Nancy K. Bristow's The American Pandemic: The Lost Worlds of the 1918 Influenza Epidemic and Patricia J. Fanning's Influenza and Inequality: One Town's Tragic Response to the Great Epidemic of 1918 offer scholars of American memory and medicine new lenses through which to view the 1918–1919 influenza epidemic and Americans' recollections of the epidemic. The books are part of a recent wave of influenza studies sparked, in part, by the recognition in recent years that influenza poses a continuing threat to humanity. Among the most notable scholarly and semi-scholarly works of the last decade are John Barry's The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague in History; Carol R. Byerly's Fever of War: The Influenza Epidemic in the U.S. Army during World War I; Niall Johnson's Britain and the 1918–19 Influenza Pandemic: A Dark Epilogue; Howard Phillips's “Black October”: The Impact of the Spanish Influenza Epidemic of 1918 on South Africa; and Howard Phillips and David Killingray's The Spanish Influenza Epidemic of 1918–1919: New Perspectives.
The purpose of Bristow's work is to “piece together fragmentary sources to hear voices previously unheard and elucidate the range of ways Americans experienced the pandemic” (6). Bristow is not the first scholar to identify the anomalies of memory that confront and confound historians of the epidemic. Bristow is, however, the first scholar to devote an entire monograph to the amorphous subject of memory as it relates to the epidemic. Her work is expansive and opens new avenues of insight into both public and private remembrance of the broadest, deadliest epidemic in American history.
The subject of memory challenges the historian not least because public and private memories influence one another, each diluting or propelling the other according to myriad emotional and material factors. For this reason, a “coherent” history of remembrance of the epidemic on a national scale is scarcely possible. American Pandemic reflects that swirl of memories. Themes repeat themselves throughout, especially the memories of doctors and nurses. Peoples' recollections of the experience reflect their material experience as well as their roles as nurses, physicians, clergy, mothers, and the like.
Despite the confusion attending memory, Bristow forges order from a cacophony of voices and, extraordinarily, from the web of silence that frequently hides the epidemic's impact on society and families and proves such a daunting challenge to its chroniclers. Bristow establishes a logical sequence of chapters that delineate broad subjects. The first chapter is perhaps the best treatment of the 1889 –91 influenza pandemic and its role in establishing influenza's reputation as an annoying, though harmless, disease. Widespread acceptance of influenza even by medical professionals as little more than the sniffles, argues Bristow, helped set the stage for America's conceptualization of the next epidemic and society's subsequent lack of memory. The chapter resists a laborious, and unneeded, recapitulation of the state of medicine, as it presents well the medical advances of the Progressive Era. The next three chapters highlight changing ideologies as well as the experiences of patients and communities, public health experts, and healthcare professionals. The final chapter delves into the costs associated with forgetting the epidemic, especially as it concerns modern epidemiologic challenges that threaten the nation.
The progression of the work is logical and Bristow's notes are exhaustive with no major omissions. American Pandemic's greatest strength is its commitment to the human voice. In the book's opening Bristow reveals the deaths in her own family as a result of the epidemic, deaths that changed the course of her family forever. Even more importantly, in terms of her study, are the ways in which time and silence obscured her family's history and shifted what little had been passed down by oral tradition; her family's experience is a model for thousands of American families whose trajectories were influenced by epidemic losses. When dissecting the vagaries of public memory, Bristow takes care to include the private reflections of public personalities. Her approach yields an emotive history that accurately reflects the interplay of experience, pain, perception, and memory, while never losing sight of the foundation of any scholarly history—the larger context and current of the period.
Bristow's work claims for influenza a larger share in the history of the nation and refutes, with varying success, the obscure role historians insist the epidemic played in the course of American history. Her strongest claim, not surprisingly, is that the deaths of nearly a quarter of a million Americans, about half of them in their twenties and thirties, exerted an incalculable force on families, with the echoes produced by raw grief, the deaths of parents (especially when those deaths resulted in orphans), and loss of household income reverberating for generations. At its most basic, the epidemic disrupted the familial security millions of people took for granted and exerted a profound, if subtle, effect on how millions of Americans faced the future and remembered their past. More difficult for Bristow to explicate are the public memories passed along during the last ninety-five years and the force those memories exerted on American institutions. It is by now quite conventional to claim that the epidemic simultaneously confirmed for many nurses the importance of their profession and sobered the outlook of physicians, whose optimistic assessment of the fight against infectious disease was sundered by their inability to treat patients whose youth and vigor heretofore promised a speedy recovery from a case of the flu. In terms of institutional changes, however, Bristow and all other influenza scholars are confronted with a dearth of records and continue to grapple with the difficulty of ferreting changes that occurred as a direct result of the epidemic, a task that might occupy an entire generation of influenza scholars. For instance, although one can argue that very few memories of the epidemic survived in American culture, historians can find myriad examples of researchers who were prompted to explore pneumonia and further develop the discipline of virology. Although quantitative historians may decry the lack of statistical data in American Pandemic, scholars who value forays into the human condition, and the scars and permutations trauma imprint upon both the individual and societal psyche, will value American Pandemic and likely use it as a springboard to their own studies of the epidemic's long-term impact.
