Medicine and healing are intertwined with history, because the body is the precondition of human sovereignty. The body is the base of the body politic.Footnote 1
We have seen multiple examples of human bodies as the forum for political debate. Not just the dead body as evidence—corpses laid out to bear witness against the Assad regime—or the body as political symbol, when the statues of al-Qaddafi and Bin ʿAli were pulled down and dismembered by the crowds. Corporeal politics demonstrate that the body and the body politic are intertwined, they reproduce each other, they are mutually constitutive, as Jean Comaroff has argued.Footnote 2 New political communities created themselves around the images of the brutalized bodies of the child Hamza al-Khatib in Syria and Khalid Sa ʿid in Egypt (“We are all Hamza al-Khatib, We are all Khalid Sa ʿid”). The self-immolation of Muhammad Bu ʿAzizi brought massive street protests and toppled the regime of President Bin ʿAli; Egyptian women cut their hair in Tahrir Square to protest the new Egyptian constitution; Salafi Islamists destroy Sufi shrines and dig up saintly bodies. These are political struggles to define emerging polities, sovereignty, and rights through the body—who is the citizen, what are his rights, how should the polity be constituted?
Yet we do not look for politics in the body. Modernity by definition is the divorce of nature from culture; we flee the body to imagine ourselves as self-determining citizen-subjects, entirely free to make our own societies and control our own destinies.Footnote 3 This liberal model of sovereignty, invented in the West and adopted to degrees in the Middle East and North Africa, is in manifest crisis, yet so paradigmatic that it is difficult to think beyond.
Medicine, public health, and the anthropology of healing provide an epistemic archeology of modernity, one that traces the modalities of power of the modern state, colonialism, and postcolonial biopolitical reality through the body. Medicines are not neutral and universal but social and cultural systems springing from political philosophy; medicine mediates the biological and social of the human being. Medicine and law define the individual's capacities, his birth, life, and death—the ontological source of his political rights. Public health articulates the social contract between citizen and polity. Healing reveals how people locate and construct themselves in the world; as phenomenologist Maurice Merleau-Ponty writes, “the body is my point of view on the world. I am the absolute source, my existence does not stem . . . from my physical and social environment; instead it moves out towards them and sustains them.”Footnote 4
A Mediterranean history is revealed in the circulation of physicians, knowledge, pharmacology, and technology between Christian and Muslim worlds, and in the strategic use of science by Ottoman, Moroccan, and Safavid rulers. But when the Islamic world began a self-conscious search for modernity, republican France was the model, and Muslim Salafi intellectuals ingested a French Comtean positivist theory of knowledge, the march of progress, and unconsciously, the positivist rejection of gnostic epistemology (maʿrifa). Epistemes create social orders, and French biomedicine was positivist and republican, designed to create a welfare state for the “citizen-patient” and to evolve “unmodern” colonized peoples towards a universal secular modernity.
Colonialism, whether French or British, governed through modern state biopolitics in the Middle East and North Africa, the technological, urban, legal, epistemological, and state mechanisms for disciplining the body, improving the family, creating rational workers, inventing political subjects, and managing the population as a biological species.Footnote 5 But colonialism deforms the “public” of health, for a state not a republic provides medicine to a patient not a citizen. Colonial public health was often medicine as a tool of conquest, race-based provision of hospitals and clinics, coercive hygiene police, an appropriation of waqfs for “public welfare,” the reallocation of city space and natural resources to advantage European interests. The history of health offers a finely grained colonial encounter in labor, environment, municipal governance, gender, policy, law, intellectual history, medical professions, the welfare state, and urban life. A social history of medicine uncovers the processes of assimilation, how new ways of knowing were ingested and digested and used to transform identity and institutions.Footnote 6
Public health was a crucible of nationalism, for the suffering body was a rallying cry for nationalists; the welfare state became a battleground between colonizer and nationalist to define the populace and show political legitimacy. Nationalists across the Middle East and North Africa took up the biopolitical search for a national body politic, modern citizens, and a state patriarchy to control reproduction. Modernity is the transition from a government of families to a government through the family,Footnote 7 which targets women, sexuality, and birth as the biological foundation of the nation.
In the postcolonial, health and healing unlock the body as archive, as the place from which subjects constitute their own sovereignty.Footnote 8 As repositories for epistemologies and vanished ways of imagining the polity, bodies reveal a reality outside the modernist frame. In 1999, I interviewed a ninety-five-year-old Sharifian Moroccan lady in the city of Fez, who explained that her blood descent from the Prophet Muhammad and intimacy with God gave her baraka, God's blessing, which empowered her to deliver babies and heal the sick, and preserved her from illness. At the same time, she described “falling down” with typhus fever in the 1940s and showed me the milky cataracts spreading in her eyes. The paradox of a body at once healthy and sick, impervious and diseased, spiritual and biological, renders visible the contradictory and layered epistemologies through which people know themselves and the world, an artifact of the war between positivism and Islam to define the human being.
It is precisely here, with bodies and healing that do not make sense, that we should look for history and politics. Corporeality offers a lens through which to understand the nature of sovereignty and the debate over its terms, with the body as a place of dialogue between the citizen and the polity.
