Computational Thinking in Sound: Teaching the Art and Science of Music and Technology is a very detailed case study of a collaborative teaching experiment funded by the National Science Foundation and employed to great success by the authors at the University of Massachusetts Lowell.
The book presents an exciting learning paradigm, something devolved and open, with shared resources and transparency of method. The departments of Music and Computer Science at UML cooperated with the aim of fostering ‘computational thinking’. Computational thinking is that mystic grail of understanding where students are able to create problems from basic scenarios and find solutions using the logic of computational thinking. The course offered by the authors was called ‘Sound Thinking’ which began in the spring of 2009 and was initially documented through conferences on computing and education. Whilst the course is offered as ‘general education’ at UML, this kind of interdisciplinary collaboration will be familiar to educational professionals worldwide. As British institutions re-imagine research-led teaching and seek more liberal educational paths, staff are encouraged to create more cross-disciplinary links, and draw out skills of analysis and problem solving, creative deployment, entrepreneurship and innovation.
The book begins by defining key concepts, such as computational thinking in a creative environment and the idea of a ‘hybrid’ course, one offered equally as an option in both departments. Central chapters outline key components of the ‘Sound Thinking’ course including music and lyric analysis through flow charts, ‘found sound’ exploration from individual play to generalised and performable graphic scores, and finally, construction of simple computer programs using MIT's Scratch software (downloadable for Windows and Macintosh via Adobe AIR but also with a fully functional web-based interface at http://scratch.mit.edu/). The last few chapters of the book look at how methods may be translated to other institutions and disciplines, providing inspiration for educators interested in moving from traditional one-to-many delivery to something more fluid.
Where collaborative learning is set out as an agenda in itself, it is normally deeply frustrating. Here it seems the authors used their own computational thinking to build and modify the course over the years. Interactions may appear a trifle ‘populist’ at times, with students blogging, peer-reviewing and self-learning. However, the quoted student feedback suggests this is a model well worthy of investigation. It is clearly time-consuming for staff in the initial stages but this too was documented in such a way as to be inspiring, not traumatic. For anyone familiar with (music) technology, some of the aims seemed a little simplistic. However, as a computer user from a generation where file-names were less than eight characters and the suffix was (and remains) three characters, I can completely vouch for the need to educate students in the necessity of structure when it comes to files, folders, functions, loops, abstractions and other more complex program schematics. Computers are currently marketed at a ‘My Documents’ generation yet as soon as one does anything remotely complex, the structure of a problem is best mirrored within the programming environment itself lest the power of the software become obscured by some superficial beauty.
It was particularly useful to note the authors’ use of open source and free software. This is vital for interdisciplinary studies, not least because most departments, no matter how cross-facing, have individual budgets. The two main programmes that are discussed are Audacity, used when dealing with found sounds and students’ personal tracks, and Scratch, dealing with notes and graphics. It is also useful to note that whilst social media can help bridge physical distances, the team recognised the enduring power of face-to-face classes and meetings in order to maintain a strong and worthwhile sense of community. It was amusing to read that the Computer Science and Music buildings were about 1.5 miles apart, necessitating careful timetabling of joint classes but always a ‘drive’.
Amongst numerous nuggets of experiential data and case study documentation were the clear benefits for the teaching team including inter-faculty understanding, shared research presentations (building an important arts-science bridge) and – considering this practice is not yet commonplace – novelty value. Top tips for added teaching value included the production of a score by student A who, thinking they would then perform it to the class, saw it given to student B, thereby revealing all the hidden rules of thumb not yet set down on paper.
Where I was disappointed with this book was its lack of focus upon the sonic results of students’ explorations and how this most important (the most important) aural phenomenon did not seem to be the key driver for computational thinking. Perhaps this is just too tricky to implement; perhaps it is something that arises through initially considering music to be a problem; perhaps music itself is too complex to worry about when the aim is something more holistic. Admittedly the book avoids pigeon-holing itself into any particular musical genre. However, computational thinking did at times seem to dictate creative musical practice. Whilst mapping electrical resistance to note-number introduced the students to algorithmic composition using ‘Scratch’, the ‘tool’ and ‘process’ centricity was overwhelming.
This book clearly resonates with the American education system. However, European practice is changing rapidly and breadth is occupying territory once solely given over to depth. I suspect priorities of education come and go with the politicians that dream them up. Luckily I do not see any sign of ‘struggle’ or ‘working against the system’ here, and the product (students that have understood their experience and are highly satisfied with their teaching and learning) is clearly a testament to a solid idea, delivered with consummate expertise and enthusiasm.
The authors mention repeatedly the amount of time required to foresee problems during the conception of the course, document process, feedback to students, prepare materials and grade submissions. Any and all positive job satisfaction should be viewed in this light. The final paragraph of the book reads ‘taking an interdisciplinary approach to computing and music will yield opportunities for you and your students to make multiple connections to music and computing content, to other areas of interest, and, most important, to other people. As you already know, it is easier than ever to connect with people, places, and things. It is our hope that the information in this book helps to make those connections more meaningful for you and your students and opens up new possibilities and ways of thinking.’ It most certainly did. Now I just need to find the time!
Extracts from the book are available via googlebooks and further details are available at the project's website http://www.performamatics.org.
