Victoria M. DeFrancesco Soto’s research on political behavior has been widely published in scholarly journals and cited in the New York Times, Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, Time, and Politico. Fluent in both English and Spanish, she provides political analysis on both US politics and its implications for countries abroad. DeFrancesco Soto’s research analyzes how social identities shape political behavior.
Highlights from her interview discuss ways in which APSA can build a bridge connecting political researchers and political practitioners. It should:
-
• Help members move away from penalizing engagement and move toward a reward system—change the incentive structure.
-
• Coordinate get-to-know-you events and roundtables with political analysts, consultants, and others.
-
• Offer a database where journalists, political analysts, and practitioners can turn for expert advice or commentary.
Victoria M. DeFrancesco Soto was interviewed by Steve Friess, who has written for Time, Politico, and many other outlets.
STEVE FRIESS (SF) What sort of changes in academia need to happen to encourage political scientists to make their work more digestible for the public? What is your sense of what the problem is?
VICTORIA M. DEFRANCESCO SOTO (VS) We need a bridge. Today, on the one hand, we have many really smart people in the academy who are producing fantastic work, but it is not translated to the layperson, to the general smart person who’s interested in politics. On the other hand, you have politicians and political consultants—people on the ground—and these two camps don’t talk to each other. Researchers are too busy doing their work and getting tenure, and political folks on the ground are too busy getting their candidates elected and doing their work. These two groups could really benefit from talking to each other. A lot of it is inertia; there is no model for talking to each other. There is also some antipathy—not outright hostility—on each side. Academics sometimes think, “Hey, we’re smarter and better than you people, sullying yourselves with the dirtiness of politics,” and the politicos go, “Oh, you guys are so nerdy and out-of-touch, and you don’t get it.” But the two groups have a lot in common.
SF What do they have in common?
VS First, is their interest in politics. Political science, it’s in our name. We deal with the same questions— the difference is in how we ask them. Perhaps we could characterize as macro versus micro; the people who are on the ground think, “How can I get my candidate elected in this primary runoff?” And, the academics are looking at, “Hey, what are the factors that get people to come out in a primary, as opposed to a general election?”
SF What was the arc for you of moving from academia into a media profile?
VS In 2008, fresh out of graduate school, I started my tenure-track position at Northwestern University in the Chicago area. The timing coincided with the heating up of the 2008 presidential election. In early 2008, I got a call out of the blue from CNN en Español to comment on the primaries because I filled this niche of doing American politics but speaking fluent Spanish. So I started appearing on CNN en Español. When the 2008 general election came, they asked me to cover Election Night. Then I did inauguration events, and I got the bug. I said to myself, “This is awesome.” I get to talk about politics, and I get to do it with a live audience. Taking a step back, one of the things I very much enjoy about academia is teaching. You have a classroom full of people that you engage, and, with media, you have classrooms that are very big. You reach hundreds of thousands of people across the country via TV, or via your articles, or via the Internet. I felt this buzz. “You know what? The election’s over. Let me just keep on with what I’m doing. I’m super lucky.” Time passed, and I finally realized that my heart was somewhere else. My heart was in seeing what we do to reach a broader audience. I started writing more—the Huffington Post. Then, CNN en Español asked me to do more work for them, and then Univision called, too. Eventually, I crossed over. MSNBC asked me do some work for them, and I ended up getting a contributorship with them. Coming up on my midterm review at Northwestern—I’d been there for four years—I realized, “You know what? This isn’t for me. I think my calling is in being that bridge.” I know regression analysis, I know how to interpret data, but at the same time, I know how to speak to a general public, and I view myself as a translator for all of the fantastic work that my colleagues do but that sadly doesn’t reach more than a couple dozen people. Not many folks who are opinion leaders in our country, in terms of politics, read American Journal of Politics every night.
SF Where is the line between being a pundit and being a political scientist?
VS They’re not mutually exclusive. There are different breeds of pundits. There are pundits who are well-informed and well-versed and researched, and they don’t necessarily have to be academics. Among these people, like Ezra Klein and Charlie Cook, and some of the folks from the National Journal, are really smart people who may not have PhDs in political science but who know how to read data and how to put two and two together. They are well-informed pundits. Then, there are other people who don’t have as much depth and are more on the entertainment side of media, news, and analysis. I see it as a spectrum.
SF In academia and to get tenure, you’re supposed to publish all of this different material. Should there be a shift in what the emphasis is when evaluating a political scientist’s work?
