In the late 1990s, critiques of ‘development’ as an international project highlighted the underlying power relations in discourses and practices of development and argued that rather than reforming development, the whole enterprise should be abandoned. These critiques, often classified under the umbrella term of ‘post-development’, included The Development Dictionary edited by Wolfgang Sachs (Reference Sachs1992) and Arturo Escobar's Encountering Development (Reference Escobar1995). While the examination of the discursive power and strategies embedded in Western-led development in the post-World War Two period was revealing, the post-development agenda was often criticised for lacking feasible alternatives, other than rather vague appeals to focus on ‘the local’ (see, for example, Corbridge Reference Corbridge1998).
In this new book, Gustavo Esteva, one of the contributors to The Development Dictionary, and his co-authors Salvatore Babones and Philipp Babcicky aim to set out an alternative to development, which focuses on human flourishing and wellbeing. Thus, the book, which has the subtitle ‘A Radical Manifesto’ involves not just critique, but also calls to action. As they state in the introduction, ‘It is not our goal to sow despair. It is our goal to challenge and inspire’ (p. vii). This is a very welcome opening to a book which will have a wide audience among students, activists and development scholars. However, overall in presenting a ‘radical manifesto’ the book often lacks depth of analysis and has a tendency towards generalisations which undermine the book's usefulness for teaching.
The book consists of seven chapters; Chapters 1, 2 and 4 provide overviews of the post-war development agenda, the role of data and statistics in constructing development problems and solutions and the environmental limits of present development practice. While much of this is familiar from earlier post-development publications, as well as a wide range of development textbooks, the authors elucidate the contradictions in development approaches very effectively. This is particularly effective in the statistics discussion on GDP growth and life expectancy. I also appreciated the concept of the ‘three Saches of development’ as a way of classifying development approaches – Goldman Sachs for neo-liberal hegemony; Jeffrey Sachs for philanthropic capitalism and ‘do-gooding’; and Wolfgang Sachs for post-development (pp. 22–4).
Chapters 3, 5, 6 and 7 provide perspectives on the alternatives to the cult of growth which are being driven by social movements from the bottom up. The authors are keen to consider what is actually happening, rather than envisaging the world as it could be. However, there are only brief glimpses of these alternatives and they include the Zapatistas and Via Campesina, organisations which have already been frequently cited in discussions of alternatives to mainstream neo-liberal development.
Where the discussion of alternatives is more successful is in discussing bottom-up development and the ‘the recovery of verbs’ (p. 101). Drawing on the concept of ‘buen vivir’ (‘living well’), which has emerged in countries such as Ecuador and Peru with large indigenous populations, the focus is on individual and collective action in relation to eating, learning, healing, settling and knowing. This contrasts with the construction of needs, such as ‘education’, ‘healthcare’ and ‘housing’, which are often seen as requiring fulfilment through the operation of the state or market. This is an important argument, and it is good to see that the authors are introducing some nuance into the debate by, for example, not wholeheartedly rejecting ‘Western’ medical intervention in favour of ‘traditional’ healing, but considering the realities of the lives of millions of economically poor residents who lack access to high quality ‘Western’ medical facilities and treatment. However, the lack of depth of analysis or information about the source of data (for example the claims about school dropout rates on page 104) is frustrating.
For Esteva et al., it is the local scale which is key in considering alternatives to development. They argue that, ‘Indigenous nations provide a ready-made model of localization’ (p. 114), and propose a form of ‘juridical pluralism’ (p. 56) that would allow for collective rights and local accountability (p. 126). While they are keen to state that this is not an attempt to reinstate some romantic vision of the past, but rather to deal with what is happening now, there is very little engagement with the tensions and fractures that can occur within local communities. While power is discussed in relation to North–South relations or with regard to multinational companies, the local operation of power within communities is ignored. There is also little consideration of how these local entities fit together within broader contexts or structures. There are hints, such as suggestions of ‘an Africa of regions’, rather than one of states (p. 125), but these ideas are not followed through.
In the epilogue, the authors address readers in the Global North directly in responding to the question ‘How can I help?’ (p. 149). I found this section particularly refreshing and certainly one which challenges the reader to consider their own position within global economic, social and political networks. Their answer to the question is to help ‘at home’ through campaigning and changing consumption practices. Going to the Global South as a responsible tourist is viewed as much more helpful than travelling as a development worker to ‘do good’, although they do relent and say that ‘If you must work in the field, work to support self-determination and the autonomous projects of self-organizing communities’ (p. 152). This concrete advice is welcome progress from the post-development critiques of the 1990s, but the continued focus on harmonious local communities remains unconvincing in laying out an alternative path to human wellbeing.
