As a singer the American young woman is a success. Her innate ambition, her pervading mentality, nervous temperament, and her superior training and heredity in the direction of independence, combine to afford her a personality which, when a good voice happens to go with it, as it often does, makes her one of the most stirring singers to be heard in any part of the world.Footnote 1
Emma Juch was no Adelina Patti. She was never feted in the capitals of Europe, nor did she sing in the Continent's great opera houses or earn enough to build a castle in Wales. Unlike her famous American contemporaries such as Lillian Nordica or Geraldine Farrar, Juch has been forgotten since her heyday in the 1880s and 1890s. By examining the life and work of someone like Juch (1860–1939)—a successful vocalist, but one with a more typical career than the towering prima donnas—the complexities of American cultural life and the powerful and often contradictory prejudices of her time come clearly into focus. The American public was at once nationalistic, but also distrustful of performers without European credentials. Proud of their strong women, Americans were also anxious that females would transgress traditional social boundaries. Juch's solution—to create an image of a strong, vibrant American artist who still understood her “proper” place as a woman—reveals some of the strategies prima donnas employed in response to these competing pressures. Her career also illustrates the fraught cultural position of opera performed in English translation. In 1885, when she joined the American Opera Company, English-language opera was popular among the middle class, but was already increasingly disdained by elite audiences and critics. Indeed, these attitudes led to the financial collapse of the two biggest English-language opera companies active at the end of the nineteenth-century—the American Opera Company and her own Emma Juch English Grand Opera Company. The reasons behind the failure of her troupe open a window into the market and social forces that shaped opera's place in American culture and also affected Juch's professional life.
Although many American singers traded on their nationality when creating their public personae, each also had to differentiate herself from other prima donnas within the crowded entertainment scene in the United States. For instance, Emma Abbott (1849–91) emphasized her middle-class morality, Yankee “can-do” pluck, and a desire to please her audiences, whereas Clara Louise Kellogg (1842–1916) took on the nickname “The Flower Prima Donna” and highlighted her support of opera in English in order to bring the genre to “the people.” Many other American-born performers went the other way and, at least to some degree, tried to hide their origins. Lillian Norton (1857–1914) studied in Europe and came home with the new name of Lillian Nordica; Pauline Elhasser (1862–1920), from Syracuse, New York, returned to the United States after her training in Dresden calling herself Pauline L'Allemand; and Giovanni Perugini (1855–1914) was really John Chatterton from Michigan. Juch was born in Austria but raised in the United States. She portrayed herself as both a “good” American and a striving immigrant who benefited from ties to the Austro-German musical traditions that were revered by many critics and music lovers in the United States.
Before the 1880s, opera was widely seen as an entertainment—a nice diversion for an evening out, grander than other theatrical genres such as operetta or comedies perhaps, but not high art. Opera in foreign languages had fallen out of favor with middle-class audiences in the 1870s. They turned to opera in English as a cheaper, but also somehow more American, alternative to the expensive performances in foreign languages they connected with Europe and the upper social classes—unwelcome associations after the Panic of 1873 and the xenophobia that followed. By the mid-1880s, the wealthy audience, whose members had rebounded and gained numbers after the Long Depression that resulted from the Panic of 1873, turned to opera in foreign languages as one method to create an American elite class.Footnote 2 As Wagner's music gained popularity in the 1880s and 1890s, however, opera's place in American culture began to change as some critics and musicians began to think of opera, or at least German opera, as high art.Footnote 3
Interpreting Juch's Biography
Emma Antonia Joanna Juch was born on 4 July 1860 in Vienna.Footnote 4 Her parents were naturalized American citizens who briefly lived in the Austrian capital (probably 1860–62) before returning to the United States and settling in New York City.Footnote 5 Juch studied voice as a teenager with the prominent teacher Adelina Murio-Celli before the British opera impresario Colonel James Henry Mapleson hired her to sing with Her Majesty's Italian Opera Company in 1881.Footnote 6 Joining his company was an important step in Juch's career; Mapleson's troupe was known for its excellent singers—important American divas including Emma Abbott, Minnie Hauk, Clara Louise Kellogg, and Emma Nevada worked with him.Footnote 7 Juch's professional relationship with Mapleson was not an easy one, and after touring Great Britain and the United States with the company she resigned in early 1883. Mapleson sued Juch for breach of contract, and even obtained an injunction in January 1883 preventing her from performing for anyone else.Footnote 8 Juch, however, had powerful family friends, and with the help of William Steinway, head of the famous piano manufacturing company, the injunction was quickly vacated.Footnote 9 Wasting no time, Juch began appearing in concerts in New York City in February.Footnote 10
Juch's next important opportunity came when she sang with the Theodore Thomas Orchestra during its 1884 and 1885 national concert tours.Footnote 11 Over the summer of 1885, Juch was hired as one of the prima donnas in the ill-fated English-language American Opera Company; that troupe went bankrupt and was reorganized as the National Opera Company in 1887 before collapsing entirely in June of that year. Juch and Charles E. Locke, the former manager of the American and National Opera Companies, continued to work together—first in a restructured National Opera Company without Theodore Thomas but with some of the same singers and repertoire (September 1887 to spring 1888), then in the first Emma Juch Operatic Concert Company (the end of 1888), followed by the Juch-Perotti Concert Company (spring 1889), and finally the Emma Juch English Grand Opera Company (which began traveling in the fall of 1889). Juch never sang opera again after her troupe disbanded in June 1892. Two years later, in June 1894, at the age of thirty-three, she married a prominent New York attorney, Francis Wellman, and for the next decade sang only in concerts and festivals. Although she and Wellman did not have children before their divorce in 1911, she maintained a relationship with Wellman's children from his first marriage who, along with her ex-husband, attended her funeral.Footnote 12 She died at age seventy-eight in her New York City apartment on 6 March 1939 following a cerebral hemorrhage.
