Descended from Darwin is itself descended from a conference held at the American Philosophical Society Library in October of 2004 with the theme Descended from Darwin: Insights into American Evolutionary Studies, 1925–1950. The volume expands the temporal and geographical reach of that theme, and adds several papers by scholars not present at the conference.
This is a volume of little histories in search of a big history. ‘We think the master narratives for [evolutionary studies in the twentieth century] have broken down’, the editors tell us, while at ‘the same time, replacements have yet to arrive’ (p. xi). The strategy of the volume is to try to prepare the ground such that any rebuilding or replacement of the crumbling master narratives will be securely founded on a broad base of empirical research. Considering the variety of subject matter covered by the volume's fifteen case studies and micro-histories, one can see that the construction of any new master narrative(s) will be a complex and difficult undertaking. So much the better for young historians of science working in this area.
So what are these old master narratives of evolutionary studies in the twentieth century that need updating? One influential way of opening the story at the century's beginning is to tell of a Darwinism on the defensive, ‘eclipsed’ by a host of evolutionary theories that relegated natural selection to a lesser or nonexistent role in explanations of evolutionary change. This opening gambit is immediately challenged in the first essay of the volume, by Mark Largent. Focusing on the American biologist Vernon Kellog's 1907 book Darwinism To-day, which has been extensively cited as evidence for the ‘eclipse’ narrative, Largent questions whether Kellog believed himself to be contributing to Darwinism's undoing. He did not. The question therefore arises: who said there was an eclipse of Darwinism, anyway?
The answer leads us into the central, controlling element of the master narrative that these essays seek to complicate. For the story of Darwinism eclipsed was pioneered and championed by the architects and popularizers of the so-called ‘neo-Darwinian synthesis’ of the 1930s, 1940s and 1950s. These scientists – Theodosius Dobzhansky, Ernst Mayr, Julian Huxley, to name a few of the biggest players – were highly skilled in the art of what political operatives today call ‘controlling the narrative’. In the synthesists' narration of evolutionary studies in the twentieth century, they cast themselves as the heroes come to rescue the damsel in distress (Darwinism) from the clutches of nefarious non-Darwinian evolutionary theories, and so restore biology to its rightful course. Their heroism obviously falls flat if Darwinism was never really in distress in the first place, and so they had a clear interest in maintaining the eclipse narrative. But the synthesists were influential scientists and compelling writers, so even historians believed what they said.
The idea here is not that the synthesists were deliberately misrepresenting their own role in the development of twentieth-century evolutionary studies. It is rather that, due to the apparent sufficiency of the received narrative and the relative recency of the events in question, scholars have only just begun to systematically search the documentary record to see if the standard story fits the evidence. What they have discovered, as evidenced by the essays in this volume, is the need for broader and more nuanced stories than the ones we have. To take one example, in the narrative that has been passed down to us from the neo-Darwinians the crucial factor that drove evolutionary studies forward after the ‘eclipse’ period was the synthesis of natural-selection theory and Mendelian genetics, which had theretofore been seen as opposed to one another. Developments in genetics were undoubtedly of major importance to the course of evolutionary studies, but the narrative emphasis on that field has resulted in the comparative neglect of the influence of other biological fields, or in the assumption that developments in those fields were themselves driven by the influence of genetics. Several essays in this volume, however, show that a number of other biological disciplines developed along their own lines and made contributions to evolutionary studies independently of the influence of genetics. Palaeontology, field zoology, botany and even economic entomology played roles in the development of evolutionary studies, and did so without taking all their marching orders from genetics. Consequently, if we are to continue to use the metaphor of ‘synthesis’, it seems we will at least have to reconsider the range of practices that were synthesized.
In the absence of any new master narratives to immediately replace the old, the editors express the hope that this volume will act as ‘a seed that will bear much intellectual fruit in the years to come’ (p. xi). Happily, the seed will have the added advantage of dissemination not only through sales of the printed volume, but also by free download from Joe Cain's website at http://www.ucl.as.uk/sts/cain/projects/descended_from_darwin/index.html.
