Although scholars often praise Hardy's “The Fiddler of the Reels” as a work with “considerable power” (The Cambridge Companion 46), the theme of the workings of the market culture in the story has gone uninvestigated. Set against the backdrop of urban transformations that were enacted by the Great Exhibition and the new mass transportation system, the text dramatizes how male impulses fit into larger questions of acquisitive power and how a narrow preoccupation with dominance creates a messy reality. This study argues that exhibitions (in the material, commercial sense of the term) and exhibitionistic celebrity behavior are aligned in “The Fiddler,” and claims that certain Darwinian and Dionysian elements in the story underwrite this theme. To substantiate this argument, my analysis is attentive to two notions: a general notion of economy and a literary notion of the trickster as expounded by C. G. Jung and Mikhail Bakhtin. Before taking my argument further, I will summarize the plot of “The Fiddler.”
The story is set in 1851 and it recounts the wizardry of a musician named Wat Ollamoor (commonly known as Mop due to his copious hair), who plays folk songs and tunes at pubs and fairs, moving “fragile and responsive” (496) women to frenzy. A notorious dandy, Mop is rumored to have had many amorous adventures. Presently, he has one with Car'line Aspent, a young women who is engaged to marry Ned Hipcroft, a capable and honest mechanic, before she finds herself deeply affected by Mop's music. Realizing that their marriage will not take place, Ned leaves his native South Wessex and travels to London, where he joins the work force engaged in constructing the Great Exhibition's famous Crystal Palace. After four years, Ned receives a letter of apology from Car'line and a plea to rethink the possibility of their marriage. Though an awkward request, Ned admits to himself that he still loves Car'line and he invites her to join him in London. To his amazement, Car'line arrives with her three-year old daughter, Carry, the biological daughter of Mop. Under Car'line's supplications, Ned decides to marry Car'line and adopt Carry. After a year or so, Ned is unemployed and decides to return to Stickleford, his native village. While traveling towards Stickleford, Car'line decides to rest at a local auction while her husband makes a brief detour to Casterbridge. She is unaware that Mop will be playing at this same auction later in the day. A man offers her a drink and soon the music begins. Unable to resist the “seductive” tunes of Mop's violin, Car'line dances, and, later, when she is invited to participate in a five-handed reel, she does not decline, despite her desire to leave the place (506).Footnote 1 Under the influence of Mop's music, the reeling and agitated Car'line collapses into unconsciousness and Mop kidnaps Carry and disappears in the night, never to be found. The “general opinion” (509) of the villagers is that Mop and Carry have emigrated to America – where he will continue to work as a fiddler, traveling between fairs and inns, while training his daughter to accompany his performances as a dancer.
The reader readily notices that “The Fiddler” positions the characters of Ned Hipcroft and Wat Ollamoor – “if that were his real name” (494) – against each other. Ned is the image of English masculinity, a productive proletariat who upholds his moral commitments and grounds his action in good conscience.Footnote 2 In contrast, Mop,Footnote 3 whose “complexion [is] a rich olive,“ functions as “un-English,” a socially marginalized newcomer who introduces difference as well as disruption into the traditional Christian culture of the narrator and his native Wessex (495). Mop is often described as wily and fox-like; he incorporates some alleged characteristics of the fox. In particular, the subtlety of his facial gestures while performing recalls what is termed the “fox's sleep” whereby the animal masquerades as indifferent to its surroundings while, in reality, it is observing them intently (Brewer 449). Worried that Mop may detect her emotional turmoil upon first hearing his violin, Car'line “found to her relief that his eyes were closed in abandonment to instrumentation” (496); however, on “[g]aining another glance at him when immediately opposite, she saw that one of his eyes was open, quizzing her as he smiled at her emotional state” (496).
