The Flower of Empire adds to a blossoming genre of cultural studies that traces the movements of single objects of natural history within their historical contexts. Tatiana Holway offers a highly engaging, synthetic account of the Victorian British ‘obsession’ over the gigantic South American water lily known today as Victoria amazonica (Sowerby), hitherto treated in limited analyses of its discovery, classification, acclimatization and usage in architectural design. As a Dickens scholar, Holway builds upon Victorian literary perspectives as well as a rich historical scholarship and new archival research. Whilst generally enjoying this book's flowery prose, the historian in me quibbles with certain matters of fact, bemoans the omission of certain others and cringes at the overuse of Dickensian reconstructions. For general readers, Holway's ‘tale of that singular water lily’ (p. 4) does offer a perceptive window into the fascinating world of Victorian botanical crazes, but more specialized audiences should receive some of its historical interpretations with healthy doses of scepticism.
The arc of Holway's tale begins and ends in British Guiana, a colony in the north-east corner of South America and the natural habitat of Victoria. The plot unfolds with the German explorer Robert Schomburgk's encounter with the lily on the River Berbice on New Year's Day 1837 whilst travelling under the auspices of Britain's Royal Geographical Society. The enormity of the lily's flowers and pads, the latter capable of extending to more than six feet in diameter, quickly attracted international curiosity. The race among noted horticulturalists to acclimatize the plant in Britain climaxed with the success of Chatsworth's head gardener, Joseph Paxton, in producing a bloom in early November 1849. Holway embellishes Paxton's heroism through a retelling of his self-proclaimed integration of principles of the lily's natural design into his architectural specifications for the ‘Crystal Palace’, home of the Great Exhibition of 1851. Sprinkled throughout the narrative are gripping anecdotes, including Queen Victoria's own involvement in various events and the ongoing debate among British naturalists over the lily's official name (resolved, as I argued, in deference to social authority; see ‘“The sceptre of her pow'r”: nymphs, nobility, and nomenclature in early Victorian science’, BJHS (2014) 47, pp. 67–94).
Holway narrates her tale with both humour and wit. Inclusive of all the relevant actors, institutions, events and outcomes, the account is comprehensive. Rightly staged in the chronicling of Victoria's acclimatization are broader contextual developments like the rise of decorative horticulture alongside the craze for collecting and domesticating exotics, innovations in Britain's glasshouse industry, the nationalization and expansion of Kew gardens, and the emergence of international exhibitions as purveyors of nations' innovativeness and industry. To her credit, Holway illuminates certain facets of Victoria's history that are lacking in the standard accounts; I found especially novel her extended analysis of Kew director William Jackson Hooker's close association with Schomburgk throughout the affair, from the earliest communication of Schomburgk's discovery right up to his procurement of the seeds that yielded the first domesticated blooms.
Notwithstanding these admirable points, there are grave factual errors. Cardinal among them, the Botanical Society of London (founded 1836) was never ‘Royal’, and Holway unfortunately makes it so and conflates it with the Royal Botanic Society of London (incorporated 1839), on pp. 87, 168, and 267. Although Victoria was patroness of the latter, and despite Schomburgk's expressed belief in May 1837, she was not patroness of the former as Holway implies on p. 28. These distinctions are critical to the correct identification of the battlefields from which emanated the ‘intramural squabble’ (p. 202) over naming the lily: the (non-royal) Botanical Society of London, from which the president John Edward Gray advanced his campaign for Victoria regina, versus the Royal Geographical Society of London, from which the commissioned botanist, John Lindley (also secretary of the Horticultural Society of London), defended his claim for Victoria regia.
Adding to this quibble, there are omissions of significant details. So, for example, given the eventual currency of the species name amazonica, we should expect identification, by name, of the term's inventor rather than the vague ‘a German naturalist’ (p. 52). This unidentified person encountered the lily some five years prior to Schomburgk, but he incorrectly assigned it to the genus Euryale. He nevertheless had the foresight to associate the species with its natural habitat, and James De Carle Sowerby carried forward the suggestion in 1850 by proposing Victoria amazonica over the competing variants (regia, regina, regalis). Holway's failure to name this German naturalist, Eduard Poeppig, is compounded by similar omissions elsewhere, for example the neglect to name Walter Hood Fitch as the noted illustrator behind the ‘Gorgeous engravings’ (p. 256) of Hooker's 1851 folio volume on Victoria – source for some of the most widely circulating period images of the lily.
Adding to these issues, there are Dickensian and similarly fictional reconstructions, which Holway uses to fill in evidentiary gaps. Usually signalled as such (‘there's no complete record’ and ‘We have Dickens’, p. 122), the hypothetical interludes only further muddy already hazy distinctions between fact and fiction plaguing the book. Holway correctly notes the exclusion of a ‘genealogy of water lilies currently growing in Britain’ (p. 256) from Hooker's 1851 folio, but her extended speculation over why Hooker made the omission has no documentary basis. Nor does her guess that the folio's dedication (not by Hooker, as she errs, but by Fitch) was made to the Duchess of Northumberland as a means of ‘securing her patronage for Kew’ (p. 257). (As I show in my forthcoming study of the Victoria folios, Hooker letters extant both in Kew's and the Duke of Northumberland's archives explicitly describe the dedicatory motives and, among them, cultivating a patroness is not even implied.)
Such misgivings notwithstanding, this is a tale that has beckoned to be told, and Holway has done so in a way that will captivate readers with both a general interest in Victorian floriculture and a specific interest in Victoria's rise to worldwide renown. The main contours of the tale may be reliably useful, but unfortunately its historicity is not so usefully reliable.
