Tara Povey's Social Movements in Egypt and Iran is a succinct and clear book that retraces the political history of two central Middle Eastern countries through the lens of political contention and protest. It is thus a useful book for students of the region trying to make sense of the contemporary mass mobilizations that have shaken the two countries, as well as those looking for an introduction to and further references on these two cases.
Povey makes the case for the use of controlled comparison for understanding contemporary politics in the Middle East. The author shows that systematic comparison allows us to successfully disentangle what is specific to each case (i.e., what is contingent to each historical development) and what is common to them (and probably many others), thus revealing macroprocesses such as contemporary imperialism or neoliberal economic policies that go beyond the specificity of Egyptian or Iranian politics (or, for that matter, “Middle Eastern” politics). The book also challenges common narratives about social movements in the region by normalizing them, thus moving away from the “Arab exception” bias.
Povey demonstrates clearly that modern repertoires of protest are not essentially European and that they have been present in the region for at least the past two centuries. She refutes the all-too-easy binaries between Muslim and secular, modernist and traditionalist, as well as radical and reformist, showing instead the fluidity of such notions.
The author proceeds to historicize movements—to analyze “sectors of the reform movement in Iran and the groups and organizations that have formed the basis of the Egyptian opposition movement since the early 1990s in their historical contexts” (p. 1). She argues that the mass mobilizations that occurred in both Iran (2009) and Egypt (2011) were “the culmination of over twenty years of mobilization by social movements” (p. 1). In this respect, she does not fall into the “spontaneous” movements trap. Povey also moves away from certain trends in the social movements and revolutions literature, which is generally “geared towards trying to identify one major causal factor underlying the uprising,” by providing a sociohistorical analysis, thus trying to see how “history can illuminate the current trajectories of 21st century movements” (p. 3).
The book intends to link the development of states, elites, and movements in the Middle East to neoliberal policies and the nature of contemporary imperialism. Consequently, contexts (national or international) appear to be central in understanding the emergence and development of social movements in Egypt and Iran. In showing continuities between different movements in the 20th and 21st centuries, Povey convincingly builds on social movements literature focused on repertoires and learned forms of claim making. This leads her to make sound assessments of present-day events, such as the Egyptian mass mobilizations of June 2013. Rather than looking at these events from a normative point of view, she views the protest waves of January 2011 and June 2013 as two parts of “an on-going revolutionary struggle in Egypt” (p. 187).
The book is divided into seven parts: an introduction followed by six (rather uneven) chapters. In Chapter 2, Povey surveys the literature on social movements, regretting the relative absence of the use of such concepts as class, which she views as central to understanding contemporary movements. She also suggests that institutional politics should not be excluded from the analysis of social movements. As she shows in the subsequent chapters, what we might call the “protest field” maintains very strong links to the institutional field of politics (state institutions, elections, etc.). Povey then proceeds with four symmetrical chapters. First, she explores interactions between “Social Movements, the State and External Forces in Modern Iran,” going back as far as the late 19th-century Tobacco Protest (Chapter 3). This is followed by the analysis of “The Rise of Social Movements in Iran since the 1990s” (Chapter 4). Then, Povey replicates this schema (Chapters 4 and 5) to analyze the emergence of social movements in the Egyptian case. Finally, in Chapter 6, she compares the issues of reform and revolution in Egypt and Iran.
As stated above, one cannot but agree with the author's theoretical and epistemological postulates. However, she does not always seem to apply them to the letter. Let us point out some examples.
This book adopts what we might call a “contextualist” approach to social movements that rejects viewing them as as static actors, endowed with essences which we might infer based on “ideology,” “religion,” or “culture.” If this reviewer completely ascribes to this approach, we find that, in a way, the author did not go far enough. Indeed, Povey's “context” is quite similar to the criticized concept of Political Opportunity Structures. The author argues that movements react to transformations in the state and economy and/or to “external forces.” But how do they react precisely? And how do they perceive those changes? The author, especially in the Egyptian case, obfuscates the internal dynamics of movements, the strategic interactions with security agencies. Very little is said on the inferred “reactions.” Another example would be the sometimes-rigid distinction between “reformist” and “revolutionary.” As a consequence, a “natural history” bias is noticeably present in the analysis, that is, a certain form of teleology that shows how everything that happened before was leading (and still is) to the revolutionary climax. In hindsight, this almost always seems true, as many epistemologists have shown. But here lays one of the specificities of revolutionary situations: they are transformative processes, meaning that we need to look at their internal workings to understand their outcomes. These internal workings are, in my view, absent from the book.
We might also point to what seems to be an exaggeration by the author concerning the lack of studies on labor movements. As much as this reviewer agrees with her on the necessity of studying them, particularly with attention to class, it seems far-fetched to state, in 2015, that “there has been a neglect of the historic and contemporary role of labour movements in social movements and social struggle” (p. 4). What about the numerous studies of Nadine Abdalla, Anne Alexander and Mostafa Bassiouny, Joel Beinin, John Chalcraft, Marie Duboc, Dina Makram Ebeid, Ellis Goldberg, Zachary Lockman, Samer Shehata, among many others?
A final critique relates to another of the author's stated intentions. The book tends to reify actors by using categories such as “youth,” “women,” “national minorities,” and “workers’ groups” without explicitly defining them, thus giving agency to ahistorical constructs. (See, for example, pp. 90 and 192.) Once again there is an apparent contradiction between the call for historicizing movements and not seeing them as “static,” and then invariably using such generalizing concepts in an uncritical fashion.
Tara Povey's book will probably leave scholars of social movements and revolutions a bit unsatisfied. However, it is bound to be interesting and useful to students and informed readers looking for a rigorous yet accessible historical introduction to contentious politics and protest in Egypt and Iran, as well as to the pernicious relations between imperialism, neoliberal economic policies, states, and political elites in the contemporary Middle East.
