This is in one sense a celebratory volume, marking the 150th anniversary of Housman's birth and recognizing his iconic status. However, the contributors mostly step back from reverence and instead take the opportunity given by the passage of time to assess Housman's methods and influence and to use published and unpublished letters and marginalia to track and debate how his mind worked. The book is divided into three sections, preceded by Stray's introduction, which includes outline biographical information, places Housman in the history of scholarship, and suggests that awareness of his techniques of self-presentation is essential for analysis of his scholarship.
The first section of the book is the longest, with seven essays on Housman's treatment of Latin authors. Many of these go beyond their immediate remit. All contain illuminating observations and evaluations of Housman's achievements. The prominent linking aspects to this section are the additional primary evidence used to probe Housman's working methods, comment on how his acerbic treatment of others sometimes impeded further work on areas he had made his own, and consideration of the distances between textual and literary criticism. Heyworth uses Housman's approach to Propertius as a spring-board for an essay that ranges skilfully between discussion of detail (including unpublished marginalia) and assessment of Housman's lack of historical interest in manuscript tradition. He also looks for possible connections between ‘A Shropshire Lad’ (1896) and Housman's Propertian agonies, concluding that while Housman's poem may have provided diversion, his creative work has greater resonances with Horace (25). Courtney's discussion of Housman's Manilius is especially valuable for its close reading of the language used by Housman to attack other scholars (the moral aspects are interestingly related to the language of the Authorized version of the Bible (32)). The criticism of Housman's Manilius is finely drawn, recognizing that richness of content is only partial compensation for the lack of dispassion and the self-presentation of the editor's superiority (41). The theme of the cult of Housman and the adverse effect exerted by his aggression is taken up by Nisbet in his discussion of Housman's Juvenal (45). Nisbet also points out Housman's lack of citation of other scholars (59). Oakley contributes a positive evaluation of Housman's work on Lucan. Like Heyworth, he makes use of evidence from letters and adds insights on Housman's relationship with Fraenkel. Williams' essay is convincing on the originality of Housman's approach to Ovid (95) and also demonstrates the importance of the long-term work that is increasingly difficult for the scholars of today (104). Essays by Butterfield and Reeve cover additional topics, dealing with metre, prosody and the few examples of verse composition (Butterfield) and the scope of Housman's editorial work (Reeve). Reeve is particularly interesting on what mss. can yield beyond the recovery of the author's text (147) and on the importance of Housman's attempt to use a full range of the serviceable manuscripts (with the inevitable difficulties caused by lack of travel grants and indeed of the digitization that is enabling various aspects of textual scholarship today).
The second section focuses on Housman and his contemporaries. It pinpoints contrasts in the aims of scholarship and in the conditions in which it was pursued. Stray's essay uses Housman's dispute with Jebb over the text of Bacchylides to explore the ‘conflict of intellectual and cultural styles, of institutional locations and of generations’ (155–6) and to explain the impact of journals on late nineteenth-century controversies (including the rôle of behind the scenes editorial mediation). Stray also considers why Housman failed to graduate at Oxford (‘a Cambridge man who went to the wrong place’ (164)). Hopkinson's study of Housman and Postgate includes a telling comparison between the aims and content of their inaugural lectures and some speculation on the development of Classics in Cambridge had Postgate and not Housman been appointed to the Chair of Latin (186). Butterfield's essay on Housman and Lindsay compares the biographies of the two men and also provides insights into the conditions that made deep and extensive scholarship possible (e.g. long study of the languages at school as well as university; consolidation of school work in early years of Lit. Hum. at Oxford; opportunity for Scottish students to add Oxford study to their Scottish degrees; lack of administrative responsibilities — to this might sometimes be added bachelor status). The essays by Lehnus and Leach make extensive use of Housman's correspondence. The former focuses on Housman's links with the papyrologist A. S. Hunt and demonstrates Housman's prowess in Greek. Leach provides insights into the hinterland revealed in Housman's letters, pointing out that he comparatively rarely initiated academic correspondence. Lehnus includes examples of Housman's less vitriolic side as well as throwing in a fascinating aside on the allegedly ‘Rabelaisian’ character of some letters that were destroyed (229).
The title of the third section, ‘Legacy’, is slightly unfortunate since it veers away from sharp assessment of Housman's influence and authority, both of which are well embedded and more critically treated in the previous two sections. This inevitably makes the section slighter. Luck's essay does, however, usefully place Housman in relation to his predecessors as well as providing details on the acceptance or otherwise of his conjectures, while the essays by Kenney and Diggle provide revealing and no doubt ironic insights into scholarly games and Housman relics respectively.
Taken as a whole, the volume displays an impressive combination of examples, evaluation and investigation of the historical contexts of scholarship. This alone would make it essential reading for graduate students and others who need to understand what textual criticism involves, why it matters and how it might be used in wider research and in teaching. However, its importance goes further. Taken together, the essays provide a window into the processes of scholarship past and present, including the tensions between search for truth and the human foibles that condition its definition and communication. Important questions are raised about the nature of interaction between scholars, their sites and modes of disagreement, the oppositions and overlaps between national traditions, and the time-scales needed for judgements to be made about the extent of influence and assimilation. These make the book a valuable document in itself for the history of scholarship. Publication comes at a crucial time for Classics, when the relationship between different specialisms is more important than ever in ensuring the coherence and perhaps the survival of the discipline. The collection should provoke serious thought among current practitioners about the differences between the academic environments of Housman, his immediate successors and those of today. How can debate (and disagreement) best be conducted in order to ensure critical ‘edge’ without discouraging continuing investigation of contentious questions? What are the best ways of maximizing communication between successive generations of scholars without narrowing the base (national, social, gender, institutional)? How, in an age when digital communication has largely superseded letters, will sources that elucidate the hinterlands of scholars be preserved? How, in effect, will future historians of scholarship frame and execute their investigations?