Patricia J. Fanning's Influenza and Inequality is a narrow exploration of community and memory. Fanning uses as her starting point the town of Norwood, Massachusetts. In her introduction Fanning reasons, much as Bristow does in her work, that an event that ripped dozens of lives from the fabric of a small town must have left an impression, at least among the survivors, even when no plaque or statuary memorializes the community's losses. During the 1990s, Fanning collected oral histories from survivors and compared their statements to written records, a comparison that yields important results.
Most histories of the American portion of the global influenza outbreak concentrate on a national narrative, with much of the texture of local epidemics disregarded in favor of sweeping generalizations about the epidemic experience. Those repeated generalizations include the notion that influenza, unlike many other infectious diseases, was no respecter of class, race, or ethnicity. Fanning, however, was told by survivors of their treatment in a town that was increasingly divided in the early twentieth century by the processes of industrialization and immigration. Survivor accounts and Fanning's independent search of records construct a picture of an epidemic that preyed heavily on the town's working poor, those who labored in the town's factories and retired at night to the town's most crowded housing in immigrant neighborhoods that lacked basic city services.
When influenza penetrated Norwood in September 1918, it settled in thickly populated ethnic enclaves, sickening and killing people through November, before abating, only to return in a strong second wave in January 1919. While middle- and upper-class residents sickened and occasionally died, their experiences hardly compared to the misery in tenements that lay within easy walking distance of their homes. Fanning correctly asserts that the elite community leaders' treatment of immigrant residents during the epidemic—arbitrary isolation and quarantine, general medical neglect, and broadsides in the newspaper concerning the tenement dwellers' filthy habits—mirrored their treatment of the “foreigners” before the epidemic. Fanning, then, illuminates the crucial link between pre-existing, socioeconomic medical conditions and the toll the epidemic took. As Fanning notes, some scholars have observed variations in mortality rates during the epidemic, but Influenza and Inequality is the first monograph to examine the reasons, both long- and short-term, behind such variation in morbidity and mortality. That she limits her study to one small town allows her to focus on the structural inequalities of the community and, by extension, suggests that similar inequalities in other communities must have influenced mortality rates, too.
Touchingly, Fanning extends her study of inequality to the treatment of the dead. Of the dozens of mass graves and thousands of unmarked graves that dot America as a direct result of the epidemic, few or none contain the remains of elite or middle class members of society. Such ignominy was reserved for the poor alone. The citizens of Norwood, not wont to extend aid to the least of their neighbors during their lives, continued the tradition even into death. The town burial grounds placed prosperous Catholics on the periphery of the cemetery, isolated from elite Protestants in death as in life. For the poorest of the dead, those without any means of burial and, in one case highlighted by Fanning, a family completely extinguished by the epidemic, perpetual rest came in a remote section of the cemetery in graves separated from the town dump by a fence marked by cheap stones with indecipherable inscriptions or not marked at all.
The works by Bristow and Fanning explore areas that are not novel to the scholars of the influenza epidemic but that have never received the treatment they deserve. Indeed, these works may be considered the first monographs in two new, but allied, directions in the historiography of the epidemic. One path, followed closely by Bristow, explores the memory of the epidemic in the public and private imagination. Her research demands historians closely explore the institutions, agencies, and families affected by the epidemic. Close investigation will yield changes and narratives of the epidemic overlooked by national studies more interested in defining a grand epidemic narrative than elucidating variations in the epidemic's assault. The path Fanning strikes is novel in terms of the epidemic of influenza; most studies have taken a much broader view that annihilates the individual context of those who experienced the trauma of the disease. Community studies form the foundation of understanding of other epidemics, from the cholera outbreaks that took place over the course of two generations in Philadelphia, which were so masterfully examined by Charles Rosenberg in The Cholera Years, through the outbreak of plague and the subsequent immolation of Chinese neighborhoods in Honolulu in James C. Mohr's Plague and Fire. Future scholarly studies of the epidemic, whether articles or monographs, must move beyond the national narratives that have constituted the bulk of the historiography. Narrow regional and community studies express differences in the severity of the disease between and within communities, as well as the memories and changes that the epidemic provoked in life and institutions.