Thousands of articles about Juch appeared in newspapers and magazines during her lifetime, but she left virtually no archival trace. With the exception of a few rather uninformative letters, there is little extant documentation of her life and career outside of accounts provided by the press.Footnote 13 Therefore, almost all of the available information about the singer has been mediated in some form. In the absence of such personal documents as letters or diaries, everything in print must be scrutinized carefully, since much of what was reported in the media was intended to sell the prima donna (and newspapers) to the public. Factual accuracy was often a casualty of such an approach. Of course, Juch certainly controlled at least some aspects of her image and had a role in its creation. The challenge in biographical research for subjects like Juch, then, is to look behind the published stories and read between the lines.Footnote 14
Like all prima donnas, Juch had to establish an image that would appeal to the public and reassure them that she was not transgressing traditional gender roles as much as it might first appear. During the nineteenth century, social norms dictated that women should remain protected in the private sphere where they were expected to oversee the home, raise their children, and provide an impeccable moral example for their husbands. According to historian Barbara J. Harris, “the cult of true womanhood was a compound of four ideas: a sharp dichotomy between the home and the economic world outside that paralleled a sharp contrast between female and male natures, the designation of the home as the female's only proper sphere, the moral superiority of woman, and the idealization of her function as mother.”Footnote 15 As was true for many prima donnas of her time, Juch's life challenged each one of these concepts. Female singers during the late nineteenth century were not only the most important symbol of operatic vocal beauty, but also celebrities whose actions were scrutinized and gossiped about in a way very few male singers had to endure. Divas like Juch were firmly in the public sphere; she earned money and was required to be in close contact with men on stage and conduct business with them off stage. Such interactions jeopardized Juch's moral superiority over men and cast doubt on her femininity, which, in turn, endangered her respectability.Footnote 16 Moreover, Juch's peripatetic life as a touring diva and her status as a single woman without children raised suspicions about her commitment to traditional familial structures and values. Marked as a “New Woman,” she was viewed as one who might be willing to put her own happiness ahead of her “natural” roles of wife and mother.Footnote 17
Juch addressed such concerns through the story of her early vocal training. She mentioned in interviews that she wished to study music because she wanted to be a “great vocalist as was my grandmother.”Footnote 18 According to Juch, her father, a musician himself, did not want her to follow in his footsteps, and she was forced to take voice lessons in secret for two years.Footnote 19 Justin Juch learned about her singing only when he went to a student recital in which she appeared. His angry expression during the concert, and hasty departure immediately afterwards, convinced Juch that he disapproved of her musical ambitions. “Upon reaching him [at home] imagine my joy and surprise at being folded in his arms and hearing him upbraiding himself for his blindness and neglect.”Footnote 20 Juch used the tale, which she retold many times, to deliver a message to the public. She may have been strong willed and independent, but her love of singing grew from her commitment to her family that, despite being populated with musicians, shared the values of the middle class, as indicated by her father's resistance to her performing career.Footnote 21 Juch's stated reason for pursuing an operatic career (to be a great vocalist like her grandmother) furthermore suggested that she was drawn to music per se and not to the (immoral) stage, and that singing was a natural (i.e., God-given) gift inherited from her ancestors. The story that her performance during a single concert had overcome her father's doubts and turned him into her devoted ally helped mythologize the sheer power of her voice and musicality. Surely, this account implied, the reader should pay to hear such an impressive artist.Footnote 22 It was probably no accident that the account of her struggle to obtain musical training began to circulate when she was headlining her own company—the time when she had the most power, operated the furthest outside of the prevailing social norms, and most needed a narrative that counteracted nineteenth-century negative stereotypes about women on the stage.
An American Singer
Juch's creation myth fed into a larger narrative she perpetuated in the press, one that cast her as an exceptionally hard-working singer, representative of healthy, virtuous, and industrious American womanhood, as opposed to the allegedly lazy and undependable European singers who flooded the American stage. As a vocalist who spent the most successful part of her career performing opera in English translation, Juch needed to be seen as distinctively American because the discourse about English-language opera emphasized its importance in creating a national musical culture.
Although their reasoning was not new to the late nineteenth century, critics, performers, and impresarios saw at least three ways that English-language opera could stimulate the formation of an American musical culture, and these arguments framed how she and other prima donnas who performed in English shaped their public images. First, critics who supported opera in the vernacular had argued in the musical press since the 1860s that English-language performance would encourage the development of an American artistic style. As one writer explained in Appleton's Journal in 1875, such performances would be a “stimulus to the creative faculties of American musicians, which now lie latent or only feebly exhibited for want of a field.”Footnote 23 Secondly, singing in the vernacular was supposed to help establish opera as an authentic American art form for everyone, rather than an imported product from Europe primarily for the wealthy elite. “Opera, to be thoroughly enjoyed by the masses and to appeal specially to the popular taste,” asserted soprano Marie Roze in 1881, “must of necessity be rendered in English, the language of the country.”Footnote 24 Lastly, performing opera in English was one way to diminish the influence of European artists and music on American culture. Particularly after the trauma of the Civil War, the formation of an identifiably American culture was very important to many people. “We make our own clothes and furniture. We read American books by a very large majority. . . . Why is it not so with music?” asked critic and pedagogue W. S. B. Mathews in 1893.Footnote 25 Critics even encouraged audiences to view attendance at English-language performances as their patriotic duty in order to keep the possibility of American opera alive.Footnote 26 Many writers and singers, in fact, suggested that repeated exposure to the best American musical talent in operatic performance would help to combat the prejudice again native-born performers and composers. In 1886, George William Curtis, writing in Harper's New Monthly Magazine, stated confidently that the American Opera Company's English-language productions represented “another warble of American independence. Ever since our declaration of political independence we have been asserting it in other forms and relations, until this last and most melodious protest, which is the latest proof that [we have] come of age.”Footnote 27 Thus, to Curtis, opera in English was not only a symbol of musical independence from Europe, but also an indication that American musical culture had matured to the point that it had outgrown the need to rely on older foreign models.
Juch incorporated these ideas into the way she marketed her grand opera troupe. She emphasized the fact that many of her star singers were Americans, as were most of the members of her chorus, noting of the latter that “the fresh quality of its voices, its marvelous attaque, and the fact that it is mostly American, have been approvingly commended.”Footnote 28 In some interviews Juch discussed her interest in helping to develop an American operatic culture that welcomed everyone into the audience and valued opera performed in English. She encouraged people to support her troupe as an expression of their loyalty to the United States and the future of American music. No doubt Juch was mimicking the strategies that she saw used by Emma Abbott, one of the most successful opera singers in the United States during the 1880s, and also by Jeannette Thurber, founder of the American Opera Company.Footnote 29 After Juch's opera troupe folded, Henry W. Savage would use these same tactics for a series of English-language opera companies he managed between 1895 and 1911.Footnote 30
In addition to positioning her company as an American product, Juch also emphasized her native roots. She was so routinely described as the “foremost American soprano upon the operatic and concert stage” that it was probably a phrase suggested by her press agent.Footnote 31 Moreover, she compared herself to the healthy, active, pioneering American woman. Juch told young women, in an 1891 profile, that in order to become a great singer “one must possess splendid bodily health, and be ambitious and industrious . . . one must rise early, take plenty of outdoor exercise and frequent cold baths.” She went on to suggest daily calisthenics through long walks, and “light dumb-bell or indian-club exercise,” although she cautioned against overexertion.Footnote 32 At that time, physicians thought that excessive exercise caused sterility and disease.Footnote 33 Since before the Civil War, however, educators and social reformers had counseled women to keep fit through moderate calisthenics so they would be healthy enough to fulfill their vital duties as wives and mothers.Footnote 34 Thus, although Juch framed her comments as guidance for potential professional singers, she was echoing advice given to respectable middle-class women for decades. Along with the recommendations to exercise and get plenty of fresh air, Juch discouraged the “muffling-up that is practised by nearly all foreign singers who visit this country. They pass their lives in heated apartments, carefully excluding every draught of fresh air for fear they may take cold and be unable to sing.”Footnote 35 Here she contrasted her vigorous life style (which she claimed was the reason that she never missed a performance due to illness) with the cosseted and confined hothouse life of the stereotypical European singer. The subtext that her healthy American way of life was superior to her foreign rivals was hard to miss.