In addition to his description as a manipulative lascivious villain, Mop is, obviously, the image of the talented mind, i.e., the music virtuoso. Mostly, however, he is the archetype of the Bakhtinian trickster whose subjectivity anticipates the modern image of the music celebrity. The narrator remarks that “[h]is fiddling possibly had the most to do with the fascination he exercised, for, to speak fairly, it could claim for itself a most peculiar and personal quality, like that in a moving preacher” (495). As the plot summary suggests, Mop is also the image of the amoral spirit that espouses a skepticism toward the notion that certain ethical values and codes are absolute and beyond contingency. The fact that he “never bowed a note of church-music from his birth; he never once sat in the gallery of Mellstock church where the others had tuned their venerable psalmody so many hundreds of times; had never, in all likelihood, entered a church at all,” attests to his radical market-oriented mind which can filter out the sacred (495–96). Through his movement between various settings, including Stickleford, Lower Mellstock, Moreford, London and later (presumably) America, Mop's character betokens adaptability to ever transforming spaces, just as tricksters and performing celebrities often do.
To articulate their vehement derision, Ollamoor's duped ex-lovers reduced him to “Mop.” Though the name carries much absurdity, it bears a startling resemblance to his role as an archetypal trickster. A mop is found everywhere: as an object, it belongs to all cultures. It is associated with the earthly; it travels across all spatial planes whether belonging to the rich or the poor. It can change the appearances of surfaces making them shiny and clean or opaque and grimy. Paradoxically, whether clean or unclean, its function is to obliterate what is out there.
Building on Bakhtin's theory as expressed in his introduction in Rabelais and His World, Mop's character and language, i.e., the music of his captivating violin, conform to the stereotypical identity of the carnivalesque trickster, who in Bakhtin's phrase, stands “on the borderline between life and art, in a peculiar midzone as it were” (7) and who, moreover, is bent on the “degradation,” and the “debasement” of language, associating it with “the lower stratum of the body” (21,147). Michael Benazon cogently speculates that “[r]eaders may wonder if Mop was intended to be a symbol of the artist, for Hardy grants him Orphic qualities…. Yet the qualification is as important as the comparison [with Paganini, the acclaimed Italian composer and violinist]. Mop seems more devoted to love than to music, and he is far from martyring himself for art. If he is a pariah, it is by choice, not from public disapprobation or persecution” (78). Mop navigates the domains of material culture, and his art sways between the erotically hypnotic and the popularly gratifying, between the Darwinian and the Dionysian, embracing the subversive and rejecting traditional moralism. Mop's music/language is that of the marketplace, which, as Bakhtin remarks, emphasizes “the material bodily principle” (18), namely the sexual body especially the phallus, and does not eschew “abusive language” (16), or acts, we may add. Let us delineate the specific carnivalesque aspects of Mop's music.
Although Mop's music harks back to earlier musical modes of folk, it, nevertheless, posits a new aesthetic key that renders art an erotic activity, not a social event, or a medium that refines further the subject's sensibilities. Consequently, his music takes on a newly oppositional meaning because it refuses to re-instate the moral.Footnote 4 As a trickster, Mop sets forth operational gambits of entertainment, seduction, and captivation such as keeping flamboyant dandy looks and closing his eyes while playing the fiddle. By these stratagems, he devises the relational usage of his music so that it becomes a real, coveted, aural commodity. As I previously suggested, this is dictated by the imperatives of the will-to-celebrity. To recapitulate, Mop's drive to manipulate Car'line's “infatuation” (497), her “hysterical tendencies” (497), and her convulsive reactions, which are likened to “galvanic shock[s]” (497), cannot be explained merely by ascribing it to obscene arbitrary evil, and Mop can be seen as more than “the traditional form of a demon lover” (Brooks 145), or one with “an uncanny knowledge of the physical and the mental state of his victims” (Brady 135). Mop, I maintain, understands the new post-Great Exhibition econo-cultural climate. If we take this context into consideration, “The Fiddler” is a story about newly transformed cultural practices, particularly popular culture/musicFootnote 5 and futural forms of celebrityhood. It bears repeating that “popular culture in particular exists as process, not essence, in a series of negotiations between different, class-specific perspectives” (Faulk 3); that “the popular is a manifest contingency or construct, existing in discursive and therefore shifting relation to any social group” (3); and that “art and culture are produced under impure conditions, and to profligate effect” (2). Not surprisingly, Mop's selfhood eludes one-dimensional definitions; nevertheless, it conjures up a coherent conceptual horizon. Before elaborating on this point, a brief exposition of the economic realities of the mid nineteenth century is necessary.
