Among the many questions raised by the Mongol conquests of the Near East, one of the most tantalising concerns the extent to which they acculturated themselves to their new environment. Questions concerning the extent to which they adopted the religions, cultures and customs of their conquered subjects continue to go back and forth with no easy resolution. This topic is important not merely because it is crucial to understanding the Mongols’ changing identity, but also because issues of cultural adaptation sit at the heart of debates surrounding the rise, development and fall of the Mongol empire(s). Thus, this book of thirteen essays is well positioned in its scope and purpose to advance our knowledge on such themes.
The first section ‘The Mongol Conquest of the Middle East’ begins with a piece by May exploring the Mongols’ strategies to territorial conquest. Here he summarises the standard military approach adopted by Mongol advancing armies, which he aptly labels as ‘Tsunami strategy’ before moving onto the question of post-invasion consolidation; stressing the importance of the tamma units and their role in enforcing Mongol rule. A strand running through this discussion is the question of the extent to which the Mongols developed such mechanisms of conquest over time and in different regions, his line being to emphasise continuities in practice. Amitai continues this conversation on the Mongol military, exploring the extent to which Mongol warcraft changed over time and the impacts of becoming sedentary. He draws the plausible conclusion that the Mongol army changed far less in composition than some historians have imagined, championing instead the idea a continuation of an essentially nomadic approach to war.
Ravalde opens the second section ‘Internal actors’ by considering the career and predicament of the vizier Shams al-Dīn Juwaynī in post-conquest Anatolia, effectively reconstructing how he implemented Mongol rule in the region, while playing a vital mediating role between the conquered populace and their nomadic masters. She weighs the strategies he employed to facilitate this difficult role and the extent to which he continued/adapted existing Anatolian administrative structures; in this case primarily a tale of rewiring society to accommodate the Mongols. De Nicola, moves the discussion on to consider the influence of Mongol woman upon the economics of the Ilkhanid empire, showing both how they made use of their newly-acquired wealth and the effect of their financial behaviour on broader flows in regional commerce.
Hodous engages with important questions surrounding Mongol religious beliefs and the changes that took places following their conquest of Muslim and Buddhist societies. She joins this discussion via a well-researched analysis of the methods employed by the Mongols when carrying out capital punishment. She demonstrates that the Mongols’ use of techniques - such as strangulation and the importance they attached to the question of whether the subject's blood should/should not be spilt – indicates a spiritual influence which in this case seems to derive ultimately from shamanism. In other cases she highlights influences from Islam, Buddhism and Confucianism.
The third section ‘culture and the arts’ begins with an astonishing story arising from the Mongol conquest of Baghdad, analysed by Biran, describing the way in which the musician Ṣafī al-Dīn negotiated his own survival during the city's fall (and that of many of his neighbours) by winning over the Mongol commander assigned to their urban district. This tale then serves as a platform for a thought-provoking discussion on the incoming Mongols’ approach to music and the arts and the strategies by which such artists won favour with the Hülegü and the Mongol court. Kolbas turns to the famous history of the Mongols written by Juwaynī, considering his perspective as an author, as well as the pressures and objectives guiding his hand. She demonstrates that while he was very much writing for his Mongol patrons, his work also reflects their steady integration with their Persian subjects. This section is completed with Ruhrdanz's piece on the evolution of manuscript illumination from the Mongol and Timurid period; this subject providing a means to discuss themes of continuity and change.
The fourth section focuses on the Ilkhan's relations with their neighbours. Khanbaghi explores the development of the Persian language under the Mongols, providing initially a very clear and helpful overview of the language's early history. He then shows how the Mongol invasions created an environment suitable for this language to thrive. Most notably, he argues that it was the region's Turkish population that drove this linguistic expansion. Dashdondog's piece changes ground to look at the administrative systems put in place by the Mongols in Greater Armenia, showing how the structures they put in place played their part in determining Armenia's role within the empire. Lane moves further afield to the Eastern Chinese city of Hangzhou, discussing one of the few buildings constructed by the Mongols during their rule: the Phoenix mosque. He considers the building's function and local reactions to its construction, showing in particular the effect of incoming Persian Muslims on the city's society. James returns to the Middle East with an excellent essay on role of the Kurds during the Mongol invasions and also the strategies employed by both the Mongols and Mamluks to win their support in their ongoing conflict. It is especially interesting to see how the pressures exerted by this long-drawn-out contest helped to shape Kurdish identity. In addition, James provides an insightful discussion on how the Mamluks reconciled their desire to win Kurdish allies in the north with their determination to resist any attempt to effect a Kurdish (Ayyubid) restoration to power in their core territories.
The Mongols’ Middle East closes with a reflective epilogue by Melville on the Mongol ‘decline’ and the issues this process poses for historians. He offers a wide ranging debate, challenging readers to consider precisely what it meant by ‘decline’ and focusing in particular on the importance of the person of the ‘khan’ in any discussion on the fall of the Mongol Empire. Within this analysis he draws some perceptive parallels to other empires, especially the Safavids, pondering how the experience of one can shed light on that of the other. He concludes by evaluating the various arguments offered at a macro level concerning Mongol (Ilkhanid) assimilation with the peoples/cultures under their control. His verdict being that their integration was slight and that they remained “aliens in the sedentary lands they conquered’”. (p. 329)
Overall, this is a challenging and thought-provoking set of essays which considers themes of continuity and change in a wide variety of contexts. The standard is generally high and many of these articles strike-at-the-heart of core questions surrounding the Ilkhans and the peoples they ruled.
