Muhammad al-Atawneh centers his study of the Dar al-Ifta, the Saudi governmental agency for issuing religious legal opinions, in the period from 1971 to 1999. Al-Atawneh begins with King Faysal's reorganization of the Dar al-Ifta in 1971 into two parts—the Board of Senior ʿUlamaʾ (BSU) and the Permanent Committee for Scientific Research and Legal Opinions (CRLO)—both chiefly under the leadership of the prominent Saudi cleric ʿAbd al-Aziz bin Baz, whose death in 1999 marks the concluding point of al-Atawneh's book. In addition, the author provides a substantial introductory discussion of pre-1971 Islamic legal history and theory from the perspective of the Hanbali school of law as interpreted by the Wahhabi ʿulamaʾ.
The bulk of the book concerns the institutional history of the Dar al-Ifta, the role of muftis in Saudi society and government, and the methods and arguments used by muftis in formulating fatwas. Chapters 5 and 6 especially contain useful case studies, dealing with such important subjects as the role of women, television, banks, and medical technology. Numerous examples of fatwas illustrate the case studies. In some of the case studies, the ʿulamaʾ limited change, while in other instances the muftis provided new interpretations of the shariʿa often using the concept of public interest as justification. Lengthy appendices present English-language translations of fatwas issued by the BSU and the CRLO. The author's chief goal is to explore the challenges faced by the Dar al-Ifta when applying Wahhabi interpretations of Muslim shariʿa to the new conditions of the late 20th century (pp. xiii, xvii).
This book may be viewed equally as a useful contribution to the history and present-day situation of Islamic law as well as to the study of contemporary Saudi Arabia. Scholarship on the history of Islamic law has flourished in recent years, especially in the growing number of highly sophisticated works dealing with the Ottoman legal system and its social influences. Works on contemporary Muslim legal systems have often been of a purely pragmatic nature, though Jakob Skovgaard-Petersen's Defining Islam for the Egyptian State: Muftis and Fatwas of the Dār al-Iftā (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1997) established a precedent for a more analytical approach. While the study of contemporary Saudi Arabia was long marked by difficulties in gaining research approval, Frank Vogel's thorough, carefully nuanced, and perceptive Islamic Law and Legal System: Studies of Saudi Arabia (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 2000) opened the way for several recently published in-depth works on the actual functioning of various Saudi institutions. Within the context set by these publications, al-Atawneh has written a sound but narrower work. He looks at a much shorter time period than that covered by Skovgaard-Petersen, while he does not adopt the broad-based approach of Vogel, who considered fatwas both in their actual application as the basis for laws in court cases as well as theoretically. Instead, al-Atawneh explicitly states that the actual application of official fatwas is outside the scope of his book (p. xix, fn. 30).
Al-Atawneh demonstrates a thorough knowledge of Islamic legal history, argumentation, and interpretation, particularly in the Saudi-Wahhabi context. He clearly and convincingly examines the institutional history of the Dar al-Ifta, including its membership and structure; the interaction between that group, the Ministry of Justice, and the Saudi kings; and the legal reasoning underlying a host of fatwas. However, he relies on published and online information. His academic position at an Israeli university no doubt hampered his ability to conduct interviews and perform research in Saudi Arabia. As a result, this work does not contain the kind of in the field research insights provided by Vogel and Skovgaard-Petersen.
The author sets forth a clearly organized development of his topics, but this presentation is marred by a large number of typographical errors, an index that is not comprehensive, and a failure to alert the reader to the links between the fatwas in the appendices and their discussion in the main part of the text. Ending his discussion in 1999 is also problematic. Adding analysis for at least part of the decade of the 2000s so as to consider any legal changes and consequences arising from the events of 9/11/2001 would have enhanced the value of the book considerably. However, the author does successfully provide much needed information and analysis on a number of hitherto murky points, including such matters as the division of responsibility between the BSU and the CRLO. Even more important is the author's thorough and sympathetic historical exploration of Wahhabi legal theory in Chapter 4. In addition, Al-Atawneh adopts a balanced tone when discussing the views of the highly controversial ʿAbd al-Aziz bin Baz, a figure often criticized and even derided outside Saudi Arabia for his conservatism.
Many of Al-Atawneh's case studies deal with topics crucial to the social reforms currently being debated in Saudi Arabia and are thus of present-day interest. Because of Saudi Arabia's important role in the Islamic world, Saudi positions on such matters also have an impact among Muslims who live beyond the kingdom's borders. The author explicates the rigid legal reasoning involved in fatwas dealing with such issues as celebrating birthdays, equality of rights for women, and the role of Sufism. On occasion he goes beyond this to point out the contrast between Saudi inflexibility and the more liberal approach predominant in most other Muslim societies. Al-Atawneh agrees with Vogel that the Saudi ʿulamaʾ can sometimes display flexibility on cultural, economic, and social issues, citing examples and argumentation mentioned in rulings on topics like television, use of the Internet, and certain medical procedures. Muftis have become more willing to consider the use of analogy and consensus and may be more open to considering the interpretations and reasoning provided by Sunni muftis outside the Hanbali-Wahhabi school of thought.
This book may be useful to those interested in the present-day application of Islamic shariʿa to a variety of social, economic, and cultural issues. Scholars interested in Islamic legal theory and history will find this book of some value, though its utility is chiefly related to Hanbali and Wahhabi jurisprudence rather than to other Sunni Muslim legal schools or to Shiʿism. Those studying Saudi Arabia will want to consult the publications of Frank Vogel first to provide a framework for understanding the subject before turning to this source. Al-Atawneh's book is too specialized and expensive to be used in the classroom, but it should be on the shelves of libraries and of scholars specializing in Islamic law, fatwas, and modern-day Saudi Arabia.