Two general traits of the new economy must be mentioned. First, value was considered a contingent matter and was determined by the oscillations of market conditions and consumers' taste and psychology. Second, in the dynamics of the new economy, desire took on the status of need. In An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith posits that economics is the science of wealth; that wealth is not the “abundance… of gold and silver” but it is the production of goods and services and their circulation for consumption among individuals and different segments of society (Pt 3, ch.11). Howard Horwitz shows that Smith's new theory is inextricably linked to a novel conception of human nature:
Since the late seventeenth century, persons had been conceived to have ‘character,’ a principle of ‘integrity’ coordinating conduct and consciousness, which valued work, thrift, and responsibility. But industry's escalating capacities to produce goods impelled a transformation to a consumption-based, rather than production-based, economic ethos. ‘Personality’ began to supplant character as a principle of personhood. This notion emphasized idiosyncrasy, viewing life more as a series of discrete rather than coordinated acts. Such a self was better able to consume a wider variety of goods. (121)
The new definition of the subject as a consuming person rendered obsolete certain notions of morality; as Horwitz remarks, “[b]efore Smith, self-interest was deemed unchristian and unethical…. Economic activity ought to be altruistic, aimed at the benefit of the community, and hence God. Private wants and interests were considered vice” (128).
The modern economy of Mop's music is at the heart of the tale. Caught between fairs and auctions, small towns and the metropolis, Mop's music takes on the commodity form; it is bound up with the shifting marketplace and the capitalist economic order of self-finance; consequently, the question of value (in its pecuniary sense) is an integral aspect of its mechanism. Since Mop does not compose original music but plays existing folk music and songs in profit-driven spaces, his objective is the creation of a lowbrow cultural product in the form of an aural commodity whose value is greater than its production process. To ensure the ever-augmenting value of his music, he must seek the collateral economy of celebrityhood. Mop is shrewd; he understands that the value of his music is minimized if it is not realized through the process of consumption, that women with a volatile sense of self are the most useful consumers. The text suggests that the female performative dance, too, is steeped in an economic sphere because it takes on the form of a relational exchange; while the female audience consumes avidly the pleasure of an aural commodity, it simultaneously bolsters Mop's status as a celebrity which, in effect, is a surplus value of his lowbrow cultural product. The more his music extracts pleasurable reactions from the female audience, the higher its value grows. Mop's desire to mesmerize Car'line, who, in the final section of the story, looks like a “London wife with a distinct London accent” (504), can be understood in the material terms of the economic efficiency of his music; the more affluent the class that his music attracts, the higher its marketability.
Given his context, I extend two reflections about the presence of the elements of the Darwinian and the Dionysian in the text.Footnote 6 I argue that while the Darwinian is a precondition of the production of Mop's aural product, the Dionysian is the means of the distribution of its value. If the signaling of the connection between the three elements of market, the Darwinian, and the Dionysian is oblique, it is due to the parochialism of the nameless narrator who equates English culture with the dogma of the Bible and its cultural byproducts such as sacred music, especially when played in the halls of small towns. Mop, however, is intent to unravel this simplistic equation, making the definition of contemporary English culture more capacious and market-oriented. The succinct remarks of Barry Faulk on the dynamics of popular culture help us understand Mop's shrewd economic perspective:
Late-Victorian literary intellectuals like Max Beerbohm and Elizabeth Robins Pennell framed a narrative of cultural rise and decline using their experience of the music hall. As they understood it, culture forms emerge with an appealing vigor, vitality, and charisma. Popular entertainment stands in some honest, responsive, and authentic relation to its patrons. Inevitably, the bloom leaves the rose; entertainment becomes commercialized, co-opted, appropriated, and vitiated. (2)
To recapitulate, while Paganini's music (which the narrator seems to regard as the acme of high culture, despite the fact that its maestro was known to be a flamboyant womanizer) is the soundscape of the old metropolitan centers, Mop's music is the soundscape of the new urban-driven, investment-driven rural spaces swept by capitalism's influence. Mop's music points beyond the rustic landscape of Southern Wessex into the future, towards the emerging realm of mass culture, celebrity culture, and the amorally humorous. In the following section, I will engage in a closer consideration of these generalizations.
