Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:07:00.505Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Inflow-shear-induced wake asymmetry links axial force oscillations to vertical wake meandering in active wake control

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 September 2026

Xinming Yang
Affiliation:
The State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Zhaobin Li*
Affiliation:
The State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Xiaolei Yang
Affiliation:
The State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Guowei He
Affiliation:
The State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Zhaobin Li, zhaobin.li@imech.ac.cn

Abstract

Content of image described in text.

This study investigates the impacts of inflow shear on wind-turbine wakes in active wake control through a resolvent-based input–output model and large-eddy simulation (LES). The input–output model, i.e. the proposed regular perturbation resolvent (RP-Resolvent) model, provides an efficient framework for analysing the underlying mechanism, while LES provides a high-fidelity comparison. The RP-Resolvent model adopts a two-parameter regular perturbation expansion of the incompressible Navier–Stokes equations around an axisymmetric baseline wake flow, to describe the wake response under the combined action of inflow shear and time-harmonic axial rotor forcing. Analysis using the RP-Resolvent model indicates a key mechanism: inflow-shear-induced asymmetry affects wake evolution via the coupling of azimuthal modes, which generates extra volumetric forcing in the entire wake region with azimuthal structures different from the rotor forcing and alters the spatial pattern of the wake’s coherent motion. Such a mechanism is tested using dynamic induction control under sheared inflow. A counterintuitive mode transition is observed, i.e. axisymmetric rotor forcing due to axial induction control triggers vertical meandering, contrasting with the axisymmetric pulsating motion observed under uniform inflow, with meandering intensity increasing with shear rate. Large-eddy simulation confirms that the model correctly predicts the spatial pattern of coherent structures and the sensitive frequencies, and reveals significant wake-recovery enhancement. This work offers new physical insights into wind-farm flow control, suggesting that atmospheric shear can be exploited to amplify control effectiveness and increase vertical mixing.

JFM classification

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Framework of the present work. Here B.C. denotes boundary condition.

Figure 1

Table 1.Rotor-forcing coefficients associated with individual monomials in the two-parameter expansion.Table 1 long description.

Figure 2

Figure 2.The base flow of wind-turbine wake u¯B$\bar {\boldsymbol{u}}_{\!B}$ on the vertical plane: (a)$(a)$ streamwise velocity component, (b)$(b)$ vertical velocity component.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Spatial mode of the harmonic streamwise rotor forcing: (a)$(a)$ first-order forcing f^ϵ0δ1,x$\hat {f}_{\!\epsilon ^0\delta ^1,x}$ and (b)$(b)$ second-order forcing f^ϵ1δ1,x$\hat {f}_{\!\epsilon ^1\delta ^1,x}$. Normalised by U hub2$U^2_{\text{ hub}}$. The dashed circle indicates the rotor boundary.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Predicted wake responses from the RP-Resolvent model for uniform inflow (left column) and sheared inflow (ϵ=0.1$\epsilon = 0.1$, right column) subjected to harmonic axial forcing at three Strouhal numbers: St$St$ = 0.10, 0.25 and 0.50 (top to bottom). Isosurfaces of streamwise velocity fluctuations are shown in red (positive) and blue (negative), illustrating the coherent structures within the rotor wake at the forcing frequency.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Wake response at St=0.25$St = 0.25$ in the vertical central plane at y=0$y = 0$ (ϵ=0.1,δ=0.04$\epsilon =0.1,\delta =0.04$). (a,b$a,b$) First-order harmonic response ϵ0δ1u^ϵ0δ1$\epsilon ^0\delta ^1 \hat {\boldsymbol{u}}_{\!\epsilon ^0\delta ^1}$; (c,d$c,d$) shear-induced first-order mean-flow modification ϵ1δ0uϵ1δ0$\epsilon ^1\delta ^0 \boldsymbol{u}_{\!\epsilon ^1\delta ^0}$; (e,f$e,f$) second-order harmonic response ϵ1δ1u^ϵ1δ1$\epsilon ^1\delta ^1 \hat {\boldsymbol{u}}_{\!\epsilon ^1\delta ^1}$; (g,h$g,h$) spatial mode of the total response at the forcing frequency.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Wake response mode to the two source terms in the ϵ1δ1$\epsilon ^1\delta ^1$ subproblem: (a,b)$(a,b)$ response to the second-order rotor-forcing modification; (c,d)$(c,d)$ response to the nonlinear volumetric forcing from first-order cross-interaction.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Wake response in the hub-height plane (xOy$xOy$) at ϵ=0.1$\epsilon = 0.1$ and St=0.25$St = 0.25$. (a$a$) Streamwise velocity u^x$\hat {u}_x$; (b$b$) spanwise velocity u^y$\hat {u}_y$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Wake response predicted by RP-Resolvent model at St=0.25$St=0.25$ in the vertical central plane (xOz$xOz$) for different inflow-shear rates ϵ$\epsilon$: (a,b$a,b$) ϵ=0$\epsilon =0$; (c,d$c,d$) ϵ=0.1$\epsilon =0.1$; (e,f$e,f$) ϵ=0.2$\epsilon =0.2$. Left column: streamwise velocity components u^x$\hat {u}_x$. Right column: vertical velocity components u^z$\hat {u}_z$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Energy norm of coherent structures at x=8D$x=8D$ for cases with different Strouhal numbers St$St$ and shear rates ϵ$\epsilon$ predicted by RP-Resolvent model.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Schematic of the computational domain.