A European Singer
Because of the transatlantic and cosmopolitan nature of fin de siècle musical culture in the United States, Juch still maintained, and sometimes even publicized, her ties to Europe. Due to the American high regard for the quality of European musicians, all native performers who began their careers in the late nineteenth century had to provide European credentials in order to gain credibility with their home country's audience.Footnote 36 As critic Alan Dale explained in 1890, “American girls with splendid vocal equipments [sic] cross the ocean and do Europe pretty thoroughly before they venture to set foot again on their native heath. . . . Even then they have to contend with those who have had the advantages of foreign birth.”Footnote 37 Furthermore, many musical groups working in the United States had direct ties with musical institutions and traditions that originated across the Atlantic.
Juch made her professional debut in New York on 28 November 1880 in a Liederkranz concert with Sebastian Bach Mills on piano and the society's orchestra conducted by Agriol Paur. The Liederkranz, founded in 1847 by German immigrants and still operating today, was one of New York's most important musical and social organizations in the nineteenth century.Footnote 38 Juch's earliest operatic experience came in 1881 and 1882, when she sang French, German, and Italian repertoire in Italian with Mapleson's troupe, Her Majesty's Italian Opera Company. Some writers in the early 1880s pointed out that Juch was the first vocalist taught entirely in America to be hired by a European opera company, but she never stressed this fact in her own publicity. Nor did she emphasize that Murio-Celli was her only instructor when recounting her background in interviews. She wanted to be seen as an American singer, but potential audience members likely would have thought that she was not well trained if they realized that she had never studied in Paris or Italy. Of course, many people may have assumed that she had studied in Austria because of her Viennese birth.
Because Juch was among the first significant cohort of American performers to work with major European opera companies, many critics positioned her as part of the first generation of native divas.Footnote 39 Alan Dale wrote of Juch,
There is a joyous star-spangled-bannerism about Miss Emma Juch that is positively pleasant to contemplate. The days when the divine but dollaresque Patti can float over to American shores and demand five thousand for a single warble, are surely passing away. American singers will soon be recognized all over the world, and even in their own country, I believe. The vocal superiority of the American is being rapidly recognized. And it is just such delightful young women as Miss Emma Juch who will win over the foreignly-disposed minds of their own countrymen.Footnote 40
Juch played a very delicate game with her nationality. She traded on her Americanness as a way to establish her English-language company as equal to the best foreign-language troupes of the day. Yet she was also Austrian, a useful asset given the prejudice against native singers.Footnote 41 The strong German presence in American musical life encouraged Juch to publicize her birthplace so she could plausibly claim to be part of the “great army of German musicians” who had made immeasurable contributions to the musical life of the nation.Footnote 42 Many of the most important music critics in the United States were dedicated Wagnerians who relentlessly promoted German music and musicians, as well as Wagner's ideas about opera. Although Juch wanted to be America's prima donna, it was to her advantage to remind people that her legacy was firmly in the Austro-German musical tradition.
At the same time, Juch could use her foreign origins to claim solidarity with her fellow Americans by emphasizing that she was an immigrant like so many others in the United States. “Although I am Austrian by birth and only American by adoption,” she pointed out in an interview, “I have given everything to try to make American opera a prosperous issue.”Footnote 43 In this statement, she identified with, and signaled her participation in, the quest for assimilation important to so many immigrants, while still acknowledging another national identity. The New York Times’ critic, William J. Henderson, described her as “so delightfully German in her innocent American way.”Footnote 44 Juch was thus able to have it both ways. She was an Austrian and an American, and could pivot between national identities as the situation demanded.
Juch and the American Opera Company
Jeannette Thurber, a wealthy American musical patron, asked Theodore Thomas in 1885 to conduct a new opera company she was forming. With its approximately 325 members, the American Opera Company (AOC) was huge and designed to prove that opera in English could be performed by American singers for American audiences with the same production values and profit margins as a foreign-language company. Thurber envisioned the troupe as one part of a much more ambitious plan to create a distinctively American musical culture. Along with the opera troupe, she founded the National Conservatory of Music in New York to provide excellent training for American musicians. She hoped to create subsidiary operatic and educational institutions in the largest cities in the United States to spread her vision throughout the nation.Footnote 45
The AOC failed spectacularly. Only a year after its premiere in January 1886, the company went bankrupt, reorganizing as the National Opera Company (NOC) to try to protect its backers from the AOC's debts. In June 1887, the NOC collapsed when the manager, Charles E. Locke, ran out of money to pay the orchestra and Thomas finally left the group, even though he was owed $18,000 in back pay. The lawsuits demanding payment by theater owners, various merchants, and singers (including Juch) went on for years. Critics would point to the failure of the AOC for decades to come as proof that English-language opera was not financially viable in the United States.Footnote 46
Juch's experiences with the AOC and NOC foreshadowed the problems she encountered when she founded her own company in 1889. First, the gossip and criticism aimed at her while she was in the AOC, as well as her response to the negative publicity, show the challenges prima donnas in prominent companies faced. Her decision to answer her critics, both through proxies and on her own behalf, was more unusual, however, and showed a determination and commanding personality that is sometimes hard to see through the intense mediation of the American press. Second, Juch repeated many of the business decisions that led to the demise of the AOC in her own company. She, along with Locke, Thurber, and Thomas, did not seem to understand fully the business and cultural environment within which they had to work.