The text marks the change from the celebrity culture of scientists and explorers (David Livingston, for example), literati (Charles Dickens, for example), and preachers (John Cumming, for example) to a more plebeian one. The text, moreover, makes clear that the rise of Mop's career was founded on the decline of conservative musicians: “His date was a little later than that of the old Mellstock quire-band which comprised the Dewys, Mail, and the rest - in fact, he did not rise above the horizon thereabout till those well-known musicians were disbanded as ecclesiastical functionaries” (495). Although “un-English” (perhaps a gypsy) and amoral, Mop's opportunity of entering the British celebrity mass culture is feasible, first, because he maintains the relationship between his music and Englishness to attract the Victorian crowds, and second, because art appreciation is at this point no longer dictated solely by the elitist attitude of critics. Remarks by Ulla Haselstein, Berndt Ostendorf and Peter Schneck on contemporary popular culture can explain aspects of Mop's approach to popular music; unlike the narrator, Mop's behavior “assumes a… dynamic interchange of cultural forms” (337); consequently, it is possible to infer that he rejects conventional ideas that posit a “hegemonic stratification” and a “monodirectional transmission between basis and superstructure” (337); put differently, Mop's use of the common musical forms is different and is not “guided by the Bloomian ‘anxiety of influence’ but rather a ‘pleasure of influence’” (337). The older musicians in Wessex “despised the new man's style” (495), asserting that “there was no ‘plumness’ in it – no bowing, no solidity” (495), that his music “was all fantastical” (495), and their judgments carry circumscribed aesthetic/critical weight because Mop is performing during an era in which popular culture is seizing its potent currency and appeal. Put differently, Mop, like his audience, is constantly in negotiation with both his time and the contemporary social scene.
Given this context, Mop is aware of the emerging new context and conditions of celebrityhood. The post Great-Exhibition futural celebrity culture is predicated, like Bakhtinian carnival, on corporeality, amorality, and sexual maneuvering. Thus, the threshold of his fame as a popular musician, who plays lowbrow music in a retail manner, can be created by the subjugation of a lower-middle class consumer/female body, which has the aura of performativity, i.e., a capacity as a dancer and speaker to perform an identity. The contradiction at the heart of the musician-trickster's subjectivity is that he is a subverter as well as a revealer of eclipsed truths. One of these truths is that eros is a primary context of marketable (retail) music and that eros cannot be contained by social taboos. Not surprisingly, Mop's trickstery and celebrityhood are attuned to the workings of biology and myth. By linking Mop's continual quest for enamored audiences under the liminal conditions of his life to Darwinian and Dionysian inclinations, “The Fiddler” casts his trickstery in the dual form of energy as well as agency that counters temporal restrictions and thus indexes the primitive and the archetypal.
Thus conceived, the tale displays a dialectic between the obsessional tendencies of the celebrity-oriented mind of Mop and the performative body of the passive consumer, Car'line Aspent. Mop's violin necessarily casts its power at the biological boundaries of gender. A quote from Darwin will focus this generalization. In The Descent of Man (published in1871) Darwin explains the typical mating behavior of birds:
The males are almost always the wooers… [t]hey are generally stronger and larger than the females, and are endowed with the requisite qualities of courage and pugnacity. They are provided, either exclusively or in a much higher degree than the females, with organs for vocal or instrumental music, and with odoriferous glands. They are ornamented with infinitely diversified appendages, and with the most brilliant or conspicuous colours, often arranged in elegant patterns, whilst the females are unadorned…. [I]t is the male which is provided with special sense-organs for discovering the female… and often with prehensile organs for holding her. (Ch. 21)
It is useful for us to juxtapose this quote with the following sentences/sections from Hardy's text: “Many a worthy villager envied him [Mop] his power over unsophisticated maidenhood – a power which seemed sometimes to have a touch of the weird and wizardly in it” (494). Mop's appearance also adds to his seductive power, with his hair described as “rank … dark and rather clammy – made still clammier by secret ointments, which, when he came fresh to a party, caused him to smell like ‘boys'-love’…. On occasion he wore curls – a double row – running almost horizontally around his head” (495). If we put the narrator's Darwinian remarks in lucid terms, we can see that although Mop seems maladaptive to English/Christian culture, his physical features, especially his “abundance of hair”(495) which he stylishly wears “long enough to rest upon his shoulders” (495), accentuate his masculine charm and gives him a competitive edge over Car'line's other male suitors (i.e., Ned Hipcroft). Therefore, his sexual urge is unabashedly excessive and confident. A veterinary surgeon – “in theory” (494) – his eyes are observantly sharp and possess diagnostic skills, and can, therefore, discern the vulnerable females who will be most attracted to his fiddle, the tool of his predation. His striking looks and his musical ability have survival value in the male world. As the narration makes evident, his music/language subverts the categories of human and non-human; for under its spell – what the narrator calls “acoustic magnetism” (507) – Car'line loses her rationality, the faculty which heeds social taboos and which makes her, according to socio-philosophical dictums, normatively human.
