Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T21:09:58.443Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Linear stability analysis of a Newtonian ferrofluid cylinder under a magnetic field

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  31 March 2021

Romain Canu
Affiliation:
Normandie Univ, UNIROUEN, INSA Rouen, CNRS, CORIA, 76000 Rouen, France
Marie-Charlotte Renoult*
Affiliation:
Normandie Univ, UNIROUEN, INSA Rouen, CNRS, CORIA, 76000 Rouen, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: renoultm@coria.fr

Abstract

We investigate the stability of a Newtonian ferrofluid cylinder under a steady magnetic field. Linear stability analysis is performed by imposing a small-amplitude axisymmetric disturbance to the basic state. Admissible magnetic field shapes are found and dispersion relations are obtained for two general shapes: axial and non-axial. For the latter, a wire is needed to avoid a singularity at the cylinder centre. Solutions are plotted for two particular shapes previously discussed in the literature for an inviscid ferrofluid: axial and azimuthal. The applicability of the developed theory to cylinder and jet experiments using a solenoid and a wire carrying a current to create the axial and azimuthal magnetic fields, respectively, is studied. For both cases, results show that the magnetic field has a stabilising effect, as already evidenced. In addition, by solving the equation for the cutoff wavenumber, we show that, unlike the azimuthal case, the axial case cannot be stable for all wavenumbers. Taking into account the ferrofluid viscosity better explains the experimental results on ferrofluid cylinders in an azimuthal magnetic field. By choosing a specific admissible magnetic fields shape, the range of wavenumbers in which the cylinder is unstable can be controlled. A radial magnetic field is one example studied here without providing any details on the means to create the field. This latter case reveals the potential of magnetic fields to control the drop size during the ferrofluid jet breakup. These results may be of interest for applications in the printing and medical fields.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Representation of a cylindrical liquid jet deformed by a varicose perturbation for spatial and temporal stability analyses in the $r\text {--}z$ plane.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Studies on ferrofluid jets.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Representation of the basic state.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Representation of a ferrofluid cylinder enclosed by a solenoid.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Representation of a ferrofluid cylinder with a wire.

Figure 5

Table 1.Experimental conditions of previous experiments on ferrofluid jets and cylinders. Unknown data are represented by the symbol $\bullet$. Data in brackets are used for estimations.

