Beth Baron's Egypt as a Woman: Nationalism, Gender and Politics is a fantastic read. Although she correctly pays homage to Benedict Anderson's notion of a nation as an “imagined community,” Baron's research answers a crucial question about the formation of national communities that goes beyond Anderson's formulation. Anderson and others argue that print media fuses nations by creating a sense of community among strangers. How then are nations (which Baron distinguishes from states) fashioned in places where there is a high illiteracy rate?
By focusing on images depicting Egypt, Baron explores how the Egyptian nation came to be imagined as a woman in its various forms. This discussion is then juxtaposed against women's alternating participation in, and exclusion from, the emerging Egyptian nation from the 19th century through the 1940s. In Part I, Baron examines the images, metaphors, poems, and ballads used to represent Egypt over several decades. In Part II, she discusses the activities of a few key elite women leaders who helped shape Egypt's political conception of itself, including Safiyya Zaghlul, Huda Shaʿrawi, Esther Fahmi Wisa, Munira Thabit, Fatima al-Yusuf, and Labiba Ahmad.
Baron's focus on gendered and family metaphors and images as a key to understanding the “emotive power of nationalism” sheds light on why nationalism is such a powerful political force (p. 4). This “emotive power” is often overlooked by scholars of nationalism who limit their studies either to nationalism as a political process or the end result of a political process (e.g., modernization). Baron's work is groundbreaking in that it captures an aspect of nationalism that has so far largely been overlooked.
The use of images—standard and predictable images such as photographs and political cartoons, as well as obscure images such as postage stamps—illuminates her main puzzles: What are the connections between gendered images of the nation and the politics of women nationalists? How were women incorporated into the collective memory and which tools were used? What is the interaction between women as symbols and women as political actors? Does inclusion or exclusion in one of these arenas bring inclusion or exclusion in the other? How did Egyptian women use symbols and events to craft national memory?
Her analysis begins with a description of an event that illustrates the irony inherent in her puzzle—the unveiling of the statue The Awakening of Egypt in front of the main train station in Cairo in 1928. Despite the fact that the statue depicts Egypt as female, women were barred from participating in the unveiling ceremony. However, Baron's story is more complicated than one of symbolism coupled with simple exclusion and, thus, far more interesting. Egypt as a Woman also shows that women activists were eventually able to appropriate the statue for their own use as a symbol of women's rights. Female images of the nation helped women by giving a woman such as Safiyya Zaghlul, a famous activist, political power and moral authority. Zaghlul used this symbol to fashion herself as a symbolic figure: the “Mother of the Egyptians” (chap. 6).
Although Egyptian women activists utilized gendered portrayals of the nation, they were also hurt by them. These images reinforced gendered boundaries and, for much of Egyptian history, “woman as a symbol [was] thought more important than women as historical actors” (p. 117). By using Egypt as a case study, Baron deftly shows how images and symbols can both carry a great deal of political power and reflect and affect the interests of actors who often forget, remember, and reconfigure them for their own political purposes.
Baron does this particularly well in her discussion of the famous “ladies' demonstrations” of March 1919. Baron researched how famous photographs of the protest were reprinted in various newspapers in divergent forms and cropped to show contrasting images over and over. She also describes how lore surrounding the event was retold differently by male and female activists and eventually was reimagined to include all classes of women. (In reality, only upper-class women participated in the demonstrations.)
More broadly, Baron does an excellent job of exploring how one particular image—Egypt as a woman—was envisioned and portrayed in photographs and political cartoons as old and young, rich and poor, secular and Islamic, and real and imagined. “Rather than one model, multiple images of ‘Egypt’ or the ‘Egyptian nation’ emerged” (p. 216), and these images both reflected and created political meaning.
In fact, it is Baron's constant depiction of representations and creations of the Egyptian nation—as both helpful and hurtful toward women (sometimes at the same time)—that makes her book so profound. She describes how traditional rhetoric surrounding the family gave women political power as keepers of the Egyptian nation's moral code and maintained the inegalitarian status quo: “Family rhetoric was a dual-edged sword [for women]. It condemned violence and stifled dissent from below…. In addition, by reinforcing domesticity, it ultimately circumscribed women's possibilities, and although it modified the gender order, it did not seriously challenge it” (p. 161).
My only disappointment is that Baron occasionally seems reluctant to fully explore this complexity. For example, in her chapter about the Islamist activist Labiba Ahmed, Baron is nuanced enough in her thinking to explore how Ahmed both wielded power as a political activist and leader and was a victim of a social system that placed women at a disadvantage. At times it seems that Baron is too positive about Ahmed's contribution to Egyptian society. For most of the chapter, Baron focuses on Ahmed's personal humility, values, interest in social welfare, and “typical modesty” (p. 211), without mentioning the hierarchal implications of her vision of what the Egyptian nation should be. It is only at the end of the chapter that Baron points out, “While Islamist politics provided some new images and outlets for women's activism, it ultimately narrowed their options and restricted political participation…. By stressing the Islamic cultural component as integral to nationalism, [Ahmed] limited the possibility of rewriting social relations along more egalitarian lines” (p. 213).
Moreover, in an effort to wrap up her findings, Baron again falls prey to a generalization that does not capture the wonderful complexities of her research. She writes that, despite their disadvantages, “elite Egyptian women overcame the limitations and pushed in new directions. When men's political culture seemed paralyzed by British interference, palace intractability, and party wrangling, women stepped into the breach to address daunting socioeconomic problems …” (p. 220). Admittedly, Baron is raising the topic of activism focused specifically on fixing socioeconomic problems, which is not the centerpiece of her story. The generalized tone of this sentence, however, does not match the nuanced approach of her historical narrative. These are very minor criticisms, however, about an analysis that is truly informative and creative, and unique in its choice of sources and narrative style.
