This first book-length study of the labour institutions created in association with the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) makes an important contribution to research on the international defence of workers' rights. Robert G. Finbow argues that, given serious obstacles to forging any workable global consensus about how to embed social clauses in international trade agreements, regional arrangements such as the NAFTA's labour ‘side agreement’, the North American Agreement on Labor Cooperation (NAALC), may offer the best opportunity to do so. This is the main significance of undertaking an assessment of the NAFTA labour rights experience.
Finbow frames his analysis of the NAALC by surveying the debate concerning international trade agreements and labour rights. Does the defence of workers' rights as human rights constitute a moral imperative, especially where egregious forms of exploitation such as child or forced labour are concerned? Or do efforts to enact uniform labour standards without regard to countries' differing levels of economic development in fact represent a thinly disguised form of protectionism? The governments of a number of developing countries have taken the position that lower wage costs are a legitimate comparative advantage in international trade, and that international activism in support of freedom of association and other labour rights is little more than an attempt by workers in advanced industrial countries to protect their more favourable wage levels and employment conditions from competitive pressures. As this book shows, the NAALC experience offers evidence to support both positions.
Finbow devotes a separate chapter to the diverse educational, training and research initiatives undertaken by the NAALC's trinational secretariat, the North American Commission for Labor Cooperation, in order to fulfil its charge to promote better mutual understanding of each NAFTA signatory country's labour laws, industrial relations practices, and labour markets. The core of the book, though, consists of a detailed presentation of the 33 so-called public submissions filed between 1994 and 2005 before the US (20 cases), Mexican (8 cases) and Canadian (5 cases) national administrative offices (NAOs), which are responsible for investigating allegations that a signatory country is failing to enforce its own labour laws or conform to the broad labour rights principles recognised in the NAALC. Finbow's analysis is based primarily on a thorough examination of the submissions and the extensive documentary record they engendered, supplemented by occasional interviews with parties to the filings and the government officials who handled them. His summaries capture accurately the intricacies of the issues involved, yet the style of presentation – at times, a straightforward listing of the charges and counter-charges made in the submissions – is very dry.
Trade union and human rights activists have been deeply frustrated that they have generally been unable to employ NAALC procedures to protect individual workers whose rights have been violated. The main difficulty is that, largely because of concerted opposition by the Mexican and Canadian governments at the time the agreement was negotiated, the NAALC lacks strong enforcement provisions. Critics also note that, in a free trade agreement that provides extensive legal guarantees of the property rights of foreign investors, such fundamental labour priorities as freedom of association and the rights to bargain collectively and to strike are ineligible for the full range of NAALC investigative procedures and trade-based sanctions. Furthermore, they point out that even in cases in which NAOs have documented violations of the labour rights most strongly protected under the NAALC (prohibitions on child labour, occupational health and safety measures, and minimum wage standards), the public submissions process has yielded nothing stronger than NAO recommendations for consultations between or among government labour ministers on the broader issues involved. No penalty has ever been levied against a NAFTA signatory country for labour rights violations.
One of Finbow's most important accomplishments is to identify areas in which, despite the NAALC's manifest limitations, some positive results have been achieved. In several instances, the political pressures resulting from highly publicised NAO investigations did produce changes in corporate or government policies, although Finbow notes that these policy shifts were not always permanent. In addition, cross-border collaboration in the preparation of public submissions has promoted closer ties among trade unions, labour rights organisations, and human rights groups in Canada, Mexico, and the United States.
One strength of this book is that Finbow introduces the NAALC case by outlining various alternative approaches (ranging from unilateral initiatives by individual states to multilateral action by the ILO) and strategies (norms definition by the ILO or legislative action by the European Union, trade-related sanctions imposed by national governments, the promotion of voluntary corporate standards by nongovernmental organisations, or multilateral enforcement by the NAALC) for the defence of labour rights. However, the absence of a more systematic comparative assessment of the NAALC in terms of these other approaches and strategies makes it more difficult to accept without question Finbow's overall conclusion regarding the limitations of such regional approaches. Indeed, Finbow's conclusion that the specific institutional design of regional labour rights models is crucially important (p. 30), while no doubt entirely valid, makes it incumbent to compare the NAALC systematically with alternative arrangements.
Despite the importance of the book's overall contribution, the text is in places quite repetitive. The presentation is, moreover, marred by frequent typographical and punctuation errors (the handling of Spanish-language names is notably inconsistent), which in some instances obscure the author's intended meaning.
