Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T00:32:20.955Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Surface temperature heterogeneity and secondary circulations in steady stably stratified Ekman layers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2026

Thijs Bon*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, KU Leuven , Celestijnenlaan, 300 – box 2421, B-3001 Leuven, Belgium
Raúl Bayoán Cal
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Portland State University, Portland, OR 97201, USA
Johan Meyers
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, KU Leuven , Celestijnenlaan, 300 – box 2421, B-3001 Leuven, Belgium
*
Corresponding author: Thijs Bon, thijs.bon@kuleuven.be

Abstract

The impact of spanwise surface temperature heterogeneity on steady stably stratified Ekman layers is systematically studied using large-eddy simulation (LES). Spanwise varying strips of high and low surface temperature are imposed in idealised LES of stable boundary layers (SBLs), in which a steady state results from a balance between cooling at the ground and heating due to imposed synoptic subsidence. Consistent with previous studies on channel flows with streamwise-aligned surface heterogeneity (e.g. Bon & Meyers, J. Fluid Mech. 2022, pp. 1–38), large-scale secondary circulations develop and extend deep into the stable Ekman layer. Coriolis effects enhance counterclockwise circulations while reducing clockwise ones, thereby tilting the mean secondary flow structures towards the left (in the northern hemisphere). Nevertheless, for the considered surface temperature contrasts of 1.5–12 K and spanwise wavelengths of 100–800 m, the impact on mean SBL structure is substantial. As the surface temperature difference or strip width increases, secondary flows and dispersive fluxes strengthen, eventually reaching the top of the SBL. This augmentation further enhances near-surface gradients, elevates SBL depths and low-level jets, and reduces mean surface heat fluxes. Novel correlations between characteristics of the surface heterogeneity and their impact on the mean SBL structure are proposed. Moreover, the local surface fluxes are shown to significantly deviate from the mean, highlighting that horizontally averaged SBL properties do not capture all important physical processes in a heterogeneous flow. Overall, this work affirms that thermal surface heterogeneity is a crucial factor in governing transport processes within the atmospheric stable boundary layer.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the formation of secondary circulations over different types of spanwise surface heterogeneity with length scale $\lambda _y\approx \delta _o$. (a) Strip-type roughness heterogeneity generating Prandtl’s secondary flows of the second kind (Anderson et al.2015), with downwdrafts of ‘turbulence-poor’ fluid above the relatively high-roughness region, $z_0^H$, and updrafts above the relatively low roughness region, $z_0^L$. (b) Thermally induced secondary flows resulting from buoyancy differences between strips with relatively high ($\theta _s^H$) and low ($\theta _s^L$) surface temperature, as recently studied by Salesky, Calaf & Anderson (2022), Bon & Meyers (2022) and the present work. The high and low momentum pathways (HMPs and LMPs) of the mean flow, directed inside the plane, are indicated by green and red areas.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic figure of the studied stably stratified Ekman layer with heterogeneous surface temperature. Green and red lines illustrate mean profiles of horizontal wind speed $\langle M\rangle$ and potential temperature $\langle \theta \rangle$, where $G$ indicates the geostrophic wind vector and $\phi _G$ the geostrophic angle. Further, $h_\theta$ denotes the thermal boundary-layer depth and $\varDelta _z\theta$ the vertical temperature difference of the SBL. Red and blue strips at the surface illustrate respective high- and low-temperature patches, with surface temperature contrast $\varDelta _y\theta$ and wavelength $\lambda _y$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Weighting functions for geostrophic damping (blue) and Rayleigh damping (red). The values for geostrophic damping $A_{k,d}$ are given by (2.6) with $H_d=300$ m and $\varDelta _d=100$ m, whereas the Rayleigh function is $A_{k,R} = 1-\cos [\pi /2 (z_k-H_R)/(L_z-H_R)]$ with $H_R$ the height where the Rayleigh damping layer starts (Lanzilao & Meyers 2023). For ease of comparison, we set $H_R=H_d-0.3\varDelta _d$ here.

Figure 3

Table 1.Overview of physical and simulation parameters that are common for all simulations in the present paper.

Figure 4

Table 2.Overview of simulations and bulk quantities. The heterogeneous surface temperature is defined by the characteristic wavelength $\lambda _y$ and surface temperature contrast $\varDelta _y\theta$, or the corresponding dimensionless Rossby and buoyancy number $\textit{Ro}_y, \textit{Bu}_y$. Simulations are further distinguished by the surface roughness $z_0$ or surface Rossby number $\textit{Ro}_0$. Reported internal flow parameters are the horizontally averaged surface shear stress $\tau _w$, heat flux $q_0$ thermal boundary-layer depth $h_\theta$ and stability indicator $h_\theta /L_O$, where $L_O = -\theta _r\tau _w^{3/2}/(\kappa g q_0)$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Mean profiles of (a) wind speed normalised by geostrophic value, (b) flow angle with respect to surface wind, (c) potential temperature deviation relative to vertical temperature difference, (d) normalised total vertical shear stress and (e) normalised total vertical heat flux for cases with varying heterogeneity wavelength $\lambda _y$. Darker lines indicate larger $\lambda _y$, while blue and red colours refer to simulations with $z_0=10^{-1}$ m and $z_0=10^{-3}$ m, respectively. Profiles are normalised by the thermal boundary layer height and surface fluxes from case R3-hom.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Illustrative example of triple decomposition of streamwise velocity field in case R3-L2-T3. Red and blue patches indicate high and low surface temperature, respectively. The top row illustrates the classic Reynolds decomposition $u = \overline {u} + u'$, whereas the bottom row reveals the decomposition of $\overline {u}$ into a horizontal mean $\langle \overline {u}\rangle$ and dispersive part $\overline {u}''$. Figure inspired by Wangsawijaya et al. (2020, figure 3).