VS You know where I’m coming from, and I’m going to lay out my bias. In academia, sometimes taking part in punditry is not only not rewarded, but actively looked down on. It’s something you don’t want anyone to find out about. Within the last six or seven years, it’s changing. There is no incentive system for public intellectuals. I prefer the term “public intellectual,” rather than “pundit” and “political analyst.” Pundit is something most people recognize, but “political analyst” is a nice wedding of two concepts; you analyze data, and the concept is rooted in politics, so you’re a political analyst. From talking to friends in academia, besides the media issue, some really big issues exist with tenure, in general. There have been so many changes to the tenure and publishing process; now there are calls and desires to re-think the tenure process. Then, add this layer of, “Well, what about the media sphere?” And I think there’s an even bigger push to want to reform the tenure process.
SF Does enough of the political science universe understand that there is a problem? Aren’t there a lot of people who think that this is the way it’s always been: publishing and the long delays that it takes to get something into the very few pieces of real estate in various academic journals? Is this a world that needs to wake up and realize that it needs change in some important ways?
There have been so many changes to the tenure and publishing process; now there are calls and desires to re-think the tenure process. Then, add this layer of, “Well, what about the media sphere?” And I think there’s an even bigger push to want to reform the tenure process.
VS It’s generational. But not only generational, because you have people, like Arthur Lupia and my mentor and friend John Aldrich, who are a different generation but they understand it. Perhaps the people who don’t see the need to change are of a different generation. The younger people see it because it’s a cutthroat process. Nowadays, you can’t even get a job interview without having published. When I came out of graduate school, I had one piece published, and still was able to eke that out. Now, it’s a whole different ballgame, compared to 20 or 30 years ago, when many people, who are making the tenure and hiring decisions for the young people, came up through the academy in a different system.
SF Let me go back to something you said earlier. You remarked that you were at this crossroads with Northwestern, and you decided to go toward a more full-time media life than an academia life. Was that necessarily a choice, and if it was a choice, do you regret having to make it? If you could, would you keep one foot in each of the worlds?
VS I don’t regret having to make it, but the prevailing model is you can’t have your cake and eat it too, which is what many folks told me. Also, I knew, “Okay, well this is the step I need to take, and I’m going to go for it, and I’m not going to expect anything from academia.” Because, I knew the feelings that were there; “If you’ve left, you’ve left.” I ended up moving to Texas; I married a Texan. I was just working on media. Through personal contacts, the LBJ School called me. They said, “Hey, can you teach an immigration grad seminar for us? We desperately need that.” I said, “Sure.” I didn’t want to go knocking on doors, because I didn’t want to put anybody in an awkward position. Later, they asked me to be a fellow at their Center for Government and Policy. Then, the director of the Center for Mexican-American Studies at University of Texas Contacted me. She said, “Oh, my God, we’d love for you to teach for us.” So I’ve ended up at this specific place where I have the best of both worlds, where I get my teaching, classroom, and university fix, which I still love, and to talk to really smart people, and go to events, and brown-bags, and also work in the media. So, God is great, and He set things up. At the time, my expectations were a black-and-white choice.
SF Do you think that you should be able to do both?
VS I do and I hope that one day, we, as a profession, will get there, and that this task force report helps us to make changes. It can be done in different circumstances. In my circumstance, it wasn’t possible at the time. I was an assistant professor at an R-1 university. Perhaps, if I were at a teaching college, or some other institution where there isn’t as much pressure to publish, that situation might be different. Maybe a non-R-1 institution would embrace this media work more.
SF Has your experience in media—interacting with journalists, other types of political professionals, and certainly candidates, and so on—influenced the way you teach and how you think about political science?
VS Absolutely, yes.
SF OK. Give me the pitch to a political scientist who thinks you’re a sell-out, who thinks that all of that media work doesn’t do anything for the classroom. What are the merits of that activity for teaching and for students?
VS Let’s think about it like medical or vet school. In the first two or three years you need that classroom learning as a base. Then, your last year, you’re hands-on; you’re cutting up animals because, ultimately, when you are in practice, you need to have that hands-on experience. We can translate that over to political science. At the end of the day, we need to understand how politicians really work, what a campaign looks like, what the dirty tricks and the black hands are, and what campaign consultants think about. We may do all this research on campaign ads, but what if we talk to Karl Rove and take him seriously? Why don’t we go and watch how a political commercial is filmed? You need both experiences. Do you want your doctor to have practiced on someone before they go in there and cut you, or you just don’t care if it’s all book learning?