To gain insight into the animalistic inclinations of Mop as a trickster, a remark from Carl Jung's theory is instructive. Jung writes that the trickster “is obviously a ‘psychologem,’ an archetypal psychic structure of extreme antiquity. In his clearest manifestations he is a faithful copy of an absolutely undifferentiated human consciousness, corresponding to a psyche that has hardly left the animal level” (200).
Taking the Darwinian and the Jungian perspectives together, we can say that the quoted lines from “The Fiddler” in the preceding paragraph emphasize the bio-economic nature of the relationship of Mop to his female consumer who is forced to engage in a performance reciprocal to his fiddle playing (symbolically his voice). The production of the music as well as its reception are seen as journeying into the interior recesses of the sexual, uninhibited self during spring (the actual time when Car'line becomes infatuated with Mop). The drama of Car'line's neuro-psychic surrender to the attractions of Mop can be interpreted in light of the Darwinian view that “males who can excite females through some elaborate performance or display are not necessarily those best adapted to other aspects of life…. But for some deeper functional reason… females are attracted to such traits” (Cartwright and Baker 192). In this sexual dance of mating and natural selection, words such as “sin” and “fall” barely come to the fore. Hardy's narrative projects the situation as beyond historical specificity, as if this is a human/animal ritualistic praxis rooted in a mythico-natural principle that is connected to the notion of fertility (i.e., the primitive) but not domesticity (i.e., the civilized). Michael Irwin reminds us that: “[t]he love which dominates Hardy's fiction is romantic or sexual. Other kinds of affection are featured, of course, but only in bit parts…. In relation to love, as to other aspects of human life, Hardy is concerned to generalize, to diagnose. He's constantly saying: this is what the thing called love is like. This is how it happens” (117). The dual Darwinian-Jungian perspective encourages the reader to conceive of Mop's violin (a phallic symbol) as his mechanism of natural selection. Thus playing music enacts the politics of possession, i.e., to possess a woman as the available asset that subsidizes male celebrityhood.Footnote 7 His violin transforms the dancing arena into a coercive disciplinary space; music becomes the site of male acquisitive power and sadistic pleasure. At the story's close, while the reeling Car'line “cast[s] her eyes upon him, as if imploring him to withdraw himself” (507) from the place, feeling the onslaught of “convulsions” (508), Mop's only thought concerning her excruciating five-hundred reel dance is “‘You cannot leave off, dear, whether you would or no!’” (507). The text asserts that these thoughts “bred in her a paroxysm of desperation that defied him to tire her down” (507).
