Karen G. Ruffle's Gender, Sainthood, and Everyday Practice in South Asian Shiʿism places ethnographic research on rituals performed in Hyderabad during the Islamic month of Muharram in the context of South Asian epic literature and vernacular culture, pan-Islamic narratives and discourses, and the values of what the author terms “cosmopolitan Shiʿism.” Ruffle defines cosmopolitan Shiʿism primarily as belief systems and ritual practices endorsed and propagated by Shiʿi centers of learning in Iran; secondarily, it connotes the aspects of the tradition that are universally recognized by the global Shiʿi community. The text as a whole is unique among recent ethnographic studies of South Asian Shiʿi Islam in that it draws upon the time that Ruffle spent in Iran; her experience there provides a counterpoint to her time in Hyderabad, grounding her notion of “cosmopolitan Shiʿism” in specific conversations and ethnographic observations.
The book focuses on issues of gender, sectarian identity, and the relationship between the everyday and ritual lives of the Shiʿites of contemporary Hyderabad. The text is generally readable and moves deftly from description of rituals and texts to abstract theorization; notable moments in the field and conversations with subjects in India and Iran are nicely described and provide starting points for addressing larger issues of religious identity and gender roles. The book's most valuable contribution is its focus on the previously understudied rituals surrounding the commemoration of the battlefield wedding of eleven-year-old Fatima Kubra (the daughter of the third Shiʿi imam, Husayn) and her thirteen-year-old cousin, Qasim (son of the second Shiʿi imam, Hasan). Other scholars—most notably David Pinault and Afsar Muhammad—have published rich ethnographic studies of Shiʿi ritual practice in Hyderabad and India more generally, and Amy Bard's work on Shiʿi women's participation in recitation of poems in praise and memory of the martyrs of Karbala provides insight into the areas of gender and everyday life that are also central to Ruffle's text. Combining a focus on gender with attention to ritual acts of remembrance and mourning, Ruffle takes the notion of imitable sainthood in Shiʿism and the complementary notion of Husayni ethics and suggests that women (and men) in the Hyderabadi Shiʿi community draw upon the stories and rituals surrounding the tragic wedding to understand who they are and who they aspire to be as well as to improve their lives.
With specific regard to gender, Ruffle documents the ways in which the female saints of Karbala are not only strongly (and positively) gendered female role models for Shiʿi women but also figures whose personae can be inhabited by men as a means for men to express their devotion to the martyrs of Karbala. However, as an ethnography that purports to document the ways in which Shiʿi saints serve as socioethical role models, the text's arguments about the relationship between the gendered female saints of Karbala and the everyday lives of Hyderabadi Shiʿi women would have been more compelling had Ruffle described and discussed more examples of the relationships that women develop with these saints—brief discussions of women named Kulsum (p. 128), Ashghar, (p. 59–63) and Sarah (pp. 13–14) constitute the only specific engagement with individual women offered by the text as a whole.
The book does a thorough job of documenting the many ways in which South Asian vernacular culture has shaped the rituals and narratives surrounding the commemoration of the battlefield wedding of Fatima Kubra and Qasim and, just as important, the ways in which Hyderabad's Shiʿa do and do not feel the need to justify this “local” influence. This is the text's other contribution to the literature on Shiʿi practice in contemporary India: it offers a historically and culturally grounded exploration of the issue of authority in contemporary South Asian Islam and the way that texts, social relationships, local leadership, and the forces of cosmopolitan Shiʿism all shape the practice and reception of the ritual commemoration of the wedding of Fatima Kubra and Qasim. Ruffle's discussion of the relationship between cosmopolitan and vernacular Shiʿism as one of making equivalences is a welcome and, it would seem, accurate conceptualization of the ways in which different forms of Shiʿism coexist in living communities (pp. 159–61).
In making her argument, Ruffle engages an often atemporal blend of sources and narratives in what is likely an effort to present the world inhabited by contemporary Hyderabadi Shiʿa. Thus, she moves quickly between pan-Islamic stories about early Islamic figures, notable texts from influential Sufi and Shiʿi theologians and teachers, Persian and Deccani-Urdu epic poems detailing the suffering of the martyrs of Karbala, Indian epics and poems, and ethnographic description of ritual mourning practices in contemporary Hyderabad. No doubt this mixture reflects the world inhabited by the community that is the focus of Ruffle's work. However, using a historical or, more important, theoretical framework to justify and explain the inclusion and integration of the text's selection of sources would have helped keep it from occasionally feeling like a somewhat hagiographic view from nowhere in particular, rather than a scholarly engagement with the Shiʿi community of Hyderabad.
Because Ruffle draws upon diverse literary, linguistic, and ritual sources in an effort to capture the everyday world inhabited by Hyderabadi Shiʿa, it is likely that, depending on the reader's area of expertise, different parts of the book will seem to offer unnecessarily lengthy recapitulations of basic information. Thus, for example, much of Ruffle's description of the distinctions made between different types of sainthood in the Shiʿi tradition and the Sufi tradition will not be news to scholars of Shiʿism or Islam more generally, but these same scholars will likely benefit from Ruffle's description of the character of Sita in the context of the Indian epic, the Ramayana. That said, because it draws upon a diverse range of sources, Gender, Sainthood, and Everyday Practice in South Asian Shiʿism will be of interest to a wide range of readers, including scholars of South Asian religion and global Shiʿism. Those interested in gender will also benefit from the text. Because it is relatively short and written in an accessible and generally engaging style, the book is suitable for use in advanced undergraduate classrooms.
