In 1948, Great Britain created the National Health Service, the world’s largest and most complex formal health care organization, and “a unique example of the collectivist provision of health care in a market society” (1). The principles on which the NHS rested – health care should be comprehensive, universal, free at the point of delivery and based on need – were ambitious but consensual. Honoring these principles in practice, however, meant tackling several challenges of institutional design – for instance, how authority would be shared between the center and the periphery of the system, how managers who were accountable to Parliament for spending the public’s money might also give proper scope to the professional judgments of physicians who were accountable for improving the public’s health, how care was to be limited when services were too expensive, and how performance of the system as a whole and of its many component parts was to be evaluated.
There ensued nearly seven decades of conflict within consensus and of byplay between continuity and change – dynamics shaped and cumulatively complicated by (to cite some highlights): newly mobilized constituencies (trade unions within the NHS and proliferating patient groups); fragmentation among organizations representing physicians; the growing prominence of economists, and the determination to instill greater efficiency in and wring higher value for money from the system; demands on behalf of consumers for voice, choice and ‘patient-centeredness’; ideological tensions between and within the Labour and the Conservative parties; “intense and cruel” media coverage (202) that fueled discontent with the shortfalls of the NHS in comparison with peer nations; a major infusion of cash into the system in 2000; relentless experiments with organizational innovations such as GP fundholding and commissioning and with hospital foundations and trusts; layering on of regulatory agencies such as NICE, Monitor, the National Clinical Assessment Authority and (most recently) NHS England to run the show (227–228, 289); recurrent impingement on the service’s resources of economic cycles, which dogged the system’s perennial quest to keep pace with technological innovations without breaking the bank; and, most recently, a new era of austerity that witnessed in 2012 the enactment of “the most complex programme of change in the history of the NHS” (286), and that threatens to hold improvements hostage to gains in efficiency and productivity that may lie beyond its capacity to achieve, at least without breaking with the consensus that has so far weathered the many and various storms in and around the system. All this presents a vast, rich and intricate tableau, which Rudolf Klein first explored with matchless skill in 1983 in a brilliant book the luster of which has deepened with each new edition.
What, then, makes this book so good? First, it offers an illuminating guide to the many foreigners (and perhaps some British) who have long found perplexing both the workings of the NHS and the endless debates on how it ought to be reorganized. Klein’s premise is that “policy-making in the health arena can only be understood in the wider political context” (284) and he proceeds to show how that context early on endowed the NHS with a high degree of institutional “complexity and heterogeneity”, ambiguous objectives coupled with “uncertainty about the means needed to achieve any given ends”, and a need to rely on professional views “of what services were needed and how quality should be assessed” because policymakers lacked “independent criteria of their own” (34). In the 1970s, designs to reorganize the system and to infuse stronger technocratic and managerial leadership could not circumvent the system’s congenital complexity, which consigned leaders to “trying to achieve a variety of policy aims, while seeking to preserve consensus and avoid conflict” (71). Thatcherites and New Labour alike found in the NHS, a ‘uniquely complex, heterogeneous, and intractable organization’ that proved to be ‘remarkably resistant to attempts to steer it from the center’. Trying to do so was akin to transforming “a free wheeling jazz group … into a disciplined symphony orchestra conducted by the Secretary of State for Health” – a “peculiarly challenging task” indeed (206). Not only challenging but probably impossible: the strains and tensions that accompany the need to “balance conflicting goals and competing demands in an ever-changing environment” leave the NHS in a “continuing process of institutional adaptation”, with scant hope that some new and better model might emerge “in immaculate form from the waves of organisational turbulence” (312). Policy, in short, is complicated because it often evokes deep and durable disagreements over values and interests.
Second, students of cross national policy will find in the book many occasions to compare and contrast developments within the distinctive NHS with those in other systems. The British ‘case’ can be instructively set alongside many others that address (for example): the proper scope of user charges and private sectors; how to gauge the need for hospital capacity in the face of Klein’s memorable principles of “infinite diversity” and “infinite indeterminacy” (57); the rise of consumer organizations and of efforts to incorporate consumer voices within governing arrangements; the shifting shapes of the power of physicians (a topic on which Klein’s insights greatly improve on familiar and simplistic zero-sum imagery); infatuations and frustrations with market forces; the quest for rigorous assessment of health care technologies; the legitimation of rationing decisions by appeal to clinical expertise; the development of conceptual and managerial techniques with which to improve the quality of care and the safety of patients; the tribulations of ministers trying to navigate between civil servants and political overseers, and the challenges of organizational innovation (such as foundation trusts) within complex streams of accountability (235–236). Klein’s adroit depiction and dissection of British variations on these ubiquitous themes at once underscore the “singularity” of the NHS and suggest comparative “prompts to the policy imagination” about alternatives (310–311).