As this exposition reveals, “The Fiddler” partakes of another aspect of Darwin's theory: in the story, the concept of teleology is sidestepped, in the sense that the story does not harbor any indication about larger metaphysical issues of human destiny. Its foreseeable direction is impelled by the dynamics of a progressive century which, the text suggests, foregrounds the material as well as the biological and obfuscates the ethical. This is a world whose contingent nature makes suffering and waste a logical outcome of its lack of transcendence. Notwithstanding, Mop is a mediating figure between biological impulses and mythical inclinations. Frank Giordano cogently argues that the story is riven by the conflict between “modern British Hebraism and ancient Greek paganism” (617). As the text makes evident, Car'line's sense of weakness, of being “overpowered with hysteric emotion” (506) upon hearing Mop's music, her stepping “despairingly” (506) into the dancing arena to let Mop's tunes transmit “through her nerves excruciating spasms, a sort of blissful torture,” make the nature of her dance not only sexual but orgiastic (506). Mop's musical discourse abolishes the need for words, replacing them with the medium that accounts for the sub-rational inclinations. Consequently, it seems appropriate to infer that Mop's character as trickster runs parallel to the ancient image of Dionysus as trickster. Louise O. Vasvari's words may best express this parallelism:
the trickster represents a symbolic inversion of established values, who is amoral, asocial, aggressive, impulsive, deceitful, exhibitionist, has an overdeveloped libido, and is constantly provoking all authority. From his position on the fringe of society, he mocks all conventions but in particular those relating to sexuality…. The trickster… represents incorrigible impulses and the insubordinate libido. (1, 15)
It follows then that the trickster's identity is bound up with a “sly phallus” (Kerényi 182); that he is “neither a magician nor a guardian of frontiers” (183). It goes without saying that the Dionysian has a capacious significance; however, a succinct exposition is instructive.
The Nietzschean formulation in The Birth of Tragedy conceptualizes the Dionysian as a fundamental impulse and aligns it, among other elements, with rapture, disorder, and the wildly comic (22, 23). Lyric poetry and music, marked by excess and intensification of rhythm, are Dionysian art impulses par excellence. When under the spell of Dionysius, discourse is weaved in passional tongues. Dionysius strips the mind of its rationality as well as self-discipline and loyalties to conventional institutionalized structures; it, therefore, makes selfhood bare itself and articulate bold emotions, ridding itself of cultural anxieties. As David Williams puts it “like many tricksters [Dionysius] had two sides to his personality: bringing ecstasy or animalistic rage” (211). It follows that the radicalized forms of the Dionysian harbor a seductive barbarity; yet, they expand the notion of life. Because the Dionysian is both volatile and flexible, it perpetuates cycles of erotic energy. In short, while the Apollonian brackets out desire and gives power to restraint, the Dionysian unleashes it.
We can assume that Mop's conception of music is bifocal: it partakes of the Dionysian passional order as well as the modern which approaches it as a commoditized thing and, as a result, enmeshed with the questions of money, taste, and class. Moreover, Mop's conception seems to posit that the value of music, as a nonutilitarian aural commodity, is not fixed but is constituted contingently by competition, reception, and the consumers' moods. No character in the story is outraged by this conception of music, not even the narrator himself, who seems more uncomfortable than appalled. In light of these remarks, I maintain that although Mop's performance is constituted totally by the Dionysian, it is, nevertheless, legitimated by the Apollonian, i.e., the pragmatically rational. Let me elaborate further on this point.
In his music, Mop appeals to the laws of the Dionysian for sundry reasons: to validate it as modern; to secure its aesthetic autonomy which, in turn, bolsters its value and its circulation. The economic merit of Dionysian-oriented music (i.e., music that indexes the Dionysian) is that it circulates more easily cross boundaries and social zones. Since its contextualization can be manipulated to embody personal signifying practices according to the recipient's inclinations, it gives the female recipient the aura of constructing an identity. But this identity is, in truth, produced by the very male artist who is subordinating the recipient as an unmindful, avid consumer: “She [Car'line] thus continued to dance alone, defiantly as she thought, but in truth slavishly and abjectly, subject to every wave of the melody” (507). To Mop, then, the Dionysian is a handy framework whose necessity is generated by the new economy of music; as a producer of a commodity, he remains an Apollonian self who protects himself from the web of intersubjectivity which the Dionysian may occasion. In Mop's world the two are complementary, not contradictory or in tension.
In conjugating the trickster's notion of selfhood, the Darwinian outlook, and the Dionysian order through the prism of music, “The Fiddler,” I maintain, casts a futural vision on the nature of post-Great Exhibition performative arts. A different lowbrow type of celebrityhood is emblematic of this new cultural climate. As the narrator reflects, many substantive nouns will go “so far as to become an adjective in honour of [an] occasion” (494) – or a popular celebrity, we may add – just as the landmark Great Exhibition had set in motion the consumerist craze of “‘exhibition’ hat,” “‘exhibition’ razor-strop,” “‘exhibition’ watch; nay, even ‘exhibition’ weather, ‘exhibition’ spirits, sweethearts, babies, wives” (494). The fact that the narrator is gossiping to his friends about Mop sustains inadvertently the latter's celebrityhood. The irony is that the trickster, Mop, has presence without ever being a speaker in the narrative, which is constructed about him and unintentionally for him by the disparaging narrator. It is such gossip that allows Mop to transcend the limits of his social positionality and provides him with an additional means to meet the mandates of a competitive entertainment market.
