Perhaps the best commentary on why nations can benefit from establishing a new international environmental specialized agency is found in Desai’s important study, which examines the quest to evolve a system for governance of the Earth’s shared natural systems. In framing the pros and cons for creating an international environmental authority, Desai makes a solid case for why the United Nations should supplement its Charter mandate of 1945 by embracing global environmental governance (IEG) as a core mission. As this book makes clear, nations have to date resisted this logic, and elected to set up ad hoc and incremental components of international environmental governance. Driven by the need to halt ever-accelerating rates of pollution and ecological degradation, this “mosaic”, as Desai calls it, is not up to the task. Why have states not done what is required? Desai’s thorough work, a synthesis of some seventeen years of his research, invites its readers to parse the obstacles that confront effective environmental governance.
Desai’s book tracks the intergovernmental negotiations forward from the “Earth Summit” in 1992 to the deliberations of the Governing Council of the UN Environment Programme in 1998, and up to the decisions of the UN General Assembly in 2013, following the inconclusive “Rio+20 Summit” of 2012. Its scope is comprehensive, in nine chapters over 273 richly annotated pages, with an appendix of fourteen primary source materials that lay out the pattern of actual intergovernmental decision-making. Part I of the book frames the “debate” about what sort of environmental international institutions are needed. Part II recounts “efforts at revitalization”, and the struggle to enhance the effectiveness of the many bilateral, regional, or international environmental institutions. Part III examines “Sectoral Law Making”, focusing on several multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs). This section is a succinct and analytic restatement of how MEAs generically function, and compliments Desai’s well-regarded study of the legal status of the MEA Secretariats in public international law.Footnote 4 The book concludes in Part IV, with a thoughtful commentary on “The Future” of global environmental governance. While recognizing the shortcomings of the UN Environment Programme (UNEP), he proposes that inevitably there will need to be a new international structure, which will be “sui generis in view of the nature and uniqueness of this functional area” (p. 271). UNEP will need to be incorporated into the emerging new system, which will also need to be the focus of a United Nations organ, preferably one whose primary role is environmental policy-making, such as a repurposed UN Trusteeship Council. States would need to bring their UN MEAs, and many of the other key environmental agreements, into a synergistic relationship with this new UN regime for international environmental governance. Desai makes a compelling case for the UN General Assembly to act: “the UN General Assembly has a role cut out for itself in the coming decade if there is a genuine desire to ensure that the IEG jigsaw falls into its place that serves the long term interests of the ‘peoples’ of the United Nations” (p. 273).
What evidence is there that states have, or will arrive at, a genuine desire to advance IEG? The book at its outset notes that the UN Member States are committed to negotiating Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and entrusting to a High Level Political Forum the task of reviewing their implementation in the context of the post-2015 development agenda (p. 43). After the publication of this volume, the 70th Session of the UN General Assembly accepted the preparatory negotiations for the SDGs. Entitled “Transforming our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development”, UNGA Resolution A/RES/70/1 was adopted unanimously. The SDGs establish environmental protection as a predicate for further socioeconomic development. Put simply, by their own “indicators”, the prioritized steps to pursue in attaining each SDG, these Goals cannot be attained by 2030 without IEG.
For the next fifteen years, states will strive to arrive at a “genuine desire” to attain goals for securing potable water worldwide. Measurable protection of the marine and terrestrial environments must be advanced. In short, all SDGs will require establishing elements of IEG. Desai’s book is prescient. It is an invaluable reference for all those who will implement the SDGs in the coming fifteen years. When it first appeared in print, Desai’s book was the centre of a one-day seminar, convened by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN), for UN Member States at the United Nations headquarters in New York. It was received with interest because Desai’s work is the latest scholarship that comprehensively surveys IEG decision-making.
All those engaged in environmental diplomacy will rely upon, and find occasion to return often to, Bharat Desai’s study on IEG.
