Americans seem to have an ambivalent attitude about religion. They find it to have a civilizing effect on political and social life, but they are also cautious about the extent to which it should mix with political power. They insist that their political leaders uphold religious values, but they want religion to be a private matter left up to conscience, not law. Recently, religion has been a topic for debates about political elections, the war on terror, and judicial decision making. Making sense of these debates requires historical and theoretical knowledge about American political and religious experience. Ellis Sandoz's Republicanism, Religion, and the Soul of America aims to provide both historical and theoretical analysis that illuminates the relationship between religion and American politics.
Sandoz is a leading authority on the political theory of Eric Voegelin, and he has written on the American political order, especially the founding period. Republicanism, Religion, and the Soul of America combines these topics. The book is divided into two parts. The first four chapters discuss religion and the American founding, and the final five chapters are an exposition and analysis of various aspects of Voegelin's political theory. Voegelin's work provides an excellent foundation for analyzing religion and politics because it examines the spiritual roots of political order in a variety of historical periods and civilizations. It is not apparent, however, how the discussion of American republicanism in the first part of the book fits with the chapters on Voegelin.
The section of the book that pertains to the American founding and religion argues that scholars tend to overemphasize the influence of Enlightenment ideas and underemphasize the contribution of Christianity on the formation of the American political order. The founders' intellectual genealogy includes classical and Christian theorists and modern thinkers like Sir Edward Coke, Locke, Montesquieu, and Blackstone who “nurtured” the older tradition in a way that made it a living force in the minds and hearts of the founding generation. For example, the American Constitution creates a mixed regime of separated and checked powers that can be traced back through its theoretical lineage to Montesquieu, Aquinas, Polybius, and Aristotle. American republican theory stems from rich and deep religious roots, as Tocqueville noted, including its view of human nature, liberty under law, consent of the government, and resistance to tyranny. These are the primary characteristics of American identity. The historical and cultural context for the American founding is imbued with Christian attitudes about the human condition and the divine origins of law noted by the ancient Hebrews, Aquinas, Richard Hooker, and Coke. Even Locke is cast as a “Christian philosopher” who influenced the development of American republicanism. Sandoz concludes that the American founding was “essentially anti-modernist” in its conception of limited government.
Once Sandoz characterizes the classical and Judeo-Christian origins of the American political tradition, he expresses his prejudice for American exceptionalism. He suggests that American political values have a universal aspect in part because of their Christian origin. The Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, and Abraham Lincoln articulate what Sandoz calls, following Adams and Jefferson, “Americanism,” the common sense of the founding generation and its homonoia (like-mindedness). This “unity of mind and spirit” (111) animates America's role in the world and justifies her just wars against tyranny in the twentieth century and the war on terror in the twenty-first century. In the final chapter, Sandoz even suggests that Voegelin, although with qualifications, supported the exportation of American representative government abroad. Sandoz states that, “with appropriate adjustments to time and tradition, representative democracy is a general form of government not unique to any specific culture but capable of great adaptations” (192). Americanism is juxtaposed to “anti-Americanism,” an ideology that strives to centralize power even to the totalitarian extreme. The world is divided into those who support Americanism and those who are Anti-American.
Just about at the midpoint of the book, Sandoz abruptly shifts topics from early American republicanism to Voegelin. The chapters on Voegelin are not connected or theoretically integrated into the early chapters on American republicanism or to each other. The first Voegelin chapter is on religion and the debate about whether he was sufficiently Christian. It contains a bold statement about Voegelin and Christianity that aims to respond to Voegelin's Christian critics: “[T]he real question may not be whether Voegelin was Christian, but whether Christianity is sufficiently Voegelinian to hold its place intellectually and spiritually in the unfolding reality experienced in modern human existence” (120). A chapter on Voegelin and Leo Strauss may be of interest to those who find their correspondence intriguing, but it seems out of place given the title of the book and the topics discussed in the first part of the book. The ensuing chapters are, likewise, divorced from the first section of the book.
Sandoz's analysis of religion and American republicanism would benefit from essential distinctions between different theoretical strains in the founding generation. Jefferson, Thomas Paine, Madison, Hamilton, and Adams represent a wider range of views, especially concerning the human condition and the nature of politics, than Sandoz is willing to admit. Irving Babbitt's Democracy and Leadership (1924) is an example of an analysis of American's spiritual roots that is sensitive to the tension between competing traditions. Jefferson and Paine are part of a romantic, even Jacobin, tradition that follows Rousseau's humanitarianism and leads to more direct and participatory democracy at home and the quest for empire abroad. This tradition is part of the theoretical and spiritual substance of American exceptionalism, but it competes with the tradition identified by Walter McDougall in Promise Land Crusader State (1997) as the “Old Testament.” What Sandoz assumes about Americanism and its global application is inconsistent with the American tradition represented by Washington, John Adams, and Hamilton. This tradition supports a far more modest role for America in the world and it leads not to populist democracy but to a sober brand of republicanism grounded in the classical and Judaeo-Christian experience Sandoz supports.
Republicanism, Religion, and the Soul of America asks one of the seminal questions about the state of American order at home and abroad: What is the American identity? The search for American identity requires an understanding of historical and theoretical origins. The book provides a description and analysis of these origins, but it tends to ignore the tensions within the American experience that illuminate the complexity of American identity, a complexity that prods one to hesitate before embracing the universality of America.
