Galvanized by civilian action in Tunisia and Egypt during January 2011, Bahrainis in villages all over the country walked out into the streets on 14 February 2011 to express their frustrations and to demand the government institute reforms. These included changes that would have improved the economic and legal status of the Shiʿa in Bahrain, who comprise the majority in a country ruled by the Sunni Al Khalifa monarchy headed by King Hamad bin ʿIsa. More than this, however, the protestors called for the expansion of all citizens’ freedoms and a return to the 1973 Bahrain constitution, which was suspended in 1975. Hamad responded over the course of the next several days by unleashing riot police on the protestors and enlisting the support of fellow Persian Gulf rulers, who sent 1,500 troops to help squelch the protests. The Al Khalifa regime's brutal reaction may seem surprising, considering how modest the demands were when compared to those of protestors in Tunisia and Egypt, who called for the dismantling of the regime in their respective countries.
It is in the context of this latest unrest that Emile Nahkleh's Bahrain has been republished. During the 1990s and 2000s, Bahrain's government had been signaling that it would move toward greater democratization, establishing a program for economic and political reforms and expanding vocational and educational opportunities. Nakhleh's work, though, shows that the regime's more recent promises for greater democracy are only the latest unfulfilled assurances going back to Bahrain's foundation as a sovereign state in 1971. His study, first published in 1976, examined the political environment of the 1972 elections to the Constitutional Assembly, which drew up the constitution, and the subsequent National Assembly. The king suspended the constitution and dissolved the National Assembly only two years later. Nakhleh's latest edition includes no revisions to the original text, but a new preface draws clear parallels between the strikes and demonstrations surrounding the constitution and elections of 1971 and 1972 and the current protests in Bahrain. Then, as now, Bahrainis wanted greater freedom, more transparency in government, and the ability to voice opposition to government policies.
In light of the recent protests, the later chapters in Bahrain provide readers with an important snapshot of the dynamic between the ruler and the ruled at another moment, when Bahrain's political environment verged on greater democratization. In 1971, Bahrain was newly independent of Britain, which had dictated government policies since 1820. The Al Khalifas were wary of leftist and Arab nationalist movements in the Persian Gulf and Arabian peninsula calling for the overthrow of conservative regimes. The promise of greater opportunity for political participation led many educated middle- and merchant-class Bahrainis to engage in cautious but optimistic campaigning. At the same time, working-class Bahrainis focused their energies on organizing themselves into labor unions and striking for improved labor conditions and pay. This nascent large-scale political activity created an increasingly tense political environment in Bahrain.
During the campaigns and elections for the Constitutional Assembly, the government arrested and detained several candidates. In the following months, as the Assembly attempted to establish a constitution and prepare for the National Assembly elections, the government continued to arrest and interrogate political candidates and labor organizers and shut down a local newspaper on the basis of a long-standing public security decree. At the end of 1972, the Constitutional Assembly presented a petition to the ruler requesting an end to the state of emergency. Three years later, the elected National Assembly again tried to put an end to the state of emergency following a series of labor strikes; the ruler, cIsa bin Salman, dissolved the Assembly and suspended the constitution.
Nakhleh's first three chapters describe the elements of political socialization in Bahraini society at the time of the 1971 and 1972 elections, and he includes detailed statistics about the development of education, social and recreational clubs, and the press. These chapters are much more theoretical than the later chapters, and the data are much less relevant to the current situation. Education in Bahrain has expanded substantially since 1971, when only 50 percent of the population was literate. Today, both men and women have greater access to education, and more than 80 percent of the population is literate. Likewise, though social and recreational clubs continue to play a role as gathering places in society, Bahrain now also has political parties. Nevertheless, Chapters 1 through 3 will be invaluable to scholars interested in Bahrain from the 1950s to the 1970s, because Nakhleh not only includes detailed statistics but also provides a detailed bibliography of various periodicals and newspapers published in Bahrain during that period. Chapters 4 through 7 are the most valuable for Gulf specialists and non-specialists alike, in that they not only describe the political climate in Bahrain at the time of the elections but also consider the dynamics of domestic Bahraini politics as well as their intersection with wider foreign policy concerns (especially as they relate to the United States’ role in the region). Here, at last, is where readers can see the long arc of suppression in Bahrain of a sophisticated, modern political population.
Unfortunately, Bahrain suffers from being a largely dated political science study. As a glimpse into Bahrain's political culture, the work is useful, and scholars of the region will no doubt be able to tease out the connections between the elections of 1972 and the current protests. The book would have benefitted greatly, however, from an extended preface or postscript expanding on the ways in which education, the press, and political parties and clubs have evolved over the last several decades.
