In recent years, a plethora of memoirs written by Jews who left Iraq in the 1950s have appeared in Arabic, Hebrew, and English. The enthusiasm with which works like Sasson Somekh's Baghdad, Yesterday (Hebrew) or Nissim Rejwan's The Last Jew in Baghdad (English) were received reveals the extent to which issues raised by Abbas Shiblak are still alive in the minds of many Iraqis—Jews, Muslims, and Christians alike.
Shiblak (in an update of his The Lure of Zion) offers a careful construction of Jewish–Iraqi history, evaluates the effects of the Palestine conflict on the Iraqi national community, and provides sociopolitical context that sheds light on factors that led to such a drastic communal act as mass emigration. In doing so, he deconstructs two national narratives—Iraqi and Zionist. He critically analyzes an Arab narrative that emphasized Zionist conspiracies and propaganda and the activities of the Zionist underground. Concurrently, he critiques a Zionist narrative that presupposed the mass immigration to Israel as the by-product of the growth of a Zionist consciousness among Iraqi Jews that reached full articulation in the early 1950s—and that ignored important moments in which members of the Jewish community underscored their loyalty to the Iraqi state. Shiblak convincingly illustrates how the decision to leave Iraq can be understood only in relation to the 1948 Palestine war. He stresses events such as the denaturalization law and its effects and the bombings of Jewish sites during April 1950 to June 1951 as primary reasons for the mass emigration. In addition, he documents the organized global Zionist campaign to bring the Iraqi Jews to Israel and how Israeli politicians used the immigration as a way of challenging Palestinian refugee claims.
First, Shiblak makes an important contribution to our understanding of Iraqi history. He views Iraqi politics as a case study of “the crisis of the Arab ruling class” (p. 31), demonstrating the degree to which Iraq of the late 1940s and early 1950s was characterized by an oppressive political culture. “Constitutional Iraq,” he notes, spent more time than not under emergency rule (p. 69). This culture became of acute importance when pro-British Nuri Saʿid formed a coalition with the ultranationalist Istiqlal party after the military failure in Palestine. “Both partners saw Zionism as a by-product of Communism, and both seemed more than ready to treat the position of the Iraqi Jews in the context of the hostilities in Palestine” (p. 87). Al-Istiqlal's mouthpiece, al-Yaqza, attacked “the three evils: the communists, the Zionists and the Jews” (p. 88) while efforts “to eliminate Jews from the army, the police, and the public services” (p. 91) created “vicious circles of suspicions” (p. 92). Arrests and violent political spectacles, current in the Iraqi political culture of the time, were also employed in the Jewish domain, as seen in the case of the public hanging of Shafiq ʿAddas (1948) for allegedly selling British arms to Israel. This “grotesque publicity” angered many Jews. However, there were other political organizations, like the social democratic al-Ahali, that challenged the ultranationalist voices (p. 89).
Second, the text analyzes British sources, mostly PRO documents, perceptively and often against the grain of their authors' intentions. Shiblak demonstrates how transfer schemes, toyed with by the British in the aftermath of the 1948 war, turned into bitter realities. The violence of colonial language is reflected in a British response to Nuri Saʿid's threats to expel Iraqi Jews to Israel: “Iraq would be relieved of a minority whose position is always liable to add to the difficulties of maintaining public order in times of tension…. The Israeli government would find it hard to resist an opportunity of bringing a substantial number of Jews to Israel” (p. 111). Iraqi Jews are thus denied any agency and are only conceptualized in relation to “public order” and the desires of the Israeli state. Another example appears in a summary of a correspondence with British legations concerning the proposed exchange of Iraqi Jews for Arab refugees (1949), observing that “the elimination of certain minorities might lead to more stability … in the Middle East” (p. 180). Shiblak also highlights the tensions in British officialdom, noting how some British officials feared the effects of the Jewish emigration because of the prominent role of Jews in the Iraqi economy (p. 121).
Third, Shiblak deals with the history of Iraqi Jews in a comparative framework, providing data on Jews in other Arab countries that underline the assimilation of Jews in the Iraqi nation state. The rise of the democratic wing of Arab nationalism appealed greatly to Jews in the 1940s. During the popular uprising against Iraq's comprador government in 1948 (the wathba), Jews protested with fellow Iraqis against socioeconomic injustice. Shiblak writes, “There was considerable sympathy for the plight of European Jews, for whom Israel offered a home, and probably some pride was felt in the fact that Jews had established a state….” Zionism, conversely, brought with it a clash of loyalties with “the people among whom they lived, and to their own traditions and culture, which reflected those of the wider Iraqi society,” and thus sympathy for Israel did not entail commitment to immigration (p. 97). Shiblak does not treat the Jewish community as monolithic and takes note of the tensions between the traditional rabbis and the new elements that took over after 1948.
Fourth and finally, the book includes a thoughtful introduction by Peter Sluglett, a rich bibliography, and important appendixes that will be of great use to teachers of both Middle Eastern and Jewish history. The sources include important studies in Arabic, often based on Iraqi state documents, like ʿAbd al-Latif al-Rawi's exploration of the communist League for Combating Zionism (ʿUsbat Mukafahat al-Sahyuniyya), which included many Jewish members. In addition, the book introduces important sources in Hebrew (although often misspelled) written by Zionist activists and emissaries.
Shiblak correctly identifies the importance of Jewish cultural activity in Iraq and lists names of several Jewish Iraqi journals and Iraqi Jewish intellectuals. He notes that the spread of education during the interwar period accelerated secular and modern trends that created a stronger involvement of Iraqi Jews with the Arab and Iraqi nation. Nevertheless, closer attention should have been paid to the nuances, tensions, and contradictions that typified the Jewish cultural field. For example, the newspaper al-Misbah was sympathetic to certain Zionist causes, whereas the cultural magazine al-Hasid hosted most of Iraq's prominent Muslim and Christian intellectuals and was considered one of the nation's leading publications.
Another curious question that remains unanswered is how Iraqi Zionist activists negotiated their identity. Unlike European Zionists, Iraqi Zionists knew that Palestine could not have been a land “with no people.” Did this knowledge, then, generate another type of Zionism, different from the European model? The involvement of Jews in the Communist movement could have been expanded, particularly involvement in lower ranks of the party. Important episodes such as the hangings of Sasson Dallal and Judah Sadiq, which had deleterious effects on the self-image of the community, might also have been dealt with in greater detail.
Nonetheless, this is an important work that expands the meaning of 1948 into new realms. In the current state of affairs, detailed and nuanced studies on Iraqi history are highly desirable. Shiblak's study certainly responds to these needs.