According to press reports, Emma Juch was the first singer hired for the AOC, probably sometime in the early summer of 1885.Footnote 47 She claimed in 1889 that she had to choose between the opportunity to sing English-language opera with Theodore Thomas and an offer from Leopold Damrosch to sing in German-language productions at the Metropolitan Opera House. Footnote 48 In reality, this could not have been the case because Damrosch's proposal was reported in the papers in September 1884 (just prior to the Metropolitan's second season), long before Thurber was hiring the AOC's staff. Juch probably turned down Damrosch in order to continue her concert work, including prestigious engagements with the Boston Symphony Orchestra and other ensembles, as well as another cross-country tour with Theodore Thomas. It may have seemed an obvious choice to Juch to pursue her concert career and sing with Thomas instead of moving to the Metropolitan, for that company had just finished a financially disastrous inaugural season that resulted in the termination of manager Henry Abbey and the troupe's subsequent transition from Italian- to German-language opera. In addition, the Metropolitan's approach—to spend most of the season in New York City before a relatively short national tour—was an unusual strategy for a grand opera company at a time when opera was usually performed by troupes that spent the entire season on the road. Given that the Metropolitan almost failed during its first season, it would have been a risky proposition to join a relatively new troupe using a business plan that had not succeeded the year before. Thomas, in contrast, was arguably the most famous classical musician in the country, and his orchestra was a stable institution that had flourished since the 1860s. He also seems to have taken a liking to her; during the run of the AOC, Thomas was accused several times of favoring Juch over the other singers, and he hired her to perform with his orchestra for many years after the AOC folded.Footnote 49
In a troupe that insisted they did not want any stars (one way they differentiated themselves from the celebrity-driven foreign-language companies), Juch was the best-known singer in the AOC. Reports quickly surfaced in the press that there was intense competition between the leading prima donnas in the troupe, which Thomas did nothing to alleviate. Inequitable treatment of singers by management was a common cause of dissention within opera companies.Footnote 50 As the financial problems of the organization deepened towards the end of 1886, the press began to look for a scapegoat to blame for the troupe's problems. Diego de Vivo, soprano Emmy Fursch-Madi's personal manager, charged that Juch's “pretentions and privileges” along with Thomas's “personal vanity . . . and enormous salary” were two reasons why the company was struggling. He went on to declare that “while Mrs. Thurber may be the power on the throne, Miss Juch is the power behind it” and that Thomas did everything he could to promote her. Charles E. Locke, the manager of the company, was (according to de Vivo) Juch's personal agent and was sacrificing the company in order to position Juch to start her own troupe the following year.Footnote 51 Two days after de Vivo's charges appeared in the Chicago Daily Tribune, a letter to the editor signed by Pauline L'Allemand, Jessie Bartlett Davis, Laura Moore, Cornelia Van Zanten, and Bertha Pierson (all singers in the AOC) was published in Chicago's Daily Inter Ocean refuting his accusations and declaring that
We have always found Miss Juch to be the most amiable, kind and unselfish of colleagues, our friend, personally and artistically, and also the staunch friend and well-wisher of Mme. Fursch-Madi. We, who have been brought into direct contact with Miss Juch, and have often been eye-witnesses to the most charming attentions and kindnesses bestowed by her upon Mme. Fursch-Madi—who is never brought into artistic conflict with Miss Juch—are surprised and shocked that Mr. De Vivo should permit himself to utter, circulate, or publish such untrue and malicious words about Miss Juch as have been openly and publicly made by him this week to the intended detriment of Miss Juch.Footnote 52
The daily press breathlessly followed the ups and downs of opera companies, and conflicts between singers were often the subject of gossipy articles. Given the newspapers’ inclination to sensationalize, it is impossible to know how accurate these stories were, but it certainly seems that Thomas showed overt favoritism towards Juch. In the competitive environment of a large opera company, with each singer vying for position and prestige, it is not hard to imagine that any hint of bias towards Juch could have caused friction.
Unlike some prima donnas, Juch was not above defending herself in the press (instead of leaving it to surrogates) if she thought she had been mistreated. After a particularly savage review by critic and conductor Arthur Weld of the Juch Company's performance of Carmen in Boston, she wrote a long letter to the editor answering each of Weld's charges.Footnote 53Carmen became so popular in America after its national premiere in 1878 that most sopranos were under enormous pressure to learn the part.Footnote 54 Critics loved to compare sopranos who attempted Carmen not only to each other, but also to iconic performances, usually by Minnie Hauk or, later, Emma Calvé.Footnote 55 Though Carmen's range was really too low for Juch to sing comfortably, the opera was simply too popular for Juch to leave out of her company's repertoire, and the burden of singing such a celebrated role that was unsuited to her voice might have been one reason she reacted so angrily to Weld's criticism of her interpretation. In her letter, Juch described her rather unusual understanding of the role of Carmen, in which she attempted to bring out the more respectable and feminine virtues of the character (see Figure 1). This reading, Juch stated, was based on intense study of the score and related materials. She even quoted excerpts from Prosper Mérimée's novella to prove her points. Explaining her idiosyncratic analysis of the part, she wrote:
Emma Juch in costume as Carmen. Undated, TCS 2 (Juch, Emma), Harvard Theatre Collection, Houghton Library, Harvard University.
Just how nearly Bizet intended that the Carmen of his opera should be the Carmen of Mérimée's novel, is a question that appears to me the artist should determine for herself, with the help from Bizet's score. It is thus that I have formulated my idea of Carmen, and, if my conception of the role involves the portrayal of a Carmen with touches of goodness and womanly feeling, all I can say is that I am sorry that my impersonation of the role, as compared with the more brutal portrayal of the character, should call out adverse criticism upon my efforts.Footnote 56
Clearly astonished and affronted that Juch would attack him in print, Weld published his own reply in which he disputed her reading of Mérimée, challenged the appropriateness of using source material to enrich the interpretation of a libretto, and—in a very condescending way—came close to calling her a liar. “Score reading is indeed an accomplishment which few women possess, and Miss Juch is to be complimented on having mastered the most difficult detail of technical music,” he wrote.Footnote 57 The dispute apparently ended there, but it was quite unusual that she was willing to go on the offensive against a critic. Musicologist Susan Rutherford notes that many women depicted their musical decisions as the result of instinctual judgments, perhaps to forestall charges of an unfeminine interest in intellectual pursuits.Footnote 58 Juch chose a different tack by portraying herself as a musical scholar who studied not just her own part, but also the full score, performance materials from and reviews of the premiere production, as well as antecedents of the libretto. Weld's review came at the beginning of her company's first year, and Juch may have considered it necessary to clarify her interpretation so that his opinions would not define the troupe's critical reception. If that was her goal, then her strategy apparently worked, because the review and resulting exchange were not reprinted in other papers.Footnote 59
Juch Moves to Center Stage
After the reorganized National Opera Company collapsed in April 1888, Locke and Juch quickly formed two operatic concert companies that each toured for a few months during the 1888–89 concert season.Footnote 60 Popular during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, concert companies were chamber ensembles consisting of a few singers and instrumentalists. They generally presented art and parlor songs and chamber music, and often ended their concerts with a costumed, but unstaged, performance of an act from a popular opera that could be sung by a few principal singers with a reduced accompaniment. When staffing these companies, Juch drew upon the network around Theodore Thomas, hiring instrumentalists who had worked closely with Thomas in the past, including cellist, conductor, and composer Victor Herbert, who served as music director for both groups.