SF Do students react to you differently as you became more prominent? If yes, how?
VS Oh, yes. They do. They’re young; they’re impressionable. They enjoy the real-world stories. I bring in real material. My husband is a lobbyist. He’s been in politics for over 20 years, so I don’t only hear stories from him, but I’m at those events, I’m at the conferences, I’m touching people, I’m talking to people. The students eat it up, all of the it. And they also really like the guest lecturers I bring to class. Back in 2007 and 2008, when Nate Silver still wasn’t that famous, but he was from Chicago, and I met him at a party, and asked, “Why don’t you come do a guest lecture for my class?” And Nate Silver comes to my class, and the students really enjoyed it. So, I leverage a different type of expertise in my courses. If you’re squirreled away in your office and you don’t leave that bubble world, you’re not going to bring the real world experience into the classroom. I know the students really enjoyed that layer. You can’t have a class of all guest lectures, but you can bring that in to highlight the material that you’ve provided.
SF What can APSA do to change the way that political scientists view the idea of being more forthright and more open with the public?
VS At the most general level, APSA can help build and serve as the bridge. And then, more specifically, APSA could help on a couple of different tasks. From the institutional perspective, APSA can help with reforming the tenure process to move away from a penalizing scholars for taking part these general media activities, to create a reward system for them. This change takes time when you have a system that’s been in place for decades, but APSA can help to change the incentive structure, broaden it, and widen it. It can also help coordinate some get-to-know-you events. Let’s host a roundtable with a couple of political scientists and a couple of political analysts or political consultants, and let’s talk to each other and start building relationships. Perhaps APSA can offer a database that journalists, political analysts, and practitioners can use. Suppose you’re looking for really interesting findings on the interpretations of negative ads? A journalist can turn to a database when preparing a story about Senator So-and-So’s negative attack ads and finds a with a short, layman’s blurb about the research. I see a huge role for APSA.
SF Okay. We haven’t talked about the NSF. Should the NSF be funding this type of work? And should political scientists expect to explain it better if they’re going to take government money?
VS Absolutely. I’ve received two NSF grants. Political science is a field of scientific inquiry; we do serious research. That said, we have done a horrible job of lobbying for it. Everybody lobbies. The Heart Association lobbies, tobacco lobbies, oil lobbies, the green coalition lobbies. Why don’t political scientists lobby? Lobbying isn’t only schmoozing; it’s talking to people. APSA should have a Day on the Hill, like the Chamber of Commerce has a Day on the Hill: gather some political scientists and take them to meet their Congress people. We need greater discourse between political scientists and government. Right now, we’re only playing defense, saying, “Please don’t keep attacking us.” My hope is that we’ll get over that hump, and then turn to offense. Any time your budget is subject to the government, whether it’s state level or federal level, you need to be always playing offense in your lobbying efforts.
Any time your budget is subject to the government, whether it’s state level or federal level, you need to be always playing offense in your lobbying efforts.
SF Is it ironic that political science focuses on politics and the art and science of communicating messages to the public and persuading them, and yet it seems so many of the people who study political science really don’t want to take part in it?
VS That doesn’t bother me. In the 1950s, political science went a little too far to the extreme of wanting to dictate what was good for politics, and that political science should be much more practical. When you get to that extreme, you start moving to the middle, and then, ultimately, to the other side. So, there’s a reason—an historical one--why this has happened. There is a place for everybody. For example, a colleague is just a wonderful, nice, and smart person, and his work is very applicable to contemporary politics. But, he could not handle talking to journalists or the media. He would rather crawl under a rock than go on TV. But he loves his work and that’s great. Let him do what he is good at; when I’ve had questions about politics, “This show, I’m going to talk about the presidency,” I’ll ping him. “Let me pick your brain.” He’s always more than happy to send me material and go through the research. Everybody I’ve ever pinged, even if I don’t know them well, they’re always happy to help. So, there are people who don’t like reaching out into the media sphere, or beyond academia, but how do we bring them in to tap their knowledge?
SF Any other thoughts?
VS This shift in focus is beginning to change, and I’m happy about it, and I’m excited to see it having institutional support.
SF All right, thank you so much for your time. I appreciate it.
VS You’re welcome.
