This book asks two important questions. The first is why is there so much violence in Brazil's ‘marvellous city’, Rio de Janeiro? Second, what can be done to curb this violence? Arias offers answers through ethnographic studies of three of Rio's slums (favelas): Tubarão, Vigário Geral and Santa Ana, proposing what he calls a network perspective on the problem. Arias suggests that the common perception, that the absence of the state in favelas allows for violence, is misleading. It is not the absence of the state that leads to violence, he contends, but rather the construction of a particular kind of state order in these localities. Furthermore, portraying favelas as part of stable, traditional patron-client relationships is also largely incorrect. Instead, loose, shifting networks link drug traffickers, the police, politicians, and the leaders of community associations (associações dos moradores, or AMs) and NGOs. Upsurges and declines in violence are due at least in part to transformations in these networks. Furthermore, the location of favelas has a major influence on the character of their networks. Arias thus accounts for variation and change in patterns of violence in a persuasive manner.
The main actors involved in favela violence are drug traffickers, who need the cooperation of other favela residents and protection from the police and politicians; AM leaders, who seek external resources and some kind of modus vivendi with traffickers; politicians, who want to enter favelas to garner votes; and NGO leaders who want to promote successful programmes and move on to better positions within the NGO community. The most ambiguous actors are the police, because they can collude with criminals, collecting bribes and abusing law-abiding citizens, or they can enforce the law – either through some kind of community policing programme or through more overtly repressive means. Violence rages in favelas when there are turf-wars between traffickers or between traffickers and the police; when the police are corrupt and abusive; and when AMs are internally divided.
Arias' response to the second question, ‘what can be done?’, is equally suggestive. The strengthening of civil society, he argues, can exacerbate violence if drug traffickers control civil society organisations. The quality of civil society and its networks are as important as the number of associations, the size of their membership, and the nature of their members' participation. Formal political institutions are less important than the characteristics of informal networks within the favelas and between the favelas and the outside world. Violence is curbed when a crisis provokes a rupture in illegal networks and brings media attention; when an AM with relative independence from traffickers and skilful political leadership can emerge; when counter-mobilisations can be organized by the AM and state and civic actors outside the community; and when political reformers can introduce police reforms and promote greater respect for human rights and the rule of law by the police, enhancing police-community cooperation. In both Vigário Geral and Tubarão, Arias argues, these conditions held for a few years, and violence was diminished. However, this was only a temporary scenario. The structural conditions favouring violence are considerable, and community activists who succeed in reducing violence were victims both of ‘movement fatigue’ and their own success (with media attention declining as spectacular incidents of violence disappeared, and NGO leaders moving out of the community to work on other projects). Arias therefore conveys a message of somewhat muted optimism.
The book's main arguments are laid out in chapters 1–5. Chapter 6 extends the analysis based on the three Rio favelas to other cities in Brazil (São Paulo, Belo Horizonte, Vitória, and Porto Alegre) and other countries in Latin America and the Caribbean (Colombia, Mexico and Jamaica). This is probably the least satisfying chapter in the book. Ethnographers will probably find it under-researched, while social scientists searching for a theory of urban violence might be disappointed by its somewhat loose approach. Although Arias is able to show how elements of the political structure in each place, including the party system, shape the nature of criminal networks, this excursus lacks the analytical rigour and consistent focus of the earlier chapters.
Chapter 7 finds Arias back on his home turf, in the book's strongest theoretical chapter. This summarizes the main argument in a way that does justice to the rich case studies presented earlier. Arias drives home his point that ‘Trafficker power … comes not from state absence, but, rather, from the way that the state is present’ (p. 192). The epilogue updates the story of the three favelas, providing graphic evidence of police corruption and violence (some of which took place under the banner of community policing). Arias concludes, ‘Until political leaders in Rio, and in Brazil more broadly … recognize the complicity of the political system, of formally democratic institutions, of local and national leaders, of elements of civil society, of the trade in drugs and arms, and the international economy more generally in the ongoing conflicts affecting this city there will be no solution to the problems faced by the millions of Brazilians who live under these horrible conditions’ (pp. 214–5).
Arias' analysis of the subtle inter-connections between various actors in the favelas is a major contribution to our understanding of Rio's urban violence. It is also a refreshing antidote to the earnest but misleading dichotomies of much official discourse.
Furthermore, Arias' book complements the writings of a new generation of scholars of Brazilian politics who have largely embraced the rational choice perspective, new institutionalism, and quantitative methods, and who thus study formal political institutions almost exclusively. Arias adds a distinctive voice to this generation in terms of his subject matter, theoretical perspective, and methods. As pressures mount in Brazil to improve public policies so as to curb violence, criminality, and corruption, this voice will become increasingly valuable.
