Burma's Economy is an economic history of Burma, from its conquest by the British in the late nineteenth century to the end of twentieth century. It is a well-written narrative that will be accessible to a wide range of readers, including students, who will learn much from its information-packed 212 pages of text and well-chosen supplements, including photographs and even newspaper cartoons.
The story the book tells has many elements familiar from the history of former colonies. Colonial rule heavily emphasized a primary product (rice, in this instance). After an initial period of agricultural growth based on expanding area under cultivation (an arduous task, involving the clearing of dense forests) agricultural growth slowed as the land frontier was reached, and productivity stagnated. The role of moneylenders, especially immigrants (in this case Chettiars from India) was controversial: while on the one hand they financed expanding cultivation, they also seized land (albeit reluctantly) when peasants defaulted on loans, which led to resentment. The modern sectors of the economy—finance, international trade, industry—were dominated by expatriates. Hostility towards the expatriates and a negative perception of colonialism led to inward-looking and statist policies after independence (in 1948). Post-independence, economic policy had several features common to import-substitution regimes, including compulsory procurement of the primary export, rice, at low prices, overvalued exchange rates, and a commitment to industrialization-led growth. This strategy failed to deliver. In another familiar note the story includes a group of talented western-trained economists (the list here includes Hla Myint and Ronald Findlay) who were periodically consulted and recommended more sensible policies, but were largely ignored.
But the Burmese story has some special features. The first has to do with human capital. As a late addition to British India (1886) Burma acquired an administration trained in Indian conditions, with a large number of Indian personnel. Geographical proximity to India and free migration brought in Indian businessmen, traders, and even workers in rice mills, docks, and the like. The Indian presence and Burmese exclusion from the modern sectors of the economy and administration was so marked that in the capital city, Rangoon, Indians became the majority. But eventually the Indians retreated and returned to India. This began in the 1930s, with the depression hurting the trader-lenders (as peasant borrowers defaulted), and expressions of Burmese resentment, including, for instance, violent altercations between striking Indian dock-workers and their would-be Burmese replacements. Many Indians left during the Japanese invasion of Burma in World War II. And the process was completed by government policy, driven by Burmese nationalism, post-independence. So, as Ian Brown tells the story, independent Burma began with an extraordinary depletion of essential human capital in business, trade, and administration, which had devastating consequences far into the future. In addition, Burma suffered enormous damage to its physical infrastructure in World War II and also faced a powerful communist insurgency. It was an exceptionally inauspicious beginning.
Burma also suffered, Brown argues, due to its location. Its original conquest was driven by British geo-political fears, and the proximity and threat of China and (especially) India, in conjunction with the bitter colonial experience, induced a sense of siege in post-independence administrations. Protection from external threats and internal unrest (e.g., due to inflation) become paramount considerations. So, when statist policies did not deliver and the army took over in 1962, far from changing course, it took state intervention to extremes rarely seen elsewhere, nationalizing even small enterprise and trade. Predictably, state-owned enterprises were poorly run, and regulations were evaded, leading to a great deal of corruption. Some of this corruption sustained economic activity and even the state itself, the trade in narcotics being one example. Western sanctions in response to this trade, and the regime's human rights violations, further stressed the economy. Subsequent steps towards market-oriented reforms were tentative and limited.
Brown tells a complex story with a light touch, avoiding polemics, and yet effectively describing and providing an explanation for the “ferocity” (p. 96) of state intervention. Still, the book has two shortcomings. Several socialist economies (Cuba, for instance), which have not grown rapidly, have done much better in terms of health and education. Given the professed commitment to socialism in Burma at various times, one wonders how it has done on these dimensions. The book provides almost no information on this. Second, it tells us very little about Burmese society itself, on issues such as wealth or income inequality, relations among ethnic groups, and the like. This reviewer was also struck by the ease with which the army came to power in 1962, and the military regime's longevity, and would have liked to see some discussion of its social composition and base of support. Brown tells a story in which the British, the Indians, the army, and some members of Burma's elites, have prominent roles, but the rest of Burma's population remains opaque. Still, these complaints notwithstanding, Burma's Economy is a hugely informative and extremely engaging account, potentially valuable to a wide readership.
