Valerie Forman's book Tragicomic Redemptions: Global Economics and the Early Modern English Stage examines seven tragicomedies against the backdrop of the changing economic landscape of early modern Britain. Four of the plays are by Shakespeare: The Merchant of Venice, Twelfth Night, Pericles, and The Winter's Tale; the other three are Fletcher's The Island Princess, Massinger's The Renegado, and Webster's The Devil's Law-Case. Forman opens with an extended introduction and then moves chronologically in her discussion of the plays, ending with an epilogue that begins with an examination of Webster, but then shifts to the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in an ambivalent concession toward presentist relevance.
Forman's selection of plays is aimed at showing the development of tragicomedy's engagement with mercantilism in the seventeenth century. Forman sees the doctrine of the felix culpa as foundational to her discussion of tragicomedy: the fall of Adam led to a happy redemption of mankind through Christ, in the same manner that the plays show the insecurity of commercial enterprise ending with some form of happy success or resolution. She emphasizes that tragicomedy is a genre and not just a hybrid, crystallized by the fluctuations of early modern trading ventures. There is a strong relationship, Forman argues, between “economic theories and generic experimentation on the early modern stage” (2), as well as with theology. In this context, she raises important questions: To what extent did tragicomedy serve as a platform for criticizing new economic practices? Were changes in tragicomedy a result of theatrical or economic developments? How did playwrights engage with the question of profit—given church disapprobation—and to what extent could tragicomedy succeed in showing the “comedy” after the tragic risks of “investments,” which, as Forman points out, was a term/concept that first appeared in correspondence of the East India Company? The plays were all written at a time when navigation and trade were taking Britons to vast regions of the world, from the Mediterranean to the Indian Ocean. Forman is correct in emphasizing the impact of the new investment enterprise, spearheaded by chartered companies (Levant and East India, in particular) on English culture, and presumably on the London stage.
But how far did that go? Historical context needs to be carefully taken into account since it casts its shadow over the plays. It is not enough to write that “these texts do not need to display their historicity” (23) when assumptions are made about history that do not correspond to known facts. Elizabethan Englishmen did not simply reject the imperial objective, as Forman states (120): after all, the charter of the queen to Sir Walter Raleigh in 1584 was a call for conquest, as was the Virginia charter of James I. Neither monarch had any problem with the “subjection” of natives, as long as there was no entanglement with other Euro-Christian potentates. Englishmen's desire for free trade was not the reason for rejecting “subjection” of peoples: rather, the English were in general not strong enough navally to do so. In fact, they were themselves being taken captive in the Mediterranean basin and the Indian Ocean by the North Africans, the Portuguese, and the Dutch. When and where, however, they did acquire power, as in the slave trade from Guinea to America, they happily did “subject” natives. If the purpose of this book is to show “that literature in general, and the theater in particular, register and address historical concerns, not only with mimetic and thematic representations (in this case of economic practices) but also in the forms themselves” (23), then should not the author show that the playwrights were familiar with the “economic practices” that their plays allegedly display? How much did Shakespeare know about English investments overseas—indeed, how much did he known about the Italian or Greek “Mediterranean” (the word is mentioned only once in all his plays) where The Merchant and Pericles are set? Is there any evidence as to his familiarity with the mercantilist theories that are supposed to underpin the tragicomedies? After all, the writings of Thomas Mun and Edward Misselden about the economics of trade postdated most of the plays in Forman's book.
Forman contends that the traffics and navigations of the English resulted in a “newly developing public discourse of economic theory” (18). It would have been helpful to bring evidence from diaries, “corantos”/newspapers, sermons, proclamations, and perhaps other plays to show that there was a public engagement with economic theories and countertheories, especially since she emphasizes the importance of “audience response” (140). Fletcher and Massinger wrote about trade, negotiations, and captivity, and Forman points to the bargaining and mart scenes as evidence of the importance of economic theory, and how the plays again show the felix culpa: success after disaster. Fletcher's The Island Princess was written sometime during 1619–21, at a time when there were thousands of English captives in North Africa. Would the audience response have really resonated with the felix factor, when families, especially the women, in their frustration at the government's indifference to the plight of the captured kinsmen, began an unprecedented collection of signatures and petitions to call attention to the culpa of the unransomed captives? That playwrights used language derived from exchange and trade does not mean that they were presenting their audiences with discussions about economics.
The idea of illustrating felix culpa, loss and then gain, in the context of drama is intriguing. But there needs to be evidence showing the intersection of theology with English drama. Forman offers a slim discussion of the felix culpa with no reference to the history of its doctrinal permutations, nor how that “paradox” (15) came to bear on the making of the genre of tragicomedy. Forman recognizes that it was not English playwrights who invented tragicomedy, which explains why her discussion of the important allusions to tragicomedy in The Faithful Shepherdess by Beaumont and Fletcher, and their engagement with Guarini's defense of tragicomedy in 1601, is relegated to an endnote. Forman asserts that “It might not be the case that all Renaissance tragicomedies follow the formula of producing a prosperous conclusion out of the averted tragedy exactly” (210 n. 26), but she then uses that formula in her analysis of the plays throughout the book. Otherwise, what is it that separates tragicomedy from “romance”? If all there is in the felix culpa is loss/fall and then gain/redemption, one wonders why the greatest Christian poem in the Western tradition simply goes by the title of Comedia? And in English, the greatest exponent of the felix culpa was Milton. Does Paradise Lost qualify as a tragicomedy?
There are many interesting observations in this book, especially in the context of the importance of economic changes in early modern England. But there is not enough supporting evidence to link them to the plays, which is why the author has to push her interpretation of the few passages in the plays that contain “economic” content to implausible limits. Are the frequent, and hilarious, allusions to castration in early modern English drama, specifically in The Renegado, really a reflection of anxiety over the loss of economic circulation (171)? Not if the genealogy of castration is taken into account in plays preceding Massinger's: after all, Massinger drew on Cervantes for his Renegado (which the author does not take into account). That London viewers of The Renegado would have thought of the “loss” of economic exchange at the mention of castration, rather than join in bawdy laughter at the “gelded” English captive, is really pushing it.