Figure 11

Table 2.Parameter space for the LES study.Table 2 long description.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Comparison of linear-shear profiles (solid lines) defined using the shear rate ϵ$\epsilon$ and power-law profiles (dashed lines) defined using the shear exponent α$\alpha$, matched by equal velocity gradients at hub height. Here, z0$z_0$ is the ground level, z hub$z_{\text{ hub}}$ is the hub height and D$D$ is the rotor diameter, which are defined for the IEA 15-MW wind turbine.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Instantaneous streamwise velocity deficit (Δux/U hub$\Delta u_x / U_{\!\text{ hub}}$) in the vertical central plane (y=0$y=0$) under combined inflow shear and DIC forcing. Columns correspond to shear rates ϵ=0.0,0.1,0.2$\epsilon = 0.0, 0.1, 0.2$ (left to right); rows correspond to forcing frequencies St=0.10,0.25,0.50$St = 0.10, 0.25, 0.50$ (second to fourth rows), with the top row showing baseline cases without forcing. Orange dash-dotted lines indicate instantaneous wake centrelines.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Streamwise variation of the standard deviation of the vertical wake centreline displacement (σzc(x)/D$\sigma _{z_c}(x)/D$) in the vertical central plane. (a$a$) Baseline (unforced) wake. (b$b$–d$d$) Forced wake at St=0.10$St = 0.10$, 0.25$0.25$ and 0.50$0.50$. The purple arrow indicates increasing ϵ$\epsilon$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Vertical component of the coherent structures (u^z/U hub$\hat {u}_z / U_{\!\text{ hub}}$) in the vertical central plane (y=0$y=0$), extracted by FFT at the forcing frequency. Columns: inflow-shear rate ϵ=0.0,0.1,0.2$\epsilon = 0.0, 0.1, 0.2$; rows: DIC frequencies St=0.10,0.25,0.50$St = 0.10, 0.25, 0.50$.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Same as figure 14, for the streamwise velocity component (u^x/U hub$\hat {u}_x / U_{\!\text{ hub}}$).

Figure 17

Figure 16.Spanwise velocity component of the coherent structures (u^y/U hub$\hat {u}_y/U_{\!\text{ hub}}$) in the hub-height plane. For other details, see figure 14.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Streamwise velocity component of the coherent structures (u^x/U hub$\hat {u}_x/U_{\!\text{ hub}}$) in the hub-height plane. For other details, see figure 14.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Figure 18 long description.Time-averaged velocity deficit (Δu¯x/U hub$\Delta \overline {u}_x / U_{\!\text{ hub}}$) in the vertical central plane (y=0$y=0$) for cases with different shear rates (ϵ$\epsilon$) and DIC frequencies (St$St$). Contours show the velocity deficit at 0.50 (dashed), 0.35 (dashed–dotted) and 0.20 (dotted).

Figure 20

Figure 19.Streamwise variation of the time-and-space-averaged streamwise velocity deficit ΔU~x/U hub$\Delta \widetilde {U}_x/U_{\!\text{ hub}}$ averaged within a rotor-sweeping area (r⩽0.5D$ r \leqslant 0.5D$). (a$a$) Baseline (unforced) wake. (b−d$b{-}d$) Forced wake at St=0.10$St = 0.10$, 0.25$0.25$ and 0.50$0.50$. The purple arrow indicates increasing ϵ$\epsilon$.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Streamwise variation of the mean wake half-width W1/2(x)/D$W_{1/2}(x)/D$ in the vertical central plane (y=0$y=0$). (a$a$) Baseline (unforced) wake. (b$b$–d$d$) Forced wake at St=0.10$St=0.10$, 0.25$0.25$ and 0.50$0.50$. In each panel, curves correspond to different inflow-shear rates (ϵ=0,0.1,0.2$\epsilon =0, 0.1, 0.2$). The purple arrow indicates increasing ϵ$\epsilon$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Reynolds shear stress τxz/U hub2$\tau _{xz}/U^2_{\text{ hub}}$ distribution in the vertical central plane (y=0$y=0$) for cases with different shear rates (ϵ$\epsilon$) and DIC frequencies (St$St$).