It is not clear how much or what kind of control Juch had over either the concert companies or the opera troupe that bore her name. Many touring troupes were named after female singers, including Emma Abbott, Clara Louise Kellogg, Nellie Melba, and Caroline Richings.Footnote 61 Press reports and memoirs from singers who headlined their own groups suggest that women were often the artistic managers, but usually left the business management to others.Footnote 62 Juch's printed interviews indicate that Locke took care of all the financial matters, but that she chose the singers and presumably the repertoire. Popular female opera performers, such as Juch, whose celebrity already gave them influence within the opera house, were well positioned to convert their fame into the personal and financial power they needed to control at least some areas of their careers.Footnote 63
Juch used the launch of her concert company to rehabilitate her image, which had been damaged by the negative stories about feuds with other singers in the AOC and the catastrophic end to the company. Press coverage focused on her femininity, her national identity, and other admirable personal characteristics. A writer with the Milwaukee Sentinel described Juch's extensive collection of hairpins, as well as “her tasteful home [that] revels in bric-a-brac and is the center of a circle of cultured people, among whom are musicians, editors, artists, and a score of the brightest women in New York, who have become attracted and attached to the lovely singer.”Footnote 64 Despite the fact that she traveled much of the year, focusing on her home situated her where she “belonged”—in the private sphere entertaining her friends with her beautiful house and her hairpins. The article also highlighted her philanthropy, especially a recent concert to benefit impoverished musicians. Prima donnas often publicized their charitable work so as to show their feminine side (because women were expected to take part in altruistic activities), as well as to divert attention from their supposed greed.Footnote 65
Other articles invoked images of hardy Americans succeeding against all odds. For instance, according to a story in the St. Paul Daily Globe,
a recital of the incidents in the career of Emma Juch, who, as a concert singer, holds the first position in America, would fill a volume and unfold an interesting story of the endeavors of a brave girl seeking self-improvement and a high standard in musical art. Her work was of the most arduous character. Obstacles that would have crushed a less resolute girl melted into air before the calm determination of this young American.Footnote 66
Juch sounds like a character out of a Horatio Alger story in this quotation, and the fact that the challenges standing in the way of her success are unnamed makes them seem all the more formidable. As she had earlier in her career, Juch played to the patriotism of her audience with familiar tropes about the United States as the land of opportunity populated by vaguely heroic people living out the American dream.Footnote 67
Juch and the Business of Opera
The Emma Juch English Grand Opera Company (EJOC) premiered on 21 October 1889 in Philadelphia's Academy of Music, performing Faust by Charles Gounod. With between 100 and 150 members, the troupe was large for an English-language company (which typically had sixty to eighty performers), but was much smaller than the AOC or the NOC. The orchestra numbered up to fifty musicians, a big ensemble for traveling opera companies, which were often criticized for having underpowered accompaniments.Footnote 68 In comparison, the Metropolitan Opera Company was larger and traveled with an orchestra of seventy pieces. The EJOC toured throughout the United States as well as into Canada and Mexico.
The company lasted only three seasons (1889–92) and was never on firm financial footing. Within two months of the troupe's founding, theater manager H. C. Miner obtained a writ for $3,500 against the EJOC's scenery and costumes to force the company's manager Charles E. Locke to repay a loan Miner had given Locke to finance some of the company's start-up costs. Footnote 69 The papers were filled with accounts of the EJOC's financial insecurity—desperate creditors obtaining liens, singers refusing to perform unless they were first paid some of their back salaries, and railroads declining to transport the group unless they were compensated in advance.
The EJOC collapsed for the first time in May 1891 in St. Louis near the end of their second season.Footnote 70 The work Juch had done to shore up her image was undone quickly as several newspaper accounts painted her in a negative light. Drawing upon the stereotype of the greedy, unfeeling diva, the Chicago Daily Tribune reported that she was “the subject of much severe criticism at the hands of her associates, who say she was not at all concerned about their fate, but drew her salary regularly and then left them [in St. Louis] to get back to New York as best they could, sweetly adding in a note to the company that she hoped to meet them in the metropolis.”Footnote 71 Despite this setback, Juch and Locke put the company back together for the 1891–92 season. Almost immediately the papers reported they had come close to selling some of their scenery in order to pay the transportation bill. Financial woes followed the troupe as they traveled across the United States until it finally dissolved for good in California in June 1892.
In some ways the EJOC was different from the AOC. Thurber and Thomas attempted several new tactics that were unusual for the time, and Juch chose to return to more standard business practices. The AOC explicitly rejected the celebration of star singers, choosing instead to promote the quality of the company as a whole and the notion that the troupe's performances could be a culturally uplifting operatic experience in English. In contrast, like most other opera companies (English- or foreign-language), the EJOC used the allure of Juch's celebrity to attract audiences. During its first season, the AOC staged unusual repertory, singing relatively unknown works such as Gluck's Orpheus and Eurydice and Anton Rubinstein's Nero, rather than the fairly small number of canonic operas that most other companies performed.Footnote 72 Although critics often complained that impresarios were too reluctant to program new pieces, company managers insisted that performing favorites such as Carmen, Faust, and Il Trovatore was the only way to ensure large audiences. Indeed, on being asked about some of the EJOC's conventional repertory choices, Locke explained,
Do I think the public care a great deal about operatic novelties? It has not been my experience that they do. I am speaking particularly of grand opera, the class with which I have been most closely identified. The most popular works in France to-day are Faust, Carmen, and Mignon—that is, in the order named they are those most frequently performed. Of course, we must bring out new things occasionally, but for the surest attractions we have to fall back on the favorites that have been proved.Footnote 73
Locke and Juch followed the AOC's playbook, however, in other respects. They used many of the same singers and even bought the AOC's costumes and sets.Footnote 74 Juch, like Thurber, was committed to the notion that her opera troupe could be part of an exciting American musical culture that relied on native-born performers. Even more importantly, Juch and Thurber both sought to attract the wealthy, educated audience that typically attended foreign-language opera. Juch understood the value of Abbott's evocation of the hardworking American triumphing over difficult odds to achieve success, but she did not want to be a populist entertainer for the middle class like Abbott. Her ambition seems to have been to expand the audience for English-language opera beyond the middle class to include those who saw opera as either a chance for the ostentatious display of wealth and prestige, or an opportunity for an uplifting musical experience. In order to accomplish this goal, however, Juch had to convince a new audience to go to her performances, while still maintaining the traditional middle-class patronage that was crucial to the success of English-language companies.
Juch used at least three strategies to appeal to the more elite audiences. Theoretically all of these approaches might also have helped attract the middle class, but taken together they may have left the impression that Juch was abandoning English-language opera's regular audience. First, she expanded her opera company's repertoire into Wagnerian operas that most English-language companies did not perform. Second, she stressed the wealth and sophistication of her audience, rather than emphasizing a more populist message used by Kellogg and Abbott before her (and by Henry W. Savage after 1895). Last, she used lavish and expensive productions designed not only to create an exciting operatic spectacle, but also to compete with the even larger foreign-language companies.
