In 2008, Americans witnessed a historical moment. Barack Obama, an African American, was elected the forty-fourth president of the United States of America. With a black president, the argument went, we have truly entered a new “postracial” era, in which the color of one's skin is no longer an impediment to one's opportunities or success in life. Obama's campaign strategy to de-emphasize race also reinforced this notion of a colorblind America. His race-neutral approach proved successful across the board in the general election, garnering a majority of the Latino and black vote and a larger share of the white vote than previous Democratic candidates, such as John Kerry, Al Gore, and Michael Dukakis. Pundits and social scientists asserted that this wide level of support was proof that race no longer mattered in electoral politics. But both books under review convincingly and impressively declare otherwise; they find that race played a substantial role in the 2008 presidential election and perhaps more than at anytime in the past 20 years.
Enid Logan's central argument is that race was an important factor in the 2008 presidential campaign, but its role deviated from our traditional notion of the way that black candidates influence the electorate. Obama did not offer a race-conscious agenda, such as proposing policies that would directly alleviate the inequalities between blacks and whites. His race-neutral approach resonated with many Americans: He gave redemption to a country with deep racial wounds redemption. According to Logan's reading of the mainstream media, Obama offered what she describes as the “triumphalist narrative of post-race America” or the “colorblind individualistic perspective” (p. 9). This narrative says that we have entered a new era of racial politics—one that has combatted the problem of race. It does not disrupt the racial hierarchy or put demands on whites; it attributes the problem of race to blacks themselves. In critique of this narrative, Logan cautions whether America has really solved its racial problem, given the large inequality in most economic and political spheres of life between whites and blacks today.
At This Defining Moment is clear, engaging, and well organized. The first three chapters provide an in-depth discussion of the “the triumphalist narrative of post-race America.” The rest of the book examines the different aspects of the presidential campaign, including the role of gender in the Democratic primaries, nationhood, Asian American and Latino interests, and the political Right, while incorporating how race contributed to an Obama victory.
The book relies on 1,500 newspaper articles, news magazines, and political blogs over a three-year period as its primary data source. Using this information, Logan provides an in-depth perspective of this new racial-politics narrative and how it saturated the campaign. But this work would have benefited from a more systematic content analysis of the information, which would have provided stronger support for her argument. In Chapter 4, she also conducts 125 in-depth interviews of college students, examining the intersection between gender and race in the 2008 campaign. From these interviews, a consistent theme appears among participants: Race matters more to her college student sample than gender. Like the news sources, however, more information could have been extracted from the in-depth interviews to strengthen her overall argument. For example, it would have helped to know if the interviewees also thought that an Obama victory would mean that the United States has triumphed over its racial problem.
Michael Tesler and David O. Sears similarly argue that race had a substantial effect on the 2008 election, more so than at any other time on record. The symbolic nature of a potential black president made race more accessible in the minds of many Americans, in comparison to previous presidential campaigns. As a consequence, support for Obama and public policies associated with him became more polarized by racial attitudes. That is, his candidacy pushed racial conservatives to be more in opposition to him and racial liberals to be more supportive, which Tesler and Sears refer to as the “two sides of racialization” (p. 29). This racialization of the 2008 campaign was present throughout the Democratic primaries and the general election. If race had such a large effect, then how did Obama manage to secure the Democratic nomination and win the presidency, especially in a country where the average white American is racially conservative? The authors provide a convincing answer. Obama's success was due, in part, to an unprecedented level of support among white racial liberals.
Obama's Race is well organized and very well written. It relies on a significant amount of survey data from the American National Election Study (ANES), the Cooperative Campaign Analysis Project (CCAP), and the National Politics Study (NPS). Each chapter presents compelling evidence that race mattered a great deal, for whites as well as for Latinos and blacks. Some scholars have criticized the theory of symbolic racism for concentrating only on whites. However, Tesler and Sears demonstrate that the concept of symbolic racism can also explain nonwhites' racial attitudes. This extension is one of the significant contributions of the book. The authors find that symbolic racism is a broader concept of racial prejudice than previously considered; it applies not only to whites but to Latinos as well. On the other hand, symbolic racism means something entirely different for African Americans. For blacks, they find that it operates as a proxy for racial group consciousness.
