A wave of scholarship dominated by grand questions of economic history has brought new vigor and vitality to the study of past economic practices of Middle Eastern states and societies. Over the last few decades Şevket Pamuk has almost rewritten the entirety of Ottoman history through the prism of economic institutions and practices and successfully placed the Ottoman experience within the broader context of global economic history. Timur Kuran's provocative scholarship has helped to incorporate the study of Middle Eastern and more specifically Ottoman economic transformation into ongoing debates over the long-term economic performance of states and societies. Nelly Hanna represents a separate track of scholarship, which is concerned not only with grand economic processes and institutions but also with their impact on the life trajectories of actual human beings. After her path-breaking study on the 17th-century merchant family of Ismaʿil Abu Taqiyya, Hanna's new book delves into the industrial sector with a view to reconstructing the life stories of leading families such as the Jalfis that dominated early modern Cairo's artisanal production. Hanna's contention is that the institutional framework within which the economy functioned enabled some members of these families to avail themselves of the commercialization of the market, expand the frontiers of their entrepreneurial activities, and achieve “the status of small-scale capitalists” (p. 15) or, as she calls them, “artisan entrepreneurs.” Focusing on their “transactions, disputes, litigation, family affairs, marriage contracts and inheritance deeds” (p. 32), the book attempts to illustrate the inner dynamics of Cairo's economic life prior to Muhammed ʿAli's economic reforms and Egypt's incorporation into the capitalist world economy. Hanna's principal thesis is that the Egyptian economy, particularly its industrial sector, had life before Muhammed ʿAli and that the presence of certain artisan families of Cairo in the 17th and 18th centuries is a strong testament to the dynamism and flexibility of the Egyptian economy in the early modern era. By making her case in the context of Egypt and more specifically Cairo, Hanna makes a compelling case for the economic vitality of Ottoman provinces and peripheral cities, which have traditionally been neglected in favor of Anatolia and Istanbul.
Hanna's 200-page text is devoted primarily to the reconstruction of the framework within which artisan entrepreneurs emerged and then to mapping out the networks that they established to secure their presence in this environment. Her main interest lies in exploring the gray zone between macrochanges to the economy and the individual lives of artisans. In pursuit of this laudable goal, Hanna has read a great deal of literature on the subject, appropriated the core–periphery model of the world systems approach, reinterpreted it, and combined it with “history from below.” Her main argument is that the commercialization of certain sectors of the economy occurred not necessarily in the context of peripheralization but rather in the context of what she calls “trade without periphery” (p. 37). This implies that Ottoman Egypt experienced a certain level of commercialization before the industrial segment of its economy was destroyed in the 19th century by the inroads of the capitalist world economy. From the 16th century on, the growing commercial links with Europe complemented the volume of trade already in existence with Istanbul and the rest of the imperial territories. Thus, the wheels of commerce sufficed to keep the economy going, and some local artisans continued to reap the benefits of the vibrant commercial sector despite barriers such as guilds, state intervention in the economy, and the state's antimarket policies.
Hanna's book is organized into seven chapters. Chapters 2 and 4 are the core chapters of the book where she develops her thesis on “artisan entrepreneurs” and then reconstructs the presence of the Jalfis as a case study. She has pieced together a large chunk of anecdotal and impressionistic evidence to make her case that the Jalfis were successful entrepreneurs of artisanal background. Based on their life stories, Hanna has also formulated a series of arguments regarding the nature of premodern manufacturing carried out in the workshops of artisans who practiced their crafts inside or outside the guilds. Hanna's portrayal of guilds as flexible and adaptive organizations complements the findings of Eunjeong Yi, Suraiya Faroqhi, and especially the late Donald Quataert, who hinted at most of these arguments and successfully addressed some of them at empirical and theoretical levels in the 19th-century context. Now, with the addition of Hanna's book, one can safely say that early modern artisans of the Ottoman world do have a history of their own. Perhaps more numerical data would help elucidate the entrepreneurial spirit of these people, but the book is so innovative and inspiring in terms of its theoretical implications that the qualitative evidence may satisfy most readers, specialist and nonspecialist alike.