Typically, English-language troupes sang canonic operas such as Faust, Carmen, Il Trovatore, La Traviata, Rigoletto, and Mignon (Thomas), as well as comic operas such as Martha (Flotow), Fra Diavolo (Auber), or The Chimes of Normandy (Planquette). Bohemian Girl (Balfe) and Maritana (Wallace), both originally in English by British composers, were also widely performed. Juch programmed many of these operas, but in addition her troupe performed The Meistersinger, Lohengrin, The Flying Dutchman, and Tannhauser. The so-called “Wagner craze” gripped the United States at this time, so in one sense it is no surprise that Juch performed his operas; nevertheless, Wagner's works were positioned as enlightened, cultured, and more edifying than entertaining—quite different from the pleasant diversion that characterized the lighter repertory that English-language companies usually staged. As Walter Damrosch explained it,
The frivolity which characterized the behavior of a portion of our people during the period when ‘amusement operas’ were principally performed at our opera-houses grew less and less with the founding of the German opera, and finally ceased altogether as the idea gained ground that music and the drama had also other purposes than the mere amusement of an idle hour, and that even on weekdays some time could be spent with nobler things in a building formerly considered to exist only as a gathering-place for the idle world.Footnote 75
This serious approach to the genre was more common in the world of foreign-language opera. Indeed, when Damrosch wrote these words in 1889, he was working as the Metropolitan Opera's assistant conductor. By programming so much Wagner, Juch signaled to her audience that she was interested in opera as high art as well as entertainment.
Although all opera companies worked to make their audiences feel they were attending a special event, Juch publicized the elite nature of her performances and her audience. In the prospectus for the company's first season, Juch's profile contained an entire paragraph about her appearance at a musicale in Newport, Rhode Island (where New York's “400” spent the summer) hosted by Mr. and Mrs. Cornelius Vanderbilt. The account is particularly striking because it is the only time the two-page biography dwells on Juch's audience rather than on her career, glowing performance reviews, and connections with other famous musicians.Footnote 76 For the 1891–92 season, Juch's prospectus made much of company's successful visit to Mexico in March 1891. Claiming that the tour was arranged at the “invitation of prominent Mexicans,” the document listed the “important native and foreign personages” who attended the troupe's performances and described the many receptions and dinners given in her honor by dignitaries in Mexico City.Footnote 77 Descriptions of these glittering events were designed to show that Juch and her company were valued by important and wealthy people. The “smart set” who received invitations to Vanderbilt musicales or Mexican state receptions were not in the middle class, but were part of the audience for foreign-language opera companies who used attendance at fashionable society functions to advance their social agendas.
Spectacle has always been part of marketing operas, but Juch used her productions to evoke the sort of luxury usually associated with foreign-language opera companies. In addition to purchasing the AOC's old costumes and sets (which were lauded for their beauty), a journalist with the Philadelphia Inquirer reported that Locke bought new clothes and scenery worth $30,000 and Juch spent an additional $10,000 on her outfits for the first season's productions.Footnote 78 Before the 1890–91 season, The World stated that the dress Juch would wear to sing Juliet (in Gounod's Romeo and Juliet) was decorated with lace worth $2,500 and compared her Lohengrin costume with a famously bejeweled garment worn by the actress Sarah Bernhardt in Theodora.Footnote 79 All the advertisements for Juch's productions of The Freischutz invited the audience to see the “startling novel and electrical effects in the Wolf's Glen.”Footnote 80 Although the marketing for the company never explicitly compares her productions with those of foreign-language opera troupes, taken in context, this focus on spectacle takes on more significance than just the extravagant images characteristic of operatic promotional materials. The size of the company, the costly productions, and the depiction of Juch's wealthy audiences all give the impression of a foreign-language company rather than a typical English-language troupe. As a journalist for the News and Observer reported in 1891,
she has such well and favorably known artists assisting her, a grand orchestra of forty solo instrumentalists, and a grand opera chorus of fifty trained voices and all requisite scenery and properties, thus giving the opera the proper mise-en-scene, and given with the same spectacular effects that have made the foreign companies so successful during their metropolitan engagement.Footnote 81
The elite audience Juch targeted sometimes attended her performances. When the EJOC premiered in Philadelphia, a French naval ship happened to be in port and the Association Nationale Française encouraged its members, as well as those of other French societies in the city, to attend a performance of Carmen on 23 October 1889 in order to honor the admiral and his officers. The Academy of Music was decorated with French flags and bunting for the foreign visitors, and the orchestra opened the evening with La Marseillaise. The morning of the performance, a reporter for the Philadelphia Inquirer declared
this will probably be the largest and most fashionable gathering of Franco-Americans ever assembled on any one occasion in this city. The compliment paid the fair American prima donna and her company by the representatives of our sister republic and French residents is a great one and will undoubtedly be fully appreciated as it will be the occasion of the first impersonation of this famous role by this favorite singer.Footnote 82
In addition to this impressive affair, Juch's opera company also performed Carmen for the king of Hawaii in Los Angeles in 1891, an event that was still discussed in the media in the 1940s.Footnote 83 A few special occasions, however, were not enough to keep the company going, nor did they change the public's perception about English-language opera's place in the American cultural landscape.
In order to fund her ambitious troupe, Juch had to charge 50 cents, $1, $1.50, and $2 per ticket (or between approximately $13 and $50 in 2012) depending upon the location of the seats and the city.Footnote 84 In 1891, the company raised each ticket price category by 50 cents. Apparently Locke wanted to charge even more (up to $3 per ticket), but local theater managers would not allow it, believing they would never be able to sell seats at that price.Footnote 85 English-language opera companies and other attractions aimed at the middle class such as operettas or comedic plays typically charged what was called in advertisements “popular prices”—between 25 cents and $1 per ticket (equivalent to about $6.40 and $32 in 2012). These ticket prices remained remarkably stable between the early 1880s and World War I, and middle-class audiences became accustomed to paying “popular prices” for all their entertainment. Whereas Juch's orchestra seating generally cost $1.50 or maybe $1, a typical operetta company would charge 25 or 50 cents for those same seats. Although Eugene Weatherell, Emma Abbott's husband and manager, maintained that a full house at $1.50 per seat was better than a half-empty house at $3 a ticket, for Juch this probably was not the case. Her troupe was up to 50 per cent larger than Abbott's and she performed more operas per season, which forced her to transport more sets and costumes.Footnote 86 Juch's company would have seemed more successful with fuller houses, but lowering her prices while keeping her expenses so high was probably not an option. Of course, she could have slashed her costs, but that never seems to have happened.
Presumably Juch thought that wealthier people, who were used to paying much more to attend foreign-language opera, would spend $2 to see her productions. Indeed a Metropolitan Opera ticket cost between $3 and $5 ($77 and $129 today).Footnote 87 In fact, opera performed in foreign languages was the most expensive entertainment option in the country. Foreign-language opera troupes could charge so much because the best singers in the world performed all the principal roles. Because they did not depend upon the middle-class audience for survival, foreign-language company managers did not have to worry about being affordable, but had to satisfy their wealthy customers who expected quality productions featuring many celebrity vocalists. Juch's challenge was both to convince her middle-class audience members that her troupe was worth a premium ticket price, and to appeal to an elite audience without the famous names and exclusive reputation for which they were used to paying.