What these two books tell us is that race benefited Obama electorally more than it hampered him. But they offer different reasons as to why. On the one hand, Logan asserts that supporting Obama allowed white Americans to turn the page on the nation's ugly racial history. It offered them racial reconciliation. On the other hand, Tesler and Sears contend that voting for Obama was symbolic. White racial liberals could express their hope of having Obama as the first African American president. Moreover, there was less risk associated with supporting him, given his race-neutral approach. In addition to being a symbolic gesture or reconciling white guilt, support for Obama may have also represented a deeper ideological sentiment among white racial liberals. To them, he signifies what African Americans can become when the walls of discrimination and racism are removed. To racial liberals, the election of Obama would begin to remove the stain of moral defect that has been attributed to blacks for so long and demonstrate that whites and blacks are equal in all characteristics.
As the scholarly community moves forward to understand the effect of race in the Obama era, both books make clear that more attention needs to be devoted to racial liberals. Specifically, we need a better understanding of the circumstances that make racial liberals' attitudes more important in political decision making.
Race not only shaped evaluations of Obama but also influenced policies strongly associated with him. Tesler and Sears refer to this as the spillover of racialization. The process works via what is known as transfer of affect—“racial predispositions were transferred from opinions about Obama to related political evaluations when there was a strong association between the two” (p. 77, emphasis original). They demonstrate that once tax policy (i.e., raising taxes on Americans in the top income bracket) was strongly associated with Obama in 2008, racial predispositions had a stronger impact on tax policy preferences than in years past. A similar effect occurs for health-care reform. Once Obama took office and aligned himself with health-care reform, opinions on health care became more polarized by racial attitudes. But how far does race spill over? Tax policy and health care are redistributive policies and, therefore, were somewhat racialized beforehand. This association may have made for an easier test of the spillover theory of racialization. Throughout the 2008 campaign, Obama also took a strong stance on alternative energy, which he argued would lower Americans' dependency on foreign oil. Because of his strong attachment to environmentally friendly policies like renewable energy, an important question is whether racial predispositions are a stronger predictor of this policy in 2008 than in years past. Such an analysis is beyond the scope of Tesler and Sears's book, but would have greatly strengthened the spillover theory of racialization. As of now, it is still unclear how far race spills over to other issue areas that Obama has embraced.
All in All, Obama's Race is a must-read for anyone who wants to understand how race significantly contributed to Obama's capture of the White House. This insightful work persuasively shows that racial predispositions played a major role in voters' evaluation of Obama. It should be read in graduate and undergraduate seminars across the country and by any student of politics—academic or practical. The statistical analysis is straightforward and the results are remarkably consistent and deeply informative. The book will be a classic and should be placed on the shelf alongside other great books on racial attitudes and public opinion, such as Donald Kinder and Lynn Sanders's Divided by Color: Racial Politics and Democratic Ideals (1996); Martin Gilens' Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy (1999); and Tali Mendelberg's The Race Card: Campaign Strategy, Implicit Messages, and the Norm of Equality (2001). At This Defining Moment is also a fine book that provokes us to think hard about what the 2008 election means for race in the future. Its extensive analysis of the mainstream media and blogosphere provides a rich narrative and a comprehensive perspective on the 2008 election of Obama.
As more political candidates begin to adopt a race-neutral agenda or move away from using racially coded language to criticize their opponents, an important question is whether these approaches will impede race from entering into electoral politics. Recently, however, Antoine J. Banks and Nicholas A. Valentino (“Emotional Substrates of White Racial Attitudes,” American Journal of Political Science 56 [April 2012]: 286–97) have demonstrated that evoking anger—independent of racial or political content—can activate thoughts about race among a large percentage of white Americans. This result suggests that the conditions for making race accessible are more inconspicuous than scholars have suspected. As we move forward to understand race in the Obama era, future research on US racial politics would greatly benefit from an analysis of the specific conditions under which race is important and when it is not.