Figure 7

Figure 6.Cross-stream planes of streamwise velocity deviation $\langle \overline {u}-\langle \overline {u}\rangle _{xy}\rangle _x$, averaged over time and the streamwise direction. (a–d) Cases R3-L1-T3, R3-L2-T3, R3-L4-T3, R3-L8-T3. Vectors are obtained from the dispersive in-plane velocity components $\overline {v}'', \overline {w}''$, while red and blue patches at the bottom correspond to high and low surface temperature. The red contour traces the line where the vertical temperature gradient is 0.

Figure 8

Figure 7.(a, b) Decomposition of (a) vertical momentum and (b) heat flux into dispersive (full lines) and turbulent (dashed lines) parts for cases with $\lambda _y=100$ and 800 m and the homogeneous reference cases. Line colours are similar to figure 4. All cases are normalised by their respective surface heat ($q_0$) and momentum fluxes ($\tau _w$) and thermal boundary layer height $h_\theta$. (c, d) Square root of normal stresses of (c) streamwise velocity and (d) potential temperature variance, decomposed in dispersive and turbulent parts.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Mean profiles of (a) wind speed normalised by geostrophic value, (b) flow angle with respect to surface wind, (c) potential temperature deviation relative to vertical temperature difference, (d) normalised total vertical shear stress and (e) normalised total vertical heat flux for cases with varying surface temperature contrast. Darker lines indicate larger $\varDelta _y\theta$, while blue and red colours refer to simulations with $z_0=10^{-1}$ m and $z_0=10^{-3}$ m, respectively. Profiles are normalised by the thermal boundary layer height and surface fluxes from case R3-hom.

Figure 10

Figure 9.(a, b) Decomposition of (a) vertical momentum and (b) heat flux into dispersive (full lines) and turbulent (dashed lines) parts for cases with $\varDelta _y\theta =1.5$ and $9$ K and the homogeneous reference cases. Line colours are similar to figure 8. All cases are normalised by their respective surface heat ($q_0$) and momentum fluxes ($\tau _w$) and thermal boundary layer height $h_\theta$. (c, d) Square root of normal stresses of (c) streamwise velocity and (d) potential temperature variance, decomposed in dispersive and turbulent parts.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Blending height $z_b$ for all R2 ($z_0=10^{-3}$ m, red) and R3 ($z_0=10^{-1}$ m, blue) simulations with varying surface temperature difference (square markers) and changing heterogeneity length scale (round markers). Colours are identical to the figures in the previous section, with darker colour indicating a higher value of $\varDelta _y\theta$ or $\lambda _y$. Panel (a) shows $z_b$ as function of $\lambda _y$, whereas in panel (b), both are scaled with the SBL depth $h_\theta$ of each simulation. The grey dashed line in panel (b) represents $0.4(\lambda _y/h_\theta )^{1/2}$.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Scaling of (a, b) mean surface heat flux, (c) shear stress and (d) SBL depth of simulations with changing spanwise surface temperature heterogeneity and surface roughness, normalised by values from the corresponding homogeneous case. The horizontal axes of panels (a) and (b–d) respectively represent the heterogeneity parameter and a modified heterogeneity Richardson number, defined in (3.1). Squares (circles) symbolise simulation sets with with varying surface temperature contrast (heterogeneity length scale), while blue and red indicate simulations with higher (R3) and lower (R2) surface roughness.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Time- and streamwise-averaged distributions of (a) surface shear stress, (b) heat flux and (c) stability parameter (i.e. the ratio between SBL depth and Obukhov length) for simulation with spanwise heterogeneous surface temperature of varying strip width, normalised by results from the homogeneous case. Darker blue colours indicate cases with larger $\lambda _y$. The spanwise coordinate is scaled with $\lambda _y$ and centred around a hot patch, indicated by the grey background. Dashed horizontal lines represent the mean of each simulation.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Same as figure 12, but for simulations with different surface temperature contrast where darker blue lines represent larger $\varDelta _y\theta$. The spanwise coordinate here is centred around the centre of the domain, and the entire width of the computational domain is shown. Grey shaded areas indicate warm strips.