English-Language Opera and the American Cultural Landscape
In the end, Juch's company failed because she alienated both segments of the audience she was attempting to entice. The middle class did not want to pay her higher ticket prices and the wealthy did not want to go to a discounted version of foreign-language opera. It is easy to understand why the middle class would shy away from paying $2 or $2.50 for an opera ticket. They could not afford the higher prices and no amount of clever marketing was going to change that reality. It is less obvious why the wealthier audience chose not to attend, given that they were willing to pay so much more for opera than Juch was charging. The answer lies in English-language opera's place in the American cultural landscape and the stereotypes about English-language singers and productions.
James Huneker, one of the most important American music critics in this period, wrote in 1900 that “the genuine opera-going class does not care a fig whether opera is sung in Zulu or German—I think Zulu would be preferred,” but that in an English-language performance, “at a blow one of the main underpinnings of opera is knocked out—its exclusiveness.”Footnote 88 The reference to “the genuine opera-going class” points to one reason why Huneker and others did not approve of English. Foreign-language opera, along with other activities such as hunting, designing a coat of arms, or building elaborate country homes, was a way for U.S. elites to display their wealth, sophistication, and cosmopolitanism. The barriers against participation by the middle class enforced by high ticket prices and the use of foreign languages helped make opera attendance one of the markers that the wealthy used to construct the American upper class at the end of the nineteenth century. Even critics who were concerned that opera was becoming too socially isolated thought that the only way for the genre to succeed in the United States was to attract wealthy benefactors. As a reporter for the Musical Record wrote in 1893, “opera is a luxury; opera needs gorgeous trappings, good singers, a large orchestra, and, alas, that it must be written, it needs the patronage of the fashionable world.”Footnote 89 In order to maintain the quality and exclusivity demanded by the elite, opera companies had to hire the most expensive singers, buy the most sumptuous sets and costumes, and cultivate a social environment that valued wealth and refinement over large, heterogeneous audiences.
There were also aesthetic reasons that advocates for foreign-language operas often cited when complaining about opera in English translation. Singers and writers sneered at the available English translations, calling them unwieldy, unmusical, and inaccurate, although these same authors often did not heap the same disdain on equally problematic foreign-language translations. As singer and critic Karleton Hackett protested, “now by what principle of art or common sense is a French opera sung in bad Italian better than the same opera sung in good English?”Footnote 90 English was also implicated in the American obsession with business, which some critics believed made the language “unvocal, hard, unsympathetic,” and unsuited for the artistic expression required in a genre like grand opera.Footnote 91 Other writers, naturally, pointed out that English was good enough for Shakespeare, but that did not seem to sway critics of opera in English translation.
For the segment of the audience that went to the opera for musical and artistic reasons (for instance those caught up in the Wagner craze), English-language opera's second-class reputation may have discouraged their attendance. The popular perception was that English-language productions were shabby, the singers were mediocre, and the middle-class patrons were déclassé and musically unsophisticated. According to one commentator, English operatic works were generally “pitchforked upon the stage with old costumes and with scenery which is customarily spoken of in the technical language of the stage as faked.”Footnote 92 An Atlantic Monthly writer repeated the common complaint that “American voices [are] too shallow for good music.”Footnote 93 The fact that foreign-language singers were paid much more than English-language vocalists furthered reinforced the idea that the latter were not skilled musicians.Footnote 94 In 1891, a critic from the New York Times (perhaps William J. Henderson) was quoted by The Musical Visitor saying that opera “ought to be sung and acted by artists schooled in the area of grand opera, not American Company opera or Emma Juch opera, but opera as it is known in Milan and in Dresden. That is a different thing from the sort of grand opera which tests the trumpet of fame in Meriden, Conn., or Wilkes-Barre, Pa.”Footnote 95 This quotation not only demonstrates a low opinion of the AOC and Emma Juch, but also betrays a certain contempt for the audiences in smaller towns outside of the artistic centers in the United States or Europe.
Of course, English-language opera had its supporters, but they were rarely completely enthusiastic in their praise. Just a few years after Juch's company failed, a critic for the Brooklyn Daily Eagle described Henry W. Savage's Castle Square Opera Company production of Carmen in a way that was typical of many reviews of English-language troupes, and the best they generally received: “For one-fifth of that money [the $5 admission charge for the Metropolitan Opera] you get no star, but Bizet's opera just as he wrote it, with a setting good enough to preserve the atmosphere of the story and a performance which is intelligent and vivid on the dramatic side, sung in the language to which the audience and the singers were born and on the musical side competent and well balanced.”Footnote 96 This reviewer did not try to suggest that the principals in the Castle Square Company were anything more than “competent and well balanced,” or that the scenery was more than “good enough,” but they produced a “competent” product that was enjoyable to attend and true to the work. Savage and Abbott were successful because they stayed within this model. They did not try to compete with foreign-language opera companies on their terms, but rather carved out their own niche, providing opera to people who appreciated good music at a good value, and probably cared little for the pretentions of the elite opera goers and the critics that supported them. This strategy proved to be quite successful until around 1911, when Savage closed his last English-language company.
Juch set herself up for failure, just as Thurber had, by attempting to push English-language opera into the same cultural position occupied by foreign-language companies. But, why, after living through the AOC's demise, did Juch follow Thurber's lead instead of emulating the far more successful Emma Abbott? In the absence of any primary sources, there is no way to know for certain what her motives were.
Clearly, one of her biggest mistakes was hiring Charles E. Locke to run the company. Not only does he seem to have been a poor money manager, as the AOC continually exceeded its budget, but he also came to the EJOC saddled with huge debts as a result of the demise of the second National Opera Company. Indeed, newspapers at the time blamed Locke's financial problems for the company's woes; as the Chicago Daily Tribune reported in a typical story from 1891, “while business has been uniformly good everywhere, the company has been in financial straits right along on account of Locke's overwhelming debts and omnipresent creditors.”Footnote 97 During the EJOC's run, Locke and his partner J. Charles Davis also managed a touring magician, a traveling troupe performing the play The Shatchen, and De Wolf Hopper's Opera Bouffe Company. Hopper claimed in his autobiography that the EJOC was making so little money that Locke used all the profits from Hopper's troupe to keep Juch's enterprise afloat.Footnote 98 There are no known extant contracts from the EJOC, so it is impossible to determine if Juch was under some kind of legal obligation to work with Locke. Diego de Vivo at one point claimed that Locke was her personal manager, and there is a cryptic reference in William Steinway's dairy on 8 March 1888 to a “meeting of Locke, Ludwig and Miss Juch's lawyer at my office, very unpleasant affair.”Footnote 99 She seems to have sung with the second iteration of the National Opera Company for the last time in early March 1888, even though the troupe kept performing until the end of April. It is possible that she struck some sort of deal with Locke to get out of her contract with the NOC on the condition that she collaborate with him on other projects, or, since Locke also left the NOC at about the same, perhaps they resigned together specifically to pursue other opportunities.Footnote 100
Despite all that had happened, Juch might not have blamed Locke for the problems with the AOC or even the second NOC. She had known him since at least 1884 when he managed Theodore Thomas's Wagner tour and that venture had been successful. With Thurber, Locke, and Thomas all trying to set the direction for the AOC, there were many opportunities for serious, and expensive, miscommunications. For instance, in 1886, Thurber and Locke both booked theaters for the AOC's second visit to Chicago.Footnote 101 With a clearer management structure in place, and a smaller company with lower overhead, Juch might have believed she could avoid the AOC's difficulties even with Locke as business manager.
