Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T06:31:43.554Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Welfare analysis of conditional indexation schemes from a two-reference-point perspective*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 October 2008

RENXIANG DAI*
Affiliation:
Netspar, CentER, Tilburg University, PO Box 90153, 5000 LE Tilburg, The Netherlands
J.M. SCHUMACHER*
Affiliation:
Netspar, CentER, Tilburg University, PO Box 90153, 5000 LE Tilburg, The Netherlands
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Conditional indexation has recently attracted interest with pension funds that are looking for a middle way between defined benefit and defined contribution. In this paper, we analyze conditional indexation schemes from a life-cycle investment perspective. Welfare analysis is applied to investigate the performance of such schemes relative to alternative investment strategies such as fixed-mix policies. We carry out this analysis in the context of a broad family of utility functions, which takes into account the possible presence of two benchmark levels corresponding to a minimum guaranty and to full indexation, respectively. For the purpose of comparability, we construct a self-financing continuous-time implementation of the conditional indexation scheme. The implementation involves continual adjustment of the parameters of the contingent claim representing final payoff. Our findings indicate that, in situations where large weight is placed on the benchmark levels, conditional indexation is fairly close to being optimal.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 2008 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The two-parameter class of utility functions (2). This figure visualizes the utility function for different values of the kinkedness parameter: κ=1 (dash-dotted), κ=2.25 (dotted), κ=5 (dashed), and κ=10 (solid). Other parameter values are: γ=1, θ1=223, and θ2=495

Figure 1

Table 1.The parameter values

Figure 2

Figure 2.The optimal pension as a function of stock market return. This figure shows the optimal pension payoff for the utility function (2) as a function of the stock index return assuming the parameter values: κ=10, γ=1, θ1=223 and θ2=495 (bold line). For comparison, the figure also shows the optimal profiles for a CRRA utility (κ=1, γ=3; drawn line), the standard logarithmic utility (κ=1, γ=1; dotted line), and a utility function with only one kink (θ2=∞; dash-dotted line). For parameter values not mentioned here, see Table 1

Figure 3

Figure 3.Cumulative distribution of the optimal pension for different values of κ and γ. The figure illustrates the impact of κ and γ on the optimal investment through simulated cumulative distribution function of the resulting pension value at time T. The plots on the first row are for fixed γ and varying values of κ, whereas those on the second row are for κ=1 and varying values of γ. For parameter values not mentioned here, see Table 1

Figure 4

Figure 4.The optimal stock weight. The figure shows the optimal stock weight as a function of time and return on stock markets. The ‘time’ axis represents the calender time, whereas the ‘return on stock market’ axis the return on the stock index so far. It is assumed that κ=10 and γ=1. For parameter values not mentioned here, see Table 1

Figure 5

Figure 5.Simulated histories of the strike and the guaranteed level. The upper panel is a simulated scenario of the stock index over 40 years, and the corresponding histories of the strike and the guaranteed level are in the middle and lower panels, respectively. In the middle and lower panels, the histories based on the two-way updating rule are represented by a solid line, and those based on the ratchet updating by a dashed line. For the parameter values of the simulation, see Table 1

Figure 6

Figure 6.The pension benefits resulting from the ratchet conditional indexation. The figure shows the pension profile from the ratchet rule of conditional indexation. The upper panel presents a simulated histogram of the pension rights, whereas the lower panel illustrates the relation between the return on the stock index and the amount of pension rights. The number of simulations is 10 000. See Section 2.2 for the parameter values of the simulations

Figure 7

Table 2.The welfare loss of various schemes against the benchmark utility with different parameter values (in percent). The table reports the welfare loss in terms of the additional percentage of contribution value which is required for a pension scheme to reach the same level of expected utility as is obtained from the optimal strategy. The numbers in smaller font are the rates of relative risk aversion corresponding to the best constant-proportion schemes. Notice that the first column (κ=1) actually uses the standard logarithmic utility as the benchmark