The pervasiveness of social mix policies would suggest that their appropriateness as a tool to solve ‘urban ills’ is well documented and clearly known: The social mixing shibboleth is, apparently, still alive and well. However, there is a burgeoning literature that is more critical of social mix policies, and it is into this arena that Arthurson's new book is entered. The book is structured around two major sections, the first of which sets of the historical rationale and arguments for adopting social mix policies through five chapters engaging with the theoretical and empirical literatures that have investigated the efficacy of such policy interventions. The second section draws on findings from qualitative research projects conducted by Arthurson and develops themes from papers previously published.
There are two substantial contributions made by this volume, both of which fall within the first section, although they are recurring themes in the second section as well. Firstly, an observation that is rarely made but is of great importance is the age of social mix policies: a quick search in Google Scholar reveals the first publications using the term originated in the early 1800s and there were many instances in the early 1900s including the well-known Garden City Movement. This historical underpinning is important as a context through which the current policies evolution can be understood. Arthurson correctly observes that this detail is frequently omitted within the social mix literature, presenting the policies as recently developed interventions, and addresses the observation through a brief discussion on the potted history of social mix. The second contribution that Arthurson makes is a link to the literature of neighbourhood effects, work that originated with Wilson (Reference Wilson1986), with the ideas of concentrated poverty and the urban underclass. Although the (assumed negative) effect of, for example, concentrations of poverty, is not the only reason why policies of social mix are pursued frequently it is a central concern of policy makers even if it is more implicit than explicit. Arthurson highlights the fact that using this literature as an evidence base is problematic: there are few examples that provide genuinely convincing and robust evidence of causal neighbourhood mechanisms leading to clear negative outcomes for individuals. Importantly, Arthurson articulates the problem of using literature derived from case studies written outside a national policy context. Whilst there is merit in drawing on international literatures, caution must be exercised in translating the nation context appropriately: the scale and concentration of poverty in the US and to a lesser extent the UK is greater than in Australia. As such, the general findings of the neighbourhood effects literature cannot be directly applied and the policy challenges are not necessary applicable in Australia and the policy gains are unlikely to be achieved because they are not there to be found. What is lacking in this discussion is the more nuanced quantitative literature that acknowledges the disagreement in the findings and the non-trivial methodological and epistemological problems (see for instance van Ham and Manley, Reference van Ham and Manley2010). In addition, the vast majority of the neighbourhood effects literature is quantitative in nature using relatively large datasets to investigate if there are statistically significant differences between individuals living in concentrations of poverty compared with individuals living in other areas. Whilst Arthurson correctly notes that there is also a need for qualitative literature to provide voices for individuals living in these neighbourhood contexts, she neglects to highlight the relative recent gains that have been made in relation to multi-method studies (Small and Feldman, Reference Small, Feldman, Van Ham, Manley, Bailey, Simpson and Maclennan2012; DeLuca et al., Reference DeLuca, Duncan, Mendenhall, Keels, Van Ham, Manley, Bailey, Simpson and Maclennan2011). Using both approaches in tandem to nuance the null and explain the exceptional can illuminate the debate on social mix with greater clarity than has been previously achieved.
The case studies in the book are drawn from published research, and the empirical information is not new and available elsewhere. Where a new contribution is made is in how this empirical evidence is used to provide context to the efficacy of social mix as a longer-term project. Using multiple research projects with data collected over the last decade, Arthurson demonstrates how the propinquity of different social groups rarely breeds positive interactions. Indeed, it frequently serves to increase tensions and mistrust between them. In the header of chapter 8, Arthurson quotes Johnston (Reference Johnston2003: 17) ‘[Governments] cannot make people like, talk with, or help their neighbours.’ Never has this seemed more appropriate! Contained within this book is a useful collection of Australian based case studies and a means to view the social mix project from a perspective other than that of the US or UK experiences. This is an important addition to the social mix literature and the increasing diversity of national perspectives available through the literature, especially in synthesised forms, can only serve to highlight the diversity of urban problems and the need for more imaginative policy solutions. The links to new literature and the commentary weaved around previously published research are sufficient to make this volume a useful publication for social mix practitioners in Australia. Readers outside Australia may wonder if this book is relevant to them − it is! The policy of social mix is rarely questioned and passively accepted as an automatic ‘good’. The research and policy community should be more critical of the policy, and the evidence presented in this volume will help to promote this understanding (if only the publishers had made it a little cheaper!)