Figure 15

Table 3.Difference in mean quantities between coarse- and fine-grid simulations (denoted by -fine), and one case with horizontal domain size (-Lxy2). Considered variables are plane-averaged surface wall shear stress $\tau _w$, heat flux $q_0$ and SBL depth $h_\theta$. The relative error is defined as $\delta [\chi ] = (\chi _f-\chi _c)/\chi _c$, where $\chi _f$ refers to the value from the simulations with the finer grid and $\chi _c$ to the coarser-grid simulation results given in table 2.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Mean profiles of (a) wind speed normalised by geostrophic value, (b) flow angle, (c) potential temperature deviation relative to vertical temperature difference, (d) normalised total vertical shear stress and (e) normalised total vertical heat flux for cases with the different grid resolution and surface roughness (see table 2). Lines with lighter colours represent cases with finer resolution. Profiles are normalised by the thermal boundary layer height and surface fluxes from case R3-L2-T3.

Figure 17

Figure 15.Decomposition of (a, c) vertical momentum and (b, d) heat flux into dispersive (full lines) and turbulent (dashed lines) parts. (c, d) Zoom of the top panels, with the turbulent flux further split into the resolved (dashed) and subgrid-scale (dash-dotted lines) contributions. Line colours are equal to figure 14. All cases are normalised by the surface heat fluxes and boundary-layer depth from case R3-L2-T3.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Time- and streamwise-averaged distributions of (a) surface shear stress and (b) heat flux for simulation with different resolution. Line colours are equal to figure 14. The spanwise coordinate is scaled with $\lambda _y$ and centred around the central cold strip in the domain. Grey shaded areas indicate the location of warm strips, while dashed horizontal lines represent the mean of each simulation. The profiles are normalised by mean surface fluxes from case R3-L2-T3.

Figure 19

Figure 17.Mean profiles of (a) wind speed, (b) flow angle, (c) potential temperature, (d) total vertical shear stress and (e) total vertical heat flux for homogeneous and heterogeneous simulations with Coriolis force (blue) or streamwise pressure forcing (noC, red). Darker lines are simulations with spanwise varying surface temperature, while lighter lines indicate simulations with a uniform ground. All profiles are normalised by the reference values from case R3-hom. In panel (a), the $x$- and $y$-components of the wind speed are displayed by dashed and dash-dotted lines, while the full lines represent total wind magnitude.

Figure 20

Figure 18.Comparison of $yz$-planes from simulations with heterogeneous surface temperature driven by (a, c) geostrophic forcing and Coriolis force and (b, d) streamwise pressure gradient. (a, b) Instantaneous streamwise velocity at $x=0$ (see supplementary material for movies of potential temperature field). (c, d) Streamwise- and time-averaged dispersive streamwise velocity fluctuation $\langle \overline {u}''\rangle _x =\langle \overline {u} - \langle \overline {u}\rangle _{xy}\rangle _x$. Streamlines indicate the direction of in-plane velocity $(\overline {v},\overline {w})$, where it should be noted that the magnitude of these motions cannot be inferred from the figure. Red and blue patches below $z=0$ indicate high and low temperature, while the thick red contours trace the points where the temperature gradient is 0.

Figure 21

Figure 19.Decomposition of (a) vertical momentum and (b) heat flux into dispersive (full lines), turbulent (dashed lines) and subgrid-scale (dash-dotted lines) parts. Line colours are equal to figure 17. All cases are normalised by their respective surface heat ($q_0$) and momentum fluxes ($u_*^2$) and thermal boundary layer height $h_\theta$.

Figure 22

Figure 20.Square root of normal stresses of (a–c) velocity components and (d) temperature variance. Full lines indicate dispersive parts, while dashed lines indicate the turbulent Reynolds stresses. Line colours are identical to figure 17. The vertical coordinate is normalised by the respective thermal boundary layer height $h_\theta$ of each case. Normal stresses and temperature variance are normalised by the nominal geostrophic wind speed $G$ and spanwise surface temperature difference $\varDelta _y\theta$ of case R3-L2-T3.

Supplementary material: File

Bon et al. supplementary movie 1

Movie Theta yz Cross-stream movie of potential temperature flow in case R3-L2-T3
Download Bon et al. supplementary movie 1(File)
File 879.1 KB
Supplementary material: File

Bon et al. supplementary movie 2

Movie Theta yz noCor Cross-stream movie of potential temperature flow in case R3-L2-T3-noC
Download Bon et al. supplementary movie 2(File)
File 789.5 KB
Supplementary material: File

Bon et al. supplementary movie 3

Movie Theta xz stable Streamwise movie of potential temperature flow in case R3-L2-T3 over an unstable (warm) patch
Download Bon et al. supplementary movie 3(File)
File 1.3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Bon et al. supplementary movie 4

Movie Theta xz unstable Streamwise movie of potential temperature flow in case R3-L2-T3 over an unstable (warm) patch
Download Bon et al. supplementary movie 4(File)
File 1.2 MB