In this text, Benavides carries forward the academic issues raised in his first book, Making Ecuadorian Histories (Austin 2004); namely, the construction of history and its articulation with identity formation and hegemonic schemes in postcolonial settings. In turn, this work is part of a recent scholarly surge that focuses on the politics of racial identity, urban historiography and nation building in Ecuador. (See for example, F. Carrión and L. Hanley (eds.), Regeneración y Revitalización Urbana en las Américas, published in Quito in 2005; Nicola Foote's ‘Race, state and nation in early twentieth century Ecuador’, Nations and Nationalism, vol. 12, no. 2 (2006); E. Kingman, La Ciudad y los Otros (Quito, 2006); C. Townsend, Tales of Two Cities (Austin, 2000); E. Kingman et al., ‘Patrimonio, políticas de la memoria y “regeneración urbana”’, Íconos, no. 20 (2004)).
The Politics of Sentiment's project is to assess the ways in which sentiments, despite being commonly considered as part of the intimate sphere, are infused with social and political meanings and effects. Through the analysis of Medardo Ángel Silva's anguish-ridden life and poetry, his poems' widespread consumption through popular music, and contemporary representations of early-twentieth-century Guayaquil, the city where Silva lived and worked, Benavides addresses the following question: how is it that individual experiences, channelled through common sensibilities, produce an ambiguous identity that at the same time constitutes and challenges cultural hegemony? He argues that the pathetic feelings pervading Silva's works and contemporary Guayaquilean popular culture, despite their apparent escapist romanticism, convey social, racial and sexual contradictions silenced in official national representations. Identification with this longing and anguish provides for the expression of an identity characterised by self-rejection, which is at the crux of postcolonial forms of domination.
The author theoretically bridges the particular and experiential nature of sentiment with overarching and abstract notions of hegemony through an imaginative use of Raymond Williams's concept of ‘structures of feeling’, those common-sensibilities, usually beyond articulated thought, that a society shares at a given point in time and that interact in complex ways to give order and meaning to the world. Indeed, Benavides describes his work as ‘a concrete ethnographic case study of Williams' cultural hypothesis of ‘structures of feeling’ (p. 27). To analyse the structure of postcolonial identity, Benavides draws on the Lacanian concept of the Real, that structural core of the subject that is inaccessible to representation and understanding. Since this concept is ‘central in [Benavides's] thinking through the [argument]’ (p. x) and also a complex and dog-eared notion with competing interpretations in the literature, devoting a mere two short paragraphs to it in the introduction is clearly insufficient. The effect is that when ‘the Real’ is used in subsequent discussion, its sense is often cryptic and, consequently, void.
The book is divided in two sections. The first one ‘looks to understand the dynamic incorporation of the imaginary past into the daily lives of people in Guayaquil today’ (p. 26). It does so through an examination of the fascinating and tragic life of the Guayaquilean poet Miguel Ángel Silva and the sui generis manifestation in his work of the social, racial and sexual contradictions that marked his life (chapter one). Benavides argues that it is the sharing of these contradictions by present day Guayaquileans, that allows for such strong identification with Silva's lyrics, making them an important ‘hegemonic device’. Although this general argument is convincing, stating that Silva ‘crystallized’ hegemonic structures of feeling and ‘defined dominant social formations’ (p. 6, my emphasis) seems to overrate his influence, or that of any other Ecuadorean poet, by a wide mark. In chapter two, Benavides shows how official contemporary representations of Silva's city – the Guayaquil of the Liberal Revolution and the 1922 strikers' massacre – conceal these social tensions and evoke an idyllic past, effecting in complex ways the formation of an ambiguous Guayaquilean identity. While the chapter on Silva is thoroughly and empirically substantiated, this is not the case for the treatment of representations of Guayaquil's past. Here Benavides lost an opportunity to carry a much needed detailed cultural and historiographical reading of the emblematic urban transformations that Guayaquil is undergoing, a central aspect of the city's current identity formation; they are mentioned just in passing.
The second section of the book explores three locales where the structures of feeling evident in Silva's work become manifest in contemporary Guayaquilean popular culture: the consumption of Silva's poetry through the musical genre known as pasillo (chapter three); transnational migration to New York (chapter four); and national representations of Blackness (chapter five). This section abounds in perceptive insights and thought-provoking discussion. However, this mostly theoretical argument would have gained much if it had been accompanied by a detailed ethnographic description of the cases examined. Sweeping generalisations are often drawn from unrepresentative examples (the assertion ‘Latin American literary tradition [is] full of agency-filled women’ is supported by two examples: La Tigra, the film, and La Tigra, the short-story (p. 44)). Likewise, in chapter four, the author announces three ethnographic life-histories. The first one turns out to be an analysis of a literary character. In the second, some scant biographical details of Pedro are followed by Benavides's extended exegesis of the interviewee's motives and feelings; by the end of the section, Pedro has almost disappeared from the discussion.
The work presents other shortcomings common to a certain tradition in cultural studies: an abuse of jargon and, more seriously, the detachment of economic structures and political processes. The reader hardly appreciates how Benavides's Guayaquilians and their structures of feeling might relate to neoliberal restructuring, active social movements and their cultural politics, political instability, the lively dynamics of regionalism and decentralisation, the collapse and resurgence of the oil-economy, hardened migration policies, populist revival or the spill-overs of Plan Colombia. Moreover, it is unclear how these hegemonic mechanisms of domination that Benavides describes matter when it comes to the control of labour, the politics of (under)development, or the establishment of a consumerist economy.
Benavides affirms ‘I strongly believe in the advantages afforded to me [in my anthropological undertaking] by my Ecuadorian identity and by my having lived in Ecuador for over ten years as a full-fledged “native”’ (p. 120). Certainly, the self-reflective character of this book is one of its virtues. On the other hand, on the grounds of this ‘nativeness’ the author seems to ask us to take his opinions and interpretations as arguments and ethnographic evidence. One only laments that the many issues this book raises about the constitution of postcolonial identities are not accompanied and supported by the substantive and detailed description that gives anthropology its distinctive character.