Figure 23

Figure 22.Comparison of the streamwise distributions of the spanwise-averaged Reynolds shear stress τ~xz=−⟨ux′uz′¯⟩y$\widetilde {\tau }_{xz}=-\langle \overline {u_x'u_z'}\rangle _y$, where ⟨⋅⟩y=(1/D)∫−D/2D/2(⋅)dy$\langle \boldsymbol{\cdot }\rangle _y = ({1}/{D})\int ^{D/2}_{-D/2}(\boldsymbol{\cdot })\mathrm{d}y$, evaluated at the upper and lower rotor-edge elevations (z=±0.5D$z=\pm 0.5D$). (a)$(a)$ Baseline (unforced) wake. (b)$(b)$ Forced wake at St=0.25$St=0.25$. Lines with τ~xz>0$\widetilde {\tau }_{xz} \gt 0$ are obtained at the upper wake edge, while lines with τ~xz<0$\widetilde {\tau }_{xz} \lt 0$ are obtained at the lower wake edge. The purple arrow indicates increasing ϵ$\epsilon$.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Comparison of the integrated mean kinetic energy budget terms for the unforced and St=0.25$St=0.25$ cases under different inflow-shear rates. Baseline (unforced) (a−c)$(a-c)$, St=0.25$St=0.25$(d−f)$(d-f)$; ϵ=0$\epsilon =0$(a,d)$(a,d)$, ϵ=0.1$\epsilon =0.1$(b,e)$(b,e)$, ϵ=0.2$\epsilon =0.2$(c,f)$(c,f)$. Here, MC$MC$, PT$PT$, TC$TC$, DF$DF$, TP$TP$ and DP$DP$ denote the mean convection, pressure transport, turbulent convection, diffusion, turbulence production and dissipation terms, respectively.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Energy norm of coherent structures at x=8D$x=8D$ for cases with different Strouhal numbers St$St$ and shear rates ϵ$\epsilon$ obtained by LESs. Yellow area: intermediate-frequency regime; blue area: low-frequency (left) and high-frequency (right) regime.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Contours of the vertical velocity component of coherent structures (u^z/U hub$\hat {u}_z/U_{\!\text{ hub}}$) in the vertical central plane from (a)$(a)$ LES, (b)$(b)$ RP-Resolvent and (c)$(c)$ Axisym-Resolvent, along with streamwise profiles of u^z/U hub$\hat {u}_z/U_{\!\text{ hub}}$ extracted at (d)$(d)$ the lower wake edge z=−0.5D$z = -0.5D$, (e)$(e)$ the wake centreline z=0$z = 0$ and (f)$(f)$ the upper wake edge z=0.5D$z = 0.5D$. Forcing frequency St=0.25$St = 0.25$, inflow shear ϵ=0.1$\epsilon =0.1$.

Figure 27

Figure 26.Comparison of vertical velocity component of coherent structures (u^z$\hat {u}_z$) contours in the vertical central plane: LES (a−c$a{-}c$), RP-Resolvent model (d−f$d{-}f$), Axisym-Resolvent model (g−i$g{-}i$); ϵ=0$\epsilon =0$ (a,d,g$a,d,g$), ϵ=0.1$\epsilon =0.1$ (b,e,h$b,e,h$), ϵ=0.2$\epsilon =0.2$ (c,f,i$c,f,i$). Forcing frequency at St=0.25$St=0.25$.

Figure 28

Figure 27.Same as figure 26 for the streamwise velocity component.

Figure 29

Figure 28.Comparison of vertical velocity component (u^z$\hat {u}_z$) of coherent structures in vertical central plane: LES (a−c$a{-}c$), RP-Resolvent model (d−f$d{-}f$), Axisym-Resolvent model (g−i$g{-}i$); St=0.10$St=0.10$ (a,d,g$a,d,g$), St=0.25$St=0.25$ (b,e,h$b,e,h$), St=0.50$St=0.50$ (c,f,i$c,f,i$). Shear rate at ϵ=0.1$\epsilon =0.1$.

Figure 30

Figure 29.Same as figure 28 for the streamwise velocity component.

Figure 31

Figure 30.Coherent structure in the vertical central plane for the cases with synthetic turbulent inflow predicted by LES. Subplots (a−c)$(a-c)$ represent the uncontrolled baseline case, (d−f)$(d-f)$ represent the cases with DIC at St=0.25$St = 0.25$ with δ=0.04$\delta = 0.04$; subplots (g−i)$(g-i)$ represent the cases with DIC at St=0.25$St = 0.25$ with δ=0.08$\delta = 0.08$; turbulence-intensity levels T1=2.5%$T1=2.5\,\%$(a,d,g)$(a,d,g)$, T2=5.0%$T2=5.0\,\%$(b,e,h)$(b,e,h)$ and T3=7.5%$T3 = 7.5\,\%$(c,f,i)$(c,f,i)$. Shear rate ϵ=0.2$\epsilon =0.2$.

Figure 32

Figure 31.Coherent structure in the vertical central plane predicted by RP-Resolvent model. The resolvent operator is established with time-averaged baseline wake flow computed from LES with different turbulence intensities without inflow shear. The DIC forcing is at St=0.25$St=0.25$ and δ=0.04$\delta =0.04$ and δ=0.08$\delta =0.08$ and turbulence intensity modelled as random volumetric forcings. Shear rate ϵ=0.2$\epsilon =0.2$.