Third, his account of these and other challenges constitute policy analysis (health or other) at its sophisticated best, which is to say, as a sustained exercise in interpretation and contextualization that seeks to find meaning in, and make sense of, what makers and shapers of policy say and do. (The “real political battle” is definitional – that is, which issues should be labeled as “essentially ‘medical’ in nature and as such taboo for the non-expert”) (42). Klein recognizes – as does Deborah Stone in Policy Paradox, another great book alongside which Klein’s may be instructively read and taught – that policy can never be apolitical, and so a winding parade of policy ‘solutions’ – technocratic rationalist, market-based, organizational, and other – comes in for nuanced scrutiny, their strengths and limits subtly arrayed and judiciously balanced.
Like Stone’s book, Klein’s illuminates the ironies and paradoxes that pervade public policy – for example, the inability of policymakers to control the gatekeeping GPs on whom the NHS depends to control demand; the repeated ventures in decentralization that (repeatedly) demonstrate how “only an assertive government could carry out the policy of reducing the role of the State” (169); the streamlining reorganizations that multiply institutional complications and frustrations; the improvements in the monitoring of quality that discover more cases of poor practices, which in turn feed “an appetite for total safety that can never be satisfied” (289); the tensions that ensue when tight global budgets coexist with wide local autonomy in a system that structurally separates GPs, hospitals and local health authorities (37, 66–67); the enduring institutional loyalties that undermine the purportedly pitiless logic of competition in the internal market (270); the earnest pursuit of enhancements in “managerial competence” (273) that somehow never suffice to make the NHS truly “world class” (255); and – the most pervasive paradox of all – the projects, designed to modulate the power of physicians, that recurrently end up reaffirming or enhancing it (33, 37, 62, 69, 158, 254, 293, 316). To shine bright explanatory light on so many discrete elements in a huge explanatory universe while simultaneously fixing each within its (multiple and overlapping) contexts, and, moreover, to do so over a 60+ year history, is a narrative and analytical challenge as difficult as may be imagined. Klein brings it off successfully and somehow contrives to make it look easy.
Finally, the book offers rich insights into the politics by which policies are made. Blessedly free of methodological exhibitionism, noisy ideological eviscerations of knaves and fools, the shoving of evidence into flimsy prefabricated theoretical models, and the upselling that so often accompany policy panaceas, the New Politics of the NHS explores the scope and limits of (for example) path dependence (institutional inertia within the NHS is indeed constraining, but spurs to change from internal and external stimuli keep prompting new institutional maps and detours onto innovative terrain; 43, 59, 309); the ways in which expanding the scope of deliberation shifts power within the health arena (41–42, 161); vote maximization as a motive for investment in new facilities (56); elite-based models (70); the nuances and contingencies of implementation (161–166); and more (309).
The book is equally insightful on the politics of numbers, which do not speak for themselves. Klein knows ‘the data’ thoroughly and deploys them throughout, but he is careful to probe what goes on behind them and to discern patterns of meaning that are often opaque. Early on, new methods of analysis gave fresh salience to issues of distribution of resources within the NHS: “conceptually they solved the puzzle about which criteria should be used to decide who got what, but politically they intensified it” (60). Under Thatcher, debates about the performance of the system foundered for want of adequate benchmarks, baselines and criteria for gauging value for money, lacunae that produced a ‘dialogue of the deaf’ dominated by the medical profession (142–144). In New Labour’s Third Way, statistical transparency – new performance indicators that captured the worrisome magnitude of ‘post-code’ variations – brought ‘political vulnerability’, and a growing list of targets added “both to the pressure on NHS managers and to the political risks involved should they not be achieved” (201). Klein’s account is packed with similarly superb accounts of the politics in play within and around an impressive list of policy prescriptions emanating from the NHS’s perpetual “pandemic of visions” (253), including privatization (123–129), pilot projects (157), reduced waiting lists (200–202), productivity measures (218–219), targets and the “measurement culture” (220–222, 289), and evidence-based evaluations (270).
Klein’s preferred conceptual orientation, which interprets policy as a process of learning – puzzle solving (309) – from trials and errors, raises questions of its own and may call to mind quips to the effect that the sole lesson of history is that no one ever learns the lessons of history. ‘Learning’ about policy does not much resemble, say, learning a language, or solving a puzzle: in the policy process the pieces and borders constantly mutate and morph. And learning may come in too many guises – learning that, learning about, learning how to, learning what not to and so on – to make it serviceable as a summary term for the lurching (217), groping and improvising that characterize the political search for acceptable policies. Likewise, in a book that meticulously captures the institutional culture of the NHS one might hope for a bit more discussion of the political culture of the British citizenry, who patiently accepted cost controls that sometimes generated suffering and death (see, e.g. 63 on renal dialysis) that comparable nations avoided, but who nonetheless continued to cherish the NHS as a ‘national treasure’ that enjoyed “rock solid” public support (305). These, however, are quibbles with a book that, unlike the NHS, needs no ‘reinvention’ at all. Should the gentle readers of this journal ever find themselves marooned on a desert island and permitted to bring but one book on health affairs, let this be it.