Juch seemed committed to English-language opera performed at a higher level than smaller, less ambitious troupes could manage. In a Musical America profile published a year before her death, Juch praised the AOC as “far in advance of the time.”Footnote 102 She commended the AOC for its high musical standards, excellent scenery and costumes, and attention to the smallest production details. Like Thurber, Juch believed that opera was an important component of American musical culture and that U.S. audiences should support opera in English translation, instead of foreign-language opera, as the basis for an operatic tradition in America. Juch said as much in an 1891 interview with the Washington Post when she upbraided audiences for not fulfilling their patriotic duty by supporting English-language opera. “Chicago is utterly hopeless. When Italian opera goes there houses are packed, and the same with German opera; but American [sic] has no chance there. It is queer patriotism that supports foreign importations and gives no encouragement to that of its own nation.”Footnote 103
When Juch first started singing opera, writers predicted that she had an important career ahead of her; however, her devotion to English-language performance probably harmed her reputation. In 1881, a critic with the New York Times declared “it may be expected that she will make a mark among Mr. Mapleson's artists.”Footnote 104 Even when she appeared with some of the most famous European Wagnerians of her day while on tour with Thomas, reviewers gave her high marks. “Miss Juch is one of the most promising singers in America and bravely holds her own in comparison with [Christina] Nilsson and [Amalia] Materna,” wrote a critic in 1884.Footnote 105 Throughout her career, writers particularly noted the purity and sweetness of her voice, as well as her clear diction. In a typical comment from an 1884 article, a reviewer called her a “pure and beautiful singer . . . [with] a limpid voice, genuine style and perfect enunciation.”Footnote 106
Once she started singing in English with the AOC, the critical reception of her voice changed. Although she still received generally positive reviews, Juch was often compared unfavorably with leading foreign-language singers. The St. Louis Globe-Democrat printed that “the warmest admirers of Miss Juch will not claim that she is so splendid an Elsa as [Etelka] Gerster.”Footnote 107 Critic Stephen Fiske wrote that she was “not above the standard of ordinary English troupes.”Footnote 108 The critic for the Chicago Daily Tribune condemned her performance of Elsa in Lohengrin as “wanting in that it did not suit the character of the heroine, besides being faulty in some respects as regards vocalization.”Footnote 109
Given such overwhelmingly positive early reviews, why did the critical reception of her voice become so varied? Writers expressed similarly diverging opinions about Emma Abbott, though critics were more vehement both about her good and bad qualities than in many of Juch's reviews. Katherine K. Preston argues that Abbott's mixed evaluations were a reflection more of the critic's ideas about opera and vocal style than of how Abbott sang. Writers who supported Abbott's populist approach and enjoyed her ornamented vocal technique were enthusiastic. Those critics, however, who were interested in establishing opera as a high art most suited to an elite, sophisticated audience were extremely critical.Footnote 110 Juch's reception reflected a similar critical division, though writers were generally less harsh in their assessment of Juch than of Abbott, who was the standard bearer for opera as middle-class entertainment.
After the Opera
When the EJOC folded, Juch returned to concert work.Footnote 111 She appeared all over the country and also sang in England. In June 1894, she married a New York City assistant district attorney named Francis Wellman, and although she took little time away from her career as a concert artist, she never sang in opera again. Juch's decision to curtail her professional obligations after marrying Wellman was not unusual, but other forces probably also contributed to her decision to abandon the operatic stage.Footnote 112 No large traveling English-language opera troupes were active in the United States in the early twentieth century, except for the Castle Square Companies. There is no evidence that she knew Henry W. Savage, and his troupes performed a substantial amount of repertory she did not know, and appealed to a middle-class audience. After spending her operatic career chasing an elite clientele, it is hard to imagine her singing with Savage. Although there are examples of singers, like Juch, who began their careers performing with foreign-language companies but who then moved to opera in English, it was more difficult to make the transition back to foreign-language opera. Some vocalists who sang in English also found success with foreign-language companies (Zélie de Lussan and Selma Kört-Kronold being two examples), yet none of the singers who made this transition had as high a profile in English-language networks as Juch.Footnote 113 She also seems to have maintained an allegiance to opera in English. In the 1938 Musical America profile, she declared of opera in English translation, “Let me say at once, that I am definitely for it! All of the objections raised, such as bad translations, altering of the musical phrase, poor diction of singers, are easy to over-ride.”Footnote 114 In addition, touring was taxing, and she may have grown weary of being on the road. In 1891, the press reported that if her opera company failed she was considering giving up the stage and returning to concert work, which required less vocal and physical stamina.Footnote 115
Despite the end of her operatic career, Juch performed chamber music concerts with prominent singers and instrumentalists, and solos with the top orchestras and conductors in the country, though she rarely traveled farther from New York than Chicago.Footnote 116 The number of her public performances declined slowly until 1902, after which she appears to have sung for private charity events and musicales for at least another decade before settling into a comfortable retirement in New York City.
Emma Juch's life story, her struggles, successes, and failures illustrate the challenges of performing opera in English in the United States at the end of the nineteenth century. As a professional woman she was vulnerable to criticism, and the papers exploited common stereotypes about prima donnas when covering her. The most prominent singer in two different companies, she was subjected to charges of greed and professional discourtesy. To combat these stereotypes, she actively sought to promote herself as a strong (but not domineering) American woman, who was willing to defend herself from what she perceived to be unjust criticism while still maintaining her respectability.
Ultimately, Juch's decision to sing opera in English translation probably hurt her professionally. In the mid-1880s, some critics even predicted that she would rival Adelina Patti one day. But she did not become the next Patti, nor was her short operatic career similar to her more celebrated American contemporaries (such as Lillian Nordica or Emma Eames) who sang foreign-language opera and enjoyed long and profitable international careers. She was never able to command the sort of prestige, ticket prices, or salary that the famous foreign-language divas of her day could. During the 1880s and 1890s, foreign-language opera increasingly came to be identified as high art and became more established as a cultivated entertainment for the educated, sophisticated elite. Juch attempted to force her company into the same niche in the American cultural hierarchy as was occupied by foreign-language opera, but the cultural and social connotations of opera in English translation were too strong and her troupe failed. Because she chose to perform with English-language companies, critics came to identify Juch as a second-tier artist, just as they branded opera in English translation a second-tier art form. Although we can never know how her career would have been different had she decided to work with Leopold Damrosch rather than Theodore Thomas in 1884, perhaps she would have become as successful as Nordica or Eames. Instead, she took a different road, and that made all the difference.
