Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:03:56.924Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Transition induced by an egg-crate roughness on a flat plate in supersonic flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 September 2022

Amanda Chou*
Affiliation:
Flow Physics and Control Branch, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
Pedro Paredes
Affiliation:
National Institute of Aerospace, Hampton, VA 23666, USAComputational Aerosciences Branch, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
Michael A. Kegerise
Affiliation:
Flow Physics and Control Branch, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
Rudolph A. King
Affiliation:
Flow Physics and Control Branch, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
Meelan Choudhari
Affiliation:
Computational Aerosciences Branch, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
Fei Li
Affiliation:
Computational Aerosciences Branch, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: amanda.chou@nasa.gov

Abstract

Hot-wire measurements in a Mach 3.5 quiet tunnel were made in the wake of a roughness patch on a flat plate. These measurements were used to determine mode shapes and frequencies of the dominant instabilities leading to boundary-layer transition. The egg-crate roughness pattern is an analytic function described by a sinusoidal equation, similar to an array of discrete elements that are positioned in a spanwise and streamwise grid, but containing both protuberances and dimples. This is an intermediate configuration towards understanding the underlying physics of a pseudorandom distributed roughness, and ultimately, the underlying physics of roughness-induced boundary-layer transition. The roughness pattern had a wavelength of 6.25 mm, with a nominal amplitude of 272 ${\rm \mu}{\rm m}$ (0.49 times the boundary layer thickness at the first row of protuberances). The roughness was positioned near the leading edge of the flat plate and contained 3.5 wavelengths in the streamwise direction and 7.5 wavelengths in the spanwise direction. The dominant instability was centred near 74 kHz at a free stream unit Reynolds number of $12.9\times 10^{6}\,{\rm m}^{-1}$ and resembled an antisymmetric mode downstream of each of the protuberances in the roughness patch. Computations using linear stability analysis based on the plane-marching parabolized stability equations (PSE) showed limited agreement with measurements when comparing the growth of the wake instability. Better agreement with the measurements was observed when considering the modification of first mode waves by the egg-crate roughness patch and the solution of the three-dimensional harmonic linearized Navier–Stokes equations was used as the in-flow to the PSE. The agreement confirms the significance of disturbance growth both upstream of and above a finite length roughness patch and the effect on the growth of instabilities in the wake.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Creative Commons
To the extent this is a work of the US Government, it is not subject to copyright protection within the United States. Published by Cambridge University Press
Copyright
© National Aeronautics and Space Administration, 2022.
Figure 0

Figure 1.Mode shapes of normalized streamwise velocity fluctuation ($|u'|$) associated with dominant instability modes from various families: (a) AA mode at $f = 50$ kHz; (b) SA mode at $f = 50$ kHz; (c) AS mode at $f = 50$ kHz; (d) SS mode at $f = 100$ kHz. Perspective is modified in order to view the mode shapes more clearly. Roughness patch parameters correspond to $k = 240\,{\rm \mu}{\rm m}$, $Re = 10.8 \times 10^{6}\,{\rm m}^{-1}$, $M = 3.5$ (reprinted with permission from Choudhari et al. (2018), figure 9). Flow from bottom to top.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Mode shapes of mass-flux fluctuations $|(\rho u)'|$ centred in a 5 kHz band around 55 kHz for ${k = 272\,{\rm \mu}{\rm m}}$ and $L_x/\lambda _x = 3.5$, $Re = 10.8\times 10^{6}\,{\rm m}^{-1}$, $M = 3.5$. The $x$ dimension is a different scale than the $y$ and $z$ dimensions to fit all of the mode shapes on the same page (redrawn from Chou et al. (2020a), figure 11). Flow from left to right.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Free stream mass-flux fluctuations along the tunnel centreline as measured with a hot wire for $T_0 = 319.3\,{\rm K}$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Photograph of the polished flat plate with the egg-crate roughness insert installed, with the coordinate system labelled in red. Flow travels from the top left-hand corner towards the bottom right-hand corner, in the $+x$ direction.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Measurements of the egg-crate roughness with comparator: (a) of surface height $h$; (b) the difference between analytic function and measurement $\Delta h$; and (c) a line cut down the centreline of the egg-crate roughness measurement in the streamwise direction.

Figure 5

Table 1.Spanwise boundary conditions used in the plane-marching PSE and HLNSE analyses. The mode labels AA, SS, SA and AS refer to antisymmetric and symmetric conditions at each boundary. Also, note that the subscript $()_z$ is equivalent to $\partial ()/\partial z$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Boundary layer profiles on a flat plate with no roughness at several stations in the streamwise and spanwise extent of the measurement region.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Scale diagram of the flat plate with measurement locations marked by blue lines. Dashed arrows indicate possible contamination lines from edges of insert. Coordinate system labelled in red, with the $+y$ direction coming out of the page.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Mean mass-flux contours behind the egg-crate roughness for the measurement plane located at multiple streamwise stations: $M = 3.5$; $Re = 12.6\times 10^{6}\,{\rm m}^{-1}$. Measurements from the experiment are given on the $+z$ side of the figures and the time-accurate laminar solution for the DNS is given on the $-z$ side of the figures for comparison: (a) $x = 58.8$ mm; (b) $x = 84.7$ mm; (c) $x = 110.6$ mm; (d) $x = 138.4$ mm;(e) $x = 153.8$ mm; ( f) $x = 179.7$ mm; (g) $x = 188.3$ mm; (h) $x = 192.7$ mm; (i) $x = 197.0$ mm; (j) $x = 205.6$ mm.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Mean mass-flux contours at $x = 110.6$ mm.

