Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T17:12:26.738Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Variable payout annuities and dynamic portfolio choice in retirement

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 January 2009

WOLFRAM J. HORNEFF
Affiliation:
Finance Department, Goethe University Frankfurt
RAIMOND H. MAURER
Affiliation:
Finance Department, Goethe University Frankfurt
OLIVIA S. MITCHELL
Affiliation:
The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania
MICHAEL Z. STAMOS
Affiliation:
Finance Department, Goethe University Frankfurt
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Many retirees hope to continue earning capital market rewards on their saving while avoiding outliving their funds during retirement. We model a dynamic utility maximizing investor who seeks to benefit from holding both equity and longevity insurance. She is free to adjust her portfolio allocation of her financial wealth as well as of the annuity over time, and she can purchase variable payout annuities any time and incrementally. In this setting, we show that the retiree will not fully annuitize even without bequests; rather, she will combine variable annuities with withdrawals from her liquid financial wealth so as to match her desired consumption profile. Optimal stock exposures decrease over time, both within the variable annuity and the withdrawal plan. Welfare gains from this strategy can amount to 40% of financial wealth, depending on risk parameters and other resources; additionally, many retirees will do almost as well as the fully optimized outcome if they hold variable annuities invested 60/40 in stocks/bonds.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2009
Figure 0

Fig. 1.Payment percentiles for alternative asset allocations in the annuity and varying Assumed Interest Rates (AIRs)This illustration assumes an initial premium of $100,000 and survival probabilities from the US 1996 Annuity 2000 mortality table for females; computations are based on equation (5). Panel (a): Yearly real annuity fund returns for the 60 (100)% stock allocation are i.i.d. log-normal with mean 4.4 (6)% and standard deviation 10.8 (18)%. The real riskless rate and the AIR (Assumed Interest Rate) are set to 2 and 4%, respectively. Panel (b): The annuity fund is assumed to be invested in a 60/40 stock bond portfolio with the mean 4.4% and standard deviation 10.8%; the AIR is set to 2, 4, and 6%, respectively.

Figure 1

Fig. 2.Illustrative optimal dynamic positions in stocks, bonds, and variable payout annuities: variations by age and cash on handThese figures represent optimal policies which vary as a function of cash on hand (W) and age; in all panels, no prior annuitization is assumed (L=0). In Panel (a), the age-65 retiree with cash on hand W=6 would spend 90% of her cash on annuities and the rest to financial investments (Panel (b)). Her optimal stock fraction is 100% within the variable annuity (Panel (c)) as well as in financial wealth (Panel (d)).

Notes: Calculations are based on backward optimization of the value function given in (15). The retiree has CRRA utility with ρ=5, β=0.96, and no bequest motive (k=0). Survival probabilities are from the US 1996 Annuity 2000 mortality table for females to price annuities and from the corresponding population mortality table to calculate utility. Yearly real stock returns are i.i.d. log-normal distributed with the mean 6% and standard deviation 18%. The real interest rate and the AIR are set to 2 and 4%, respectively.
Figure 2

Fig. 3.Illustrative optimal stock fractions in the combined annuity and financial wealth portfoliosThese figures represent the relationship between the retiree's age and the optimal stock fraction in her combined annuity and financial asset holdings. The latter is defined as the stock fraction of her expected annuity wealth PV (the present value of remaining expected annuity payouts ) plus the stock fraction of her financial wealth S, as a percent of financial plus annuity wealth (πsS+πaPV)/(S+PV). Panel (a) shows how this stock fraction varies with age and cash on hand W; Panel (b) shows how it varies with age and pre-existing annuity payments L. In both panels, no prior annuitization is assumed (L=0).

Note: See Figure 2 for calculation details.
Figure 3

Fig. 4.Dispersion of annuity, total stock, and consumption paths: base casePanel (a) depicts the dispersion of the annuitized fraction of wealth PV/(S+PV) as it varies with age; panel (b) reports similar age-dispersion percentiles for the stock fraction of the combined annuity and financial wealth portfolios [=(πsS+πaPV)/(S+PV)]. Panel (c) shows similar dispersion for consumption, measured as a multiple of pension income.

Notes: See Figure 2 for details. Computations are based on 100,000 Monte Carlo simulations using the optimal policies from Figure 3 and initial wealth of 5 times pension income (S0=5).
Figure 4

Fig. 5.Impact of changing the AIR on (a) the expected share of financial wealth, (b) total stock share, and (c) consumption. This figure depicts the results from solving the optimization problem in (15) for AIRs (Assumed Interest Rates) of 2%, 4%, and 6% respectively.

Note: See Figure 4 for details.
Figure 5

Table 1.Required increase (in %) in financial wealth to make a retiree indifferent between the specified phased withdrawal strategy versus gaining access to variable payout annuities: impact of different preferences, initial financial wealth, and assumed interest rates (AIR)