Figure 6

Table 2.Ferrofluid properties under standard laboratory conditions. Unknown data are represented by the symbol $\bullet$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Solutions of the dispersion relation in an axial magnetic field for $Oh=0.55$, $\mu _r=2$ and different $\varGamma _m$; (a,b) $\alpha _r$ as a function of $k$, (c,d) $\alpha _i$ as a function of $k$. Panels (b,d) are blow-ups of (a,c); —— $\varGamma _m=0$; — - – $\varGamma _m=1$; — — $\varGamma _m=5$; - - - - - - - - $\varGamma _m=10$. Black lines correspond to the capillary solutions and grey lines to the hydrodynamic solutions. Vertical dotted lines represent the values of $k_c$, $k_1$ and $k_2$ for $\varGamma _m=0$.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Value of $k_c$ as a function of $\varGamma _m$ for $\mu _r=2$. The inset is a blow-up in the vicinity of low $\varGamma _m$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Solutions of the dispersion relation in an axial magnetic field for $Oh=0.55$, $\varGamma _m=1$ and different $\mu _r$; (a,b) $\alpha _r$ as a function of $k$, (c,d) $\alpha _i$ as a function of $k$. Panels (b,d) are blow-ups of (a,c); —— $\mu _r=1$; — — $\mu _r=3$; - - - - - - - - $\mu _r=5$. Black lines correspond to the capillary solutions and grey lines to the hydrodynamic solutions.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Delimitation of the different stability regimes for any value of $k$ and $Oh$, $\mu _r=2$ and different $\varGamma _m$. From the darkest to the lightest, $\varGamma _m=0$, $\varGamma _m=1$, $\varGamma _m=3$, $\varGamma _m=5$ and $\varGamma _m=10$. Vertical dotted lines represent the corresponding value of $k_c$, and solid lines separate the regimes with and without oscillations delimited by $k_1$ and $k_2$ values.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Solutions of the dispersion relation in an axial magnetic field created by a solenoid for $Oh=0.55$, $\varGamma _m=1$, $\mu _r=2$ and different $\delta _s$; (a,b) $\alpha _r$ as a function of $k$, (c,d) $\alpha _i$ as a function of $k$. Panels (b,d) are blow-ups of (a,c); —— no solenoid; - - - - - - - - $\delta _s=1.5$; — — $\delta _s=2$; — - — $\delta _s=3$; --- $\delta _s=5$. Black lines correspond to the capillary solutions and grey lines to the hydrodynamic solutions. The inset is a blow-up around $k_c$.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Value of $\delta _s$ satisfying condition (4.2a,b) as a function of $k_c$. The inset is a blow-up in the vicinity of small $\delta _s$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Portion of the solenoid where relation (4.1) is valid to within $1\,\%$ as a function of its aspect ratio $\varLambda _s$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Minimum value of $\beta$ as a function of $\varGamma _m$ in an axial magnetic field for $Oh=0.55$, $\mu _r=2$ and $\epsilon =10^{-4}$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Solutions of the dispersion relation in an azimuthal magnetic field for $Oh=0.55$, $\mu _r=2$, $\delta _w=0.1$ and different $\varGamma _m$; Panels (b,d) are (a,b) $\alpha _r$ as a function of $k$, (c,d) $\alpha _i$ as a function of $k$. Panels (b,d) are blow-ups of (a,c); —— $\varGamma _m=0$; --- $\varGamma _m=0.5$; — - – $\varGamma _m=0.8$; — — $\varGamma _m=1$; - - - - - - - - $\varGamma _m=2$. Black lines correspond to the capillary solutions and grey lines to the hydrodynamic solutions.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Solutions of the dispersion relation in an azimuthal magnetic field for $Oh=0.55$, $\mu _r=2$, $\varGamma _m=0.5$ and different $\delta _w$; (a,b) $\alpha _r$ as a function of $k$, (c,d) $\alpha _i$ as a function of $k$. Panels (b,d) are blow-ups of (a,c); - - - - - - - - $\delta _w=0.01$; —— $\delta _w=0.1$; — — $\delta _w=0.2$. Black lines correspond to the capillary solutions and grey lines to the hydrodynamic solutions.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Comparison with the experimental data of Arkhipenko et al. (1981) in an azimuthal magnetic field. (a) Value of $\varLambda ^{*}$ as a function of $N_{Bo,m}$; $\square$, experimental data with a column of 18 cm; ${\bigcirc}$, experimental data with a column of $50\ \textrm {cm}$; grey line corresponds to the inviscid theory of Arkhipenko et al. (1981) and black line to the present viscous theory. (b) Value of $\alpha _{r}^{*}$ as a function of $N_{Bo,m}$; dots correspond to the experimental data; dashed lines to the inviscid theory of Arkhipenko et al. (1981) and solid lines to the present viscous theory. Black corresponds to $R_0=2.1\ \textrm {mm}$ and grey to $R_0=2.8\ \textrm {mm}$. Identical lines are plotted for the ferrofluids FF1 and FF2 of table 2.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Comparison with the experimental data of Bourdin et al. (2010) in an azimuthal magnetic field. Circles correspond to experimental data for different $N_{Bo,m}$ from $1.85$ to $11.57$, the dashed line to the inviscid theoretical prediction made in Bourdin et al. (2010) and the solid line to the present viscous theory plotted for the ferrofluid FF3 of table 2 and $N_{Bo,m}=6.51$.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Solutions of the dispersion relation in a radial destabilising magnetic field for $Oh=0.55$, $\mu _r=5$, $\varGamma _m=0.425$ and $\delta _w=0.1$; (a,b) $\alpha _r$ as a function of $k$, (c,d) $\alpha _i$ as a function of $k$. Panels (b,d) are blow-ups of (a,c). Black lines correspond to the capillary solutions and the grey line to the hydrodynamic solution. Vertical dotted lines represent the values of $k_{c1}$ and $k_{c2}$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Summary diagram of the results.