was he a bona fide Leninist? From Lev Trotsky and Nikolai Bukharin to the old Georg Lukacs, major Leninist figures questioned Stalin's self-aggrandizing claims. Yet, Stephen Kotkin's monumental study, based on Sysiphus-like travails in the archives, both in Russia and in the United States, offers the image of a Marxist theorist, a man for whom ideas mattered immensely. Two hundred pages of endnotes show the exhaustive and exhausting nature of this admirable endeavor. No topic is simply mentioned, no detail is left without a reference to make it revealing and credible. This is historical writing at its best.
There are several crucial points in Kotkin's gripping biography: first, Stalin's deep Marxist convictions. He was not a theoretical opportunist, but a theorist convinced that Marx' worldview, as developped by his idol, Lenin, was the real scientific compass needed to grasp the contradictory nature of the social world. Kotkin's goal, therefore, is to show how Stalin saw the world through these Marxist lenses. Stalin’s self-image (a very important point in the previous, unfinished masterful biograhy written by the late Robert C. Tucker) was one of an adamant Marxist—a stance to which he remained faithful until his demise in March 1953. Second, it was utterly important to him to be acknowledged as Lenin's true heir. This was—in the Bolshevik universe of bitter rancors, feverish jealosies, and all-consuming rivalries—a matter of life and death. Stalin's nemesis, Lev Trotsky, had the same ambition, and the competition between the two paragons of Bolshevism sealed the fate of the Soviet experiment.
Stalin disliked Trotky to the point of a irreconcilable, venomous hatred. In turn, Trotsky treated Salin, as well as the other Bolshevik luminaries, as mere mediocrities. The link to Lenin's mantle was in this culture the guarantee of legitimacy. Whoever was the right interpreter of Lenin's gospel, was the true apostolic heir. To deprive Trotsky of such a status, Stalin (initially helped by two of Lenin's closest associates, Lev Kamenev and Grigory Zinoviev) invented Leninism as a presumed self-sufficient body of revolutionary precepts—the “Marxism of the age of imperialism and of the proletarian revolutions,” as he defined it. Logically, as Trotsky’s pre-1917 itinerary included moments of harsh polemics with Lenin on topics as significant as the nature of the vanguard party and the pace of the revolution, a constitutive other was constructed. Its name, to be forever vilified, was “Trotskyism.” Third, for Kotkin, Stalin's personality with all its psychological enigmas played a crucial role in the survival of the Soviet state and all the major decisions, including the genocidal war against the peasantry known as the collectivization of agriculture. Kotkin sees these decisions not so much as a result of historical necessity, but rather as the effect of an overgrown, exacerbated ideological obsession with fulfiling Lenin's behests. Stalin saw himself as today's Lenin and acted accordingly.
One of the most engaging sections in this immensely appealing book deals with the end of Lenin's life and his so-called “Testament.” Relying on the contributions of some Russian historians, Kotkin reached the conclusion that the much-quoted “Letter to the Congress,” Lenin's dictated final thoughts about political strategies and the increasingly vicious battle between the epigones, was in fact a forgery, or better said, a document attributed, rather than belonging to Lenin. This is a major point, politically and historically, and it needs some clarification. For Kotkin, the absence of Lenin's initials from the texts indicates malfeasance. He suggests that the “Testament,” especially the last letter in which Lenin asked for Stalin's removal from the already omnipotent office of general secretary of the Central Committe, was in fact authored by Nadezhda Krupskaya, Lenin's wife and lifelong political comrade. If this was so, one wonders how could Stalin ignore such an occurrence and not invoke it at least in the Bolshevik top inner circle? All his life he was haunted by what appeared to have been Lenin's disappointment in him. Why did he allow Krupskaya to die in her own bed, long after Lenin's death, in 1939? For Trotsky, whom Lenin called in the document “the most brilliant Central Committee member,” it was normal to stick to the defunct leader's words. For Stalin, however, challenging the authenticity of the “Testament” would have made sense. He did not do it and this raises questions about Kotkin's argument. He may be right, but such a significant claim needs more substantiation and calls for a whole scholarly discussion.
In October 1923, three months before his passing away, the terminally ailing Lenin, wheelchair-ridden and looking almost carbonized, imposed on his guards and chauffeur to take him for a final visit to the Kremlin. This is one of the most moving passages in the book: The old leader cannot communicate but through vague sounds, there is no Politburo member there to greet him, they are all gathered in a meeting in Trotsky's apartment where, instigated by Stalin and Zinoviev, they condemn “Trotskyist” factionalism. From his library, Lenin picks up a book by the mentor of his youth, Georgi Plekhanov, and three volumes by Hegel. This is a telltale story revealing Lenin's utimate conviction that without understanding Hegel it is impossible to understand Karl Marx's doctrine.
It seems, from Kotkin's account, that Stalin was the last among the top elite to have learned about the “Testament.” He was struck by the intrigues fomented by his colleagues. Naturally inclined to see treason and conspiracy everywhere around him, he found his misgivings vindicated. It did not help that a year later, two members of his triumvirate, Lev Kamenev and Grigory Zinoviev, established an alliance with Trotsky, the so-called Left Opposition. Endowed with an unbending will, convinced that the laws of history were on his side, a champion of the party bureaucracy interests, Stalin outmaneuvered his competitors and transformed his original mini-kingdom in the Kremlin into a nightmarishly grandiose historical adventure. Kotkin’s book chronicles this destiny with a sure hand, highlighting intense political will, ironclad determination, and inflexible tenacity, as the most important components of Stalin's mind. For Kotkin, it was this formidable hubris, completely driven by ideological fixations, not the historical circumstances invoked by historians such as E. H. Carr, that explain what otherwise would remain forever inexplicable.
This first volume of Kotkin's seminal work ends with what Stalin himself defined as the year of the great turning point, 1928. At this moment, Trotsky was defeated, Nikolai Bukharin and his followers had capitulated, and Stalin ran supreme. A new revolution was to come, his own one, which he dreamed to be as consequential as Lenin's. I cannot wait to read the next volumes of this truly brilliant book, comparable to the best Soviet studies ever offered, from Boris Souvarine, Robert Conquest, Richard Pipes, Leonard Shapiro, Alain Besançon, Zbigniew Brzezinski, and Adam Ulam to Martin Malia, Robert Service, Seweryn Bialer, Sheila Fitzpatrick, Robert V. Daniels, Archie Brown, Robert Gellately, Dmitri Volkogonov, J. Arch Getty, Ronald G. Suny, and Simon Sebag Montefiore. All those interested in the mechanisms of ideocratic tyranny and the relation between personality, ideology, and terror will immeseley benefit from reading Kotkin's superb book.
