This detailed handbook is concerned with key aspects of what is still – in the short term – at a time of recession and – in the longer term – growing global pressure on the world's resources, defined as ‘development’. The question of whether we need to rethink the question of what ‘development’ ought to be is not addressed and it is to be hoped that future editions of this lengthy report will begin to turn its attention to these questions, before competition for basic resources – food, drinkable water, land, minerals, forestry products – forces us to. This said, this is a very useful sourcebook for those concerned with issues of poverty, inequality and the respective roles of state, market and civil society (NGOs – non-government organisations) in promoting worldwide reductions in poverty, particularly through the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals. The tale told is not an encouraging one and reveals one critical aspect of what is now laughingly referred to as the ‘international community’, that is that group of nation states who drive international political and economic policy or are content to follow it. The report argues for example ‘that current approaches to poverty often ignore its root causes, and consequently do not follow through the causal sequence. Rather, they focus on measuring things that people lack to the detriment of understanding why they lack them’ – a criticism which could be made of many local anti-poverty strategies worldwide. This focus of course is not accidental: a determined examination of the causes of poverty would reveal how its maintenance is in the interests of the richer members of ‘the international community’.
The report reviews the three main approaches to combating poverty – poverty reduction strategies, programmes that target the poor and programmes based around the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals. Whilst there are some gains made in individual countries, and in certain aspects (for example in terms of gender equality), and global progress was made between 1990 and 2005 in terms of reducing the number of poor people (defined as those living on less than $1.25 a day) from 1.8 billion to 1.4 billion, this rate of progress has not been sustained from 2005 onwards. Other UN reports suggest that there will still be at least 1 billion people in poverty in four years time, when the MDG process, as presently constituted, comes to an end. Why is this the case?
The report indicates some of the main reasons for this relative failure. Whilst many individual countries have developed anti-poverty strategies – and much bilateral aid has been used as a lever requiring them to do so – poverty reduction programmes have been directed largely within the framework of one overarching goal set by the International Monetary Fund, that of fiscal stability. This demands low inflation targets and associated macroeconomic frameworks which have simply reflected the earlier practices of structural adjustment programmes: public sector retrenchment and greater support for privatisation programmes which have forced up the price of accessing public services and ensured that substantial capital has flowed out of poor countries into the pockets of global multinational corporations. This, in the end, works against the relief of poverty: as the report indicates, critical issues and obstacles to overcoming poverty include ‘growing levels of inequality; the often contradictory impact of certain macroeconomic policies; and the political and social relations that structure power and exclusion’– but these are ignored.
This last rather coy factor refers to the ways in which the power of individual states has increasingly been circumscribed by the power of multinational companies. The report argues strongly that reducing income inequality is essential for poverty reduction, yet we know very clearly from the experience of many countries which have exposed their economies to the full blast of market forces – as required by the IMF and World Bank – that marketisation, with a growth in the number and size of multinational corporations, brings deepening income inequalities. Although these corporations have engaged in a considerable amount of partnership work with an apparently pro-poor approach, and there are examples of innovative ethical trading and corporate social responsibility initiatives, the report argues, again rather coyly, that business interests have an enormous impact on public policy, with globalisation and liberalisation ‘profoundly’ altering power relations at a state level; further, ‘whether or not such approaches enhance corporate accountability and promote inclusive development remains an open question’. For most of those at the receiving end of such policies, the question is far from open: most multinational corporations pursue ethical trading and corporate social responsibility only insofar as it does not affect the bottom line – that of profitability.
Essentially, as the report concludes, it is not just that economic, social and political policies need to be aligned, and that this alignment must be sensitive to local traditions and economic systems, but that social policy and politics are failing to confront or even acknowledge the economic impact of these wider global pressures, which are in no sense pro-poor. The image that comes to mind is that of running up a rapidly accelerating downwards escalator. Whilst economic globalisation has brought some benefits to some groups of poor people, this is largely coincidental: the opening up of more and more local markets to global intervention for the benefit of rich consumers elsewhere so that, for example, we can have Kenyan roses on our tables at all times of the year and our own relatively impoverished teenage children can afford Primark clothing even at a time of recession brings few social and economic benefits to most of the poor of the producing countries. Perhaps only when we start to recognise that economic growth is neither a good in itself, nor sustainable in the medium term, will we begin to turn our attention to socially useful production. Unfortunately, it may take a global crisis in the availability of key resources to bring us to that recognition and the need to redefine what we understand by ‘development’. At that stage, we can hope that the needs of the world's poor come fully into focus.