Figure 10

Figure 10.(a) Streak strength profiles at each streamwise station and (b) streak amplitude over the measurement region.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Power spectra taken at the location with the largest r.m.s. near the centreline for the most-amplified disturbance in a planar survey. The electronic noise floor of the system is also shown.

Figure 12

Figure 12.The r.m.s. mass-flux fluctuation contours for the 75 kHz instability behind the egg-crate roughness for the measurement plane located at multiple streamwise stations: $M = 3.5$; $Re = 12.6\times 10^{6}\,{\rm m}^{-1}$. Flow travels from bottom to top of image.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Power spectra taken at the location with the largest r.m.s. in the wake of the protuberances centred near $z= -2.6$ mm.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Comparison of power spectra in the wake of the protuberances centred near $z= -2.6$ mm to the power spectra in the centreline wake ($z \approx 0.5$ mm).

Figure 15

Figure 15.Comparison of r.m.s. contours normalized by the cross-sectional maximum full bandwidth r.m.s. across different bandwidths at select streamwise stations: (a–c) $x = 138.4$ mm; (d–f) $x = 179.7$ mm;(g–i) $x = 192.6$ mm; (j–l) $x = 205.6$ mm; (a,d,g,j) 10–40 kHz; (b,e,h,k) 40–200 kHz; (c, f,i,l) full bandwidth.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Autobicoherence for (a) $x = 110.6$ mm, (b) $x = 138.4$ mm, (c) $x = 179.7$ mm, (d) $x = 192.6$ mm at the location with the highest overall autobicoherence near the centreline.

Figure 17

Figure 17.The AA mode shape at 80 kHz in the wake of the roughness patch, computed with (a) PSE of only the wake instabilities (PSE-only) and (b) PSE of the first mode, HLNSE of the modification of the first mode over the roughness patch, and PSE of the modified first mode and wake instability (HLNSE+PSE).

Figure 18

Figure 18.Mode shapes of the 80 kHz instabilities computed with HLNSE+PSE of modified first mode and wake instabilities for the (a) AS mode and (b) SA mode.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Comparison of measured r.m.s. amplitudes (left-hand axis) at 75 and 80 kHz with computed $N$-factors (right-hand axis) for (a) PSE of only the wake instabilities (PSE-only), (b) PSE of the first mode, HLNSE of the first mode and PSE of the modified first mode and wake instabilities (HLNSE+PSE).

Figure 20

Table 2.Computed $N$ factors for the wake instability at $x = 84.7$ mm and estimates of the initial amplitude of the AA mode based on the measured r.m.s. amplitude of 0.065 % of $(\rho u_e)$ at 80 kHz.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Comparison of power spectra to most-amplified modes computed with PSE of only the wake instabilities for (a) $x=84.7$ mm, (b) $x = 110.6$ mm, (c) $x = 138.4$ mm, (d) $x = 153.8$ mm, (e) $x = 179.7$ mm.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Comparison of power spectra to most-amplified modes computed with HLNSE and PSE of the modified first mode and wake instabilities for (a) $x=84.7$ mm, (b) $x = 110.6$ mm, (c) $x = 138.4$ mm, (d) $x = 153.8$ mm, (e) $x = 179.7$ mm.

Figure 23

Figure 22.The r.m.s. mass-flux contours behind the egg-crate roughness for the measurement plane located at multiple streamwise stations compared with the HLNSE+PSE stability analysis: $M = 3.5$; $Re = 12.6\times 10^{6}\,{\rm m}^{-1}$. Measurements from the experiment in a 5 kHz bandwidth centred at 75 kHz are given on the $+z$ side of the figures and the HLNSE+PSE stability analysis at 80 kHz is given on the $-z$ side of the figures for comparison: (a) $x = 58.8$ mm; (b) $x = 84.7$ mm; (c) $x = 110.6$ mm (experimental side spans from $z = 0$–24 mm); (d) $x = 138.4$ mm; (e) $x = 153.8$ mm; ( f) $x = 179.7$ mm; (g) $x = 188.3$ mm; (h) $x = 192.6$ mm; (i) $x = 197.0$ mm; (j) $x = 205.6$ mm.

Figure 24

Figure 23.The DNS of shear contours normalized by the amplitude of the egg-crate function and the free stream mass flux and comparison with mode shapes. Black lines are isolines of the mass flux. The first column is the spanwise shear, the second column is the wall-normal shear, and the last column is the computed 80 kHz AA mode shape: (a) $x = 30.0$ mm (contour limits adjusted for spanwise shear); (b) $x = 35.2$ mm; (c) $x = 38.0$ mm; (d) $x = 41.3$ mm; (e) $x = 44.2$ mm; ( f) $x = 47.6$ mm; (g) $x = 55.0$ mm; (h) $x = 80.0$ mm; (i) $x = 120$ mm; (j) $x = 140$ mm; (k) $x = 160$ mm; (l) $x = 200$ mm.