Milagros Navarro Caballero offers a careful study in two volumes published by Ausonius, the group in which she developed her research. N. C. has produced a corpus of women belonging to the elite in the three Hispanic provinces (Baetica, Lusitania and Citerior) during the Roman era, focusing on the period between the end of the first century b.c.e. and the third century c.e. The author is aware of her methodological problems: her sources, based on short texts with often uncertain locations; the difference between public and private, very distant from our own; and the criteria for determining that a woman belongs to the elite. The author chooses, correctly, not to apply juridical criteria strictly, for instance, by including the mothers and grandmothers of the members of the ordo equester. Nevertheless, other included categories are more problematic: female slaves, women related to the seuiri augustales, or those whose membership of the elite is uncertain. N. C. encompasses them all in her corpus on the same level as women whose membership of the elite is certain, and this particularity is seldom brought to the fore.
Perfectissima femina is organised in four sections, each divided into three chapters. Each part ends with a concluding paragraph which aids the reader's understanding and helps to organise the considerable amount of data presented by the author. The textual location of the footnotes does not interfere with the reading. The second volume consists of a corpus of the 614 analysed women organised by prouinciae and followed by various useful indexes (numerical order, alphabetical order, sources, cited people, places of importance).
Firstly, N. C. determines the characteristics of her two primary sources: epigraphy and iconography. The epigraphy is composed of three kinds of inscription: funerary, honorific and votive. The two former categories sometimes overlap, in cases where they were not funded with public money. However, as the author acknowledges throughout the book, their importance resides in their location in loco publico. Whether they were commissioned by or for women, these inscriptions are precious, not only due to the type of source itself, but also because they pose rare exceptions in a world ruled by men. N. C., showing her epigraphic skills, involves the reader in her constant awareness of the limits imposed by the data used. In her iconographic analysis, she relies, almost exclusively, on Carmen Marcks’ unpublished Köln PhD dissertation (Formen statuarischer Repräsentation von Privatpersonen in Hispanien zur Zeit der Republik und in der Kaiserzeit (2005)). N. C. accompanies this review of Marcks’ work with a very useful annex consisting of drawings and definitions of the typology of feminine statues. This is a constant trait in N. C.’s work: the inclusion of a vast number of tables, maps and graphics which help with the analysis of the documentation.
The second section focuses on how the presence of women in the coloniae of the Iberian peninsula is, above all, a question of prestige. To do so, the author follows the words of Pliny, HN 34.9.17 regarding the three pillars of individual prestige: the tomb, public ties and the home. The chronological evolution of these practices allows for the transition from the first ‘pillar’ to the second one: as funerary self-representation decreases, the honorific increases. This conclusion helps the author to organise her analysis chronologically in this section. A positive aspect of her study is the inclusion of the type of material of which the inscription is made as a criterion for considering whether a woman belonged to the elite. However, this kind of data is subsequently absent, both in the tables of the first volume and in the corpus of the second. Women appear to be portrayed as part of dynastic galleries in a two-fold manner, as devotees of the men of their family with public posts and as recipients as part of the familial dynasty itself, in the ciuitates with a larger degree of Romanisation (Baetica, southern Lusitania, and the coastal Levante). The section concludes with a study of their representation in the domestic sphere, much less frequent than the previous categories.
In the third section, N. C. analyses women according to their role in the family: daughters, wives and mothers. The first are most heavily represented in the documentation, as they assumed social responsibilities once their relatives died. Nonetheless, it is wives and mothers who provide a better understanding of the aim of the book. Women of the elite increased the prestige of their families thanks to marriage strategies and the onomastic practices they established after their marriage, which are analysed by the author. While marriage bestowed a social role on women, widowhood provided them with a personal public role and a future of their own. This is developed in the fourth section, which is focused on their euergetism. Women sought to perpetuate their gens and improve the social and political wellbeing of their family. This is why women of the elite became flamines, both provincial and local.
In a study of this scope, presented in two volumes, and in which iconography is presented as essential for understanding women of the elite, the fact that no images are presented for each inscription is problematic. The description of inscriptions lacks the objectivity of a picture, and being sent back to the references in which they are edited feels awkward and impractical. Furthermore, the corpus lacks the epigraphic data required to analyse the monuments (type of monument, material, measurements, preservation).