Hardy's story suggests that post-Great Exhibition music celebrityhood is sustained by gender power relations; it takes on the form of an erotic contract created by immersive musical forms in which emotions become more perceivable and the body takes on a more salient position. More and more, the course of modern post-Great Exhibition male celebrityhood is forecasted by what one may call female melophilia. More and more, the indispensability of the docile female consumer becomes imperative. The male celebrity subject is born of domination and presence, of a surplus of desire which will materialize in a modern non-material cultural form, which one may label the “will-to-celebrity.”
As his presumed departure to America implies, Mop's pernicious yet pleasant music will continue to function as a force that creates cultural changes across geographical spaces. Consequently, it seems appropriate to infer that “The Fiddler” takes up a dual Darwinian-Dionysian perspective to speculate how music, in the future, will make ever ubiquitous an interplay whose nature is gender-based and bio-economic. This requires that we rethink the cultural definition of music. The post-Great Exhibition boom of aural commodities created conditions that allowed amoral musicians to flourish and celebrityhood to become easily accessible.Footnote 8 The borders of elitist and popular music began to blur. Musicians became more and more akin to economic, self-assertive agents who do not adhere to idealist pre-Great Exhibition aesthetic attitudes. No longer a venue of the spiritual, the new modes of impure music were home to the interaction between producers and consumers. This new celebrityhood-oriented music was gauged by the body's reaction upon receiving it – it was gauged by palpability. The narrator hints at the degenerative effects of such music, which is conducive to excess. Yet Car'line is not ruined and Mop is not punished. The absence of nemesis and hubris not only renders Hardy's “evolutionary meliorism” contingent and, thus, betokening the triumphal persistence of the carnivalesque, but it also corresponds to the Darwinian and Dionysian conceptions of reality. Let us remember that the story was published in 1893, in a literary volume on the occasion of the Chicago Fair. It is during the 1890s that the Wildean vision came into literary vogue, a vision of “art-for-art's sake” which announced “All art should be quite useless” (Wilde 6), and claimed that art does not function as a source of a moral stabilizing discourse in a volatile world. It is during this period that, in the words of Heather L. Braun, “the emerging Aesthetic movement in literature and painting challenged writers to reject bourgeois values of moderation and progress in favor of erotic excess and nostalgia” (110).
To conclude, expressing a concern with the threats of popular music, Thomas Hardy's “The Fiddler” draws trajectories between music and market. Mop's music is depicted as diabolic because it seizes upon opportune economic conditions to create moral crises. Nevertheless, the text connects the dissemination of diabolic music to female dysfunctionality. Ostensibly, Car'line's character debunks the traditional Victorian image of womanhood; she does not even grieve over the disappearance of her daughter. While Ned tries desperately to rescue Carry and is outraged at Mop's “torturing” of the child through strenuous performances, Car'line's customary reply is “Don't ‘ee raft yourself so, Ned! You prevent my getting a bit o’ rest!” (509). An unteachable female, neither her rural life nor her urban experience in London cure her of her irrational convulsive reactions and bestow on her a coherent selfhood. An aspect of Car'line dysfunctionality seems to be her attraction to one who is utterly un-English. As an intruding trickster, Mop might throw into relief the binaries of alien/native and immoral/moral; nevertheless, the melophilia of Car'line collapses these binaries, rendering the moral perspective in the text opaque and further complicating the reader's perception of Mop, as his trickstery loses its aura of total evil. The tone of the narrator might be suffused with a conservatism that is fixated on highlighting the promiscuous turn of popular entertainment, yet it points to an inevitable fluid worldliness that is becoming increasingly an integral aspect of the modern worldview; it, moreover, emphasizes the fact that the market mandates are the ultimate givers of cultural forms, and therein lies the relevance of Hardy's tale to our postmodern times.
