Fejfer's study seeks to break new ground as the first book devoted primarily to the reconstruction of the social-historical and physical context of portraits. In this it differs from the bulk of scholarship in the field, which focuses on typological categorization of portraits or addresses broad and abstract changes of period style in portraiture. F.'s aims are certainly worthy ones, and only the most encyclopaedically well-informed specialist in Roman portraiture would not find new and interesting information and ideas here. That said, the quality of F.'s work is very uneven indeed.
The strength of F.'s study lies in her attentive and thoughtful examination of the immediately material circumstances of portraiture. Readers will find excellent accounts of the varying character of portrait bases; of the different material categories of portrait (painted, miniature, bronze and white marble, coloured marble, terracotta, wood, mosaic and so on); of their formats and the historical development of such formats (herm-shafts, tondos, various types of bust). These are all exceptionally well illustrated, in particular with helpful photographs from unusual angles, permitting one to see, for example, the different kinds of cutting characteristic of the heads inserted into different types of support. Equally valuable are F.'s interesting discussions of the rather shaky foundations of accepted typologies of imperial portraiture and of the reconstruction of workshops, in both cases grounded in excellent close visual analysis of portraits from good archaeological contexts.
Her explorations of the broader social and historical contexts of Roman portraiture are, however, less compelling. She seeks to explain late Republican verism as the simple entailment of (a) realistic wax funerary masks and (b) heightened political competition within Italian municipia in the second half of the first century B.C. The former predate the emergence of verism by well over a century, while the latter postdates by at least sixty years what F. regards as the earliest secure date for the beginnings of verism. Consequently (perhaps predictably — cf. JRS 90 (2000), 18–50), I am unable to understand why she finds the arguments for a link between the broadly synchronous (later second century B.C.) development of verism (and nudity) in Roman portraiture and the use of portraits in the context of relations between Roman patrons and Greek client communities (setting up portraits in Rome and Italy, as well as Greece) so chronologically problematic (263–5). Here, as elsewhere, F.'s judgements and arguments concerning social and historical contexts seem rather arbitrary. Part of the difficulty is theoretical and conceptual. F. seems unaware of the considerable discussions of the problematic character of the concept ‘context’ in recent art history, archaeology and cultural studies. F. never adequately defines or unpacks her key concepts: social context and identity. Consequently, her comprehensive knowledge of the now numerous studies of groups of statue bases from different times and places does not take us much beyond rather bitty summaries of the results of these earlier studies. What is called for is more selective and strategic secondary analysis of some of those studies, with a more carefully specified understanding of ‘social context’, using systematic comparison to bring out the many different levels and modes of social structuring of portraiture as an institution.
The most disappointing feature of the book is the carelessness of the author in matters of referencing, particularly of literary sources. Time and again, very specific claims are made with reference to literary sources (‘Ovid describes … Philostratos commented’) that are not cited. Secondary sources are sometimes offered as substitute, but often without a specific page reference to facilitate tracking down the primary source. A claim about the use of portraits in glass-paste or on painted glass disks as objects of exchange between lovers is made on the basis of a reference to Cicero, whom F. does not cite, referring us instead to a secondary source (172). This repeats the general claim (slightly differently — cameos) but again without the specific source citation (Ad Att. 6.1). Scholarship degenerates into a game of Chinese whispers, each account taking us further from what is strictly warranted by the original text. This mentions simply imagunculae, a term attested only in two other contexts, and referring in the only case where it is clearly specified to a small bronze image, a statuette or bust (OLD). When we do get specific citations, these are too often wrong — copied inaccurately from secondary sources. Arrian's Periplus of the Euxine (correctly cited by Hannestad, to whom F. refers) becomes his Discourses of Epictetus in F., discussing the portrait of Hadrian at Trapezos (505, n. 186).
Some responsibility must lie with the publisher since the book does not seem to have been copy-edited or proof-read to normal standards. Not counting the missing references, even an unsystematic collection of errata runs to five pages single-spaced, comprising several hundred items. ‘Tetrarchs’ is spelt wrongly in three different ways. Latin and Greek are often incorrect. Names, titles and dates in the references and bibliography include numerous errors (P. Stuart for P. Stewart throughout; ‘L’Arte Romana nel Centro del Povere’ for ‘Centro del Potere’ (Bianchi Bandinelli), etc.). A lack of concern for accuracy and detail also informs the handling of epigraphic and sometimes even archaeological evidence. On p. 286, the text of an inscription as transcribed by F. does not match that in the reconstruction drawing (fig. 220) of the portrait in its context (Fundiliae C.F. Patronae vs. Fundilia etc.). The name of the subject of the accompanying male statue is spelt in three different ways in F.'s transcription, the reconstruction drawing, and lastly the photo of the statue base (pl. 29b) which allows the reader to make the necessary corrections. In other instances, where one has no photograph at hand, it is clear that F. has mistranscribed an inscription because the Latin makes no sense (e.g. p. 67 fonendem), and one can track back to the original source (ponendam CIL XIV.353). A claim about the recycling of portraits for their material value beyond the edges of the Empire is made on the basis of ‘a third century silver portrait head in miniature … found in Denmark’ (173 with n. 129), but with no reference readers cannot validate date, find spot, or how the portrait has been treated: such ‘evidence’ is useless for the purposes of research.
The pervasive character of these shortcomings — mistranscriptions, mistranslations, miscitations — rather undermines the confidence of the reader in the evidentiary basis for F.'s claims, particularly when left to take her word for the existence of statements in specific sources which she fails to reference. I would certainly like to read the third-century text which, according to F., tells us that ‘wax images were sent to cities around the Empire from wherever the emperor was; they were treated as if it were the emperor himself who had arrived’ and ‘suggests that wax was used because it could act as a realistic substitute for a person’ (175). But the authority cited (MacCormack, Art and Ceremony (1981), 67–73) does not mention wax, nor do any of the third-century texts in her footnotes seem to discuss these wax images. As it stands it is impossible to verify F.'s claim.
It is a shame that the really strong aspects of F.'s contribution should be so much occluded by the shortcomings of other aspects and stages of the volume's production. The sections on the artefactual aspects of portraiture, and the discussions of workshop structure and of the typologies of Roman imperial portraiture break new ground and are by a long way the best discussions of these issues in English. They will surely be required reading for university courses on Roman portraiture. It would be very welcome if the publisher could bring out a corrected and properly referenced second edition of this book.
