Jennifer Waldron's Reformation of the Body provides insights into the complex relationship between faith and theatre in early modern England. Waldron argues that theatre practitioners exploited ambiguity in Reformation theology, especially its critique of Catholic images, idols, and depictions of the body. Through case studies of canonical works such as John Foxe's 1583 Actes and Monuments, John Calvin's documents, and the Bible, Waldron argues against those scholars who emphasize the persistence of a Catholicized representation well after the Reformation. Rather, she maintains, the Reformation pervaded theatrical representation soon after becoming popular with the multitude. She heralds the body as the primary contact point for divine connection and the stage as the mass medium where this is evinced.
Waldron integrates theological contextualization and textual analysis to set up in her first chapter a dichotomy between social perceptions of Catholicism and Protestantism in early modern England: idolatrous Catholicism versus somatic Protestantism. Her major argument is rooted in Calvinist theology, where Christ is the “lively” (47) image of God, to be compared against Catholic, “idolatrous” (51) representations. She also considers differences between Protestant and Catholic sacraments in terms of their view of the body, noting that Calvin sanctioned only the sacraments that Christ experienced with his incarnate body. Waldron focuses on the question of how this disambiguation affected the early modern stage, arguing that the theatre, where actions presented onstage are known to be fictitious, provided powerful experiences of recollection through the “lively” body.
Chapter 2, “Sacrament and Theater: Shakespeare's Lawful Magic,” examines the final scene of Shakespeare's The Winter's Tale, in which the statue of Hermione comes back to life, through the lens of Protestant sacraments. In particular, she is interested in how an audience would perceive an actor playing a statue that comes to life. Waldron observes that Shakespeare's choice to give the sculptor an Italian (Catholic) name, Julio Romano, initially activates for the Protestant audience the forbidden memory of pilgrimage to an idol. Yet the statue is then transfigured within the Calvinist theology of the “lively body” (78). Paulina's lawful magic affects the lively bodies of the actor and Hermione, reminding the audience that “[u]nderneath the illusion of a statue coming to life is an ordinary body” (79). Chapter 3 examines Christopher Marlowe's Doctor Faustus and the legal limitations of portraying sacred characters onstage. Through analysis of Marlowe's syncretic irony and exploration of the body, Waldron highlights the tension between Catholic and Protestant perceptions of eternal corporeality. Waldron references the question of predestination and its bodily manifestation in Faustus, particularly in Faustus's inability to pray or to control his hands, tears, or head. She argues that when in the B-text Faustus's body is brutally destroyed, Marlowe uses it as the stand-in for humankind, highlighting one's lack of control over fate. Waldron emphasizes Marlowe's use of text from a familiar Catholic cycle play, suggesting that this invites the audience to recall the old Catholic perspective unsympathetic to the Calvinist stance regarding bodily torment. What does eternal justice look like? Waldron argues Marlowe's answer is in the Faustus [B-text]: justice delivered by God via the body.
In Chapter 4, “Revenge, Sacrifice, and Post-Reformation Theater,” Waldron argues that Thomas Kyd sets The Spanish Tragedy in a classical–Christian hybrid world to allude safely to Catholic rites while remaining within a Protestant-oriented Senecan worldview. Waldron reads Horatio's murder as a Christly sacrifice, his being hanged from a tree as a parallel to Christ's Crucifixion on a wooden cross. Language of Horatio's body bearing fruit on that tree corresponds with the Christian ideology of eternal salvation won through the suffering and death of Christ. According to Waldron's reading, Kyd utilized instantly recognizable Catholic tropes while setting the action in the Protestant sacred via the imagery of martyrdom. Waldron implicitly points to the ambiguity of shared Catholic and Protestant martyrdom, but a fuller exploration of this idea would bolster her case. In Chapter 5 Waldron extends her study of sacrifice to other revenge tragedies, including Titus Andronicus, as well as to nonrevenge tragedies such as Othello. She argues that Othello focuses on the legalistic sacrifice of Desdemona as a “lively” body. Using the text of Othello as her major source, Waldron focuses attention on written allusions and textual connections as proof that Lutheran and Calvinist arguments against celibacy and priestly confession are present in the play. Her discussion of Titus Andronicus contrasts the bodily sacrifice Marcus and Lucius offer for the unification of Rome and the forced sacrifice of Queen Tamora's sons. Stressing the juxtaposition of these two moments of sacrifice, Waldron submits Titus as a commentary on all that was “pagan” (160) about the Catholic Eucharist. Both chapters approach texts through close reading, presenting some interesting findings, but the discussion of theatrical application could be expanded through further discussion of early modern performance.
Chapter 6 returns to the concept of martyrdom, exploring Dekker's The Virgin Martyr, and here and in her Epilogue Waldron delves into the agency of the character and the actor: Who governs the body? Is it the actor, playwright, manager, or another entity? As it addresses these and other key questions about early modern theatre, the book should appeal to scholars of theatre, as well as historians, literary critics, and scholars of theology and political science, particularly those who specialize in the early modern period. Waldron structures an interesting argument about the dominance of Calvinism in early modern English culture, countering prevailing notions of secularization and remnant Catholicism in England. Consistently aware of her underdog status, Waldron hoists her thesis on the shoulders of respected scholars in the early modern field, including Sarah Beckwith, Julia Reinhard Lupton, and Stephen Greenblatt. The book is a substantial addition to the conversation about faith, theatre, and culture in the early modern period.
