Much like ‘best of’ compilations in music, well-conceived academic readers should offer something to seasoned hands as well as the uninitiated. The neophyte student should gain a broad overview of a topic, whilst the experienced scholar might find within its pages some gems previously unknown to them. This book succeeds in providing exactly this, together with generous commentary between sections and indeed at the beginning of each extract. After all, what is a ‘best of’ compilation without extensive liner-notes?
Given the high standing of its editors within the world of urban ethnography, it is not particularly surprising that both the choice of extracts here and the explanatory material interspersing them are of an excellent standard. The book is logically organised, beginning with an introduction that provides an ‘invitation’ to the methods that have become the identifying feature of this body of scholarship. The first substantive section on community uses a series of well-chosen extracts to illustrate the links between the ethnographic craft and the nature of the findings it tends to produce.
Each of the following sections, respectively covering: social interaction, family, education, employment and subsistence, leisure activities, policy applications and reflexivity, all make their substantive points clearly. In each section, there is much to offer the social policy student and scholar on the specific topic considered. The original commentary forms the scaffold within which the extracts provide the kind of detailed, nuanced evidence that makes this genre of scholarship so compelling. Communities and behaviours that are often dismissed as ‘wanton’, ‘deviant’ or ‘problematic’ (on which more later) are located within broad and oppressive social structures. As the editors note, social structures and policies can be very usefully understood through their manifestations in everyday life: their impacts on the ways in which people earn, learn or simply interact. Obviously, the reader format lends itself to the inclusion of ‘classics’ and this book is no exception, hence the selection of extracts from seminal texts, such as Paul Willis’ ‘Learning to Labour’, and W.E. Du Bois’ ‘The Philadelphia Negro’. It does, however, also include some more contemporary pieces that are perhaps likely to become better known as time passes, such as the contributions from Randol Contreras and Amy Best.
This book is a veritable treasure trove for scholars and students interested in urban life, social problems and the policy instruments through which these might be addressed. Part VII of the book indeed poses the question ‘does it have a point?’ In answering, the editors make explicitly clear what is implicitly evident from nearly every extract contained within the wider volume: yes! Urban ethnography with its tight focus on the way in which people live day-to-day provides vital, grounded context and micro-detail to inform policy debates. By breaching the barriers that ‘scientific’ methods place between researchers and their participants’ lives, ethnography reveals how problems and policies are actually experienced – how they unfold ‘on the ground’. Policies formed in the abstract can often have unintended consequences in their application. Ethnography can bridge this chasm. As the extracts in Part VII demonstrate, urban renewal may not be welcomed by the residents whose lives it is ostensibly aimed at improving. It instead may be experienced as an exclusionary policy which places real estate markets ahead of creating opportunities for local residents, displacing rather than reducing crime.
Similarly, this section demonstrates how one ‘social problem’ may indeed be a confluence of other issues and indeed the consequences of earlier flawed policies. The ‘crack house’ described by Williams for example cannot simply be understood as a product of drug problems where it simultaneously houses those made destitute or desperate by deindustrialisation and the deinstitutionalisation of mental health care. Although never easy to conduct, the ethnographic research that yields such insights is indispensable for those who are seeking to make a difference in the lives of the excluded. As the extract on welfare by Edin and Jencks demonstrates, those in poverty often live precariously and seeming simple solutions to their predicaments may cause more problems than they are worth.
There is very little to criticise in this book, beyond what might be said about academic readers in general and urban ethnography in particular. In the case of the former, extracts no matter how well contextualized and introduced often lose much in their separation from their wider text. This is particularly true of ethnography, where full texts often give the reader a great sense of fully humanized, complex individuals and communities. Nevertheless, the reader format will arguably motivate the interested to seek out the full text for extracts that they appreciate. Secondly, urban ethnography as a whole can be criticised for focusing overly on issues of poverty or ‘social problems’, whilst often avoiding research topics and participant groups that are more ‘mundane’ or ‘elite’. Such preponderance is evident in this reader, as much as the academic genre that it samples and indeed the social sciences generally. In a social policy context, however, this is not always a negative attribute, where the voices and experiences of the marginalized often fail to gain recognition. The editors moreover include pieces that speak to more universal experiences of urban life, from Michael Bull on the role of portable listening devices (for him the Walkman – for us now, the MP3 player) and Tamara Mose Brown on the relationship between technology and childcare. There might also be a slight US bias in this reader, but the principles discussed tend to have general relevance nonetheless.
It is difficult to think of an equivalent text that can give so much insight into the processes and findings of urban ethnography so generally. Moreover, packaged in the way that these extracts are, they provide a fantastic learning resource and taster. For social policy students and scholars, this perspective represents a valuable opportunity to come face-to-face with issues that are too often studied at arm's length: to recognise the extent to which abstract debates can have wide (and sometimes unintended) consequences for vulnerable populations, and to do so in the context of rigorous and engaging research.
