I was formally introduced to antiracist pedagogy in the spring of 2016, several months before I traveled for the first time to the Rosedale Freedom Project (RFP) in Rosedale, Mississippi, to teach a course on music and politics to high school students. Oft romanticized as the place where blues guitarist Robert Johnson sold his soul to the devil at the crossroads, Rosedale is a small town in the Delta region. The majority of its population is Black, and consistently, more than half of this population has lived below the poverty line.Footnote 1 The RFP seeks to help send its students, the majority of whom are Black and profoundly underserved by the state of Mississippi, to and through college. In preparation for the summer (and at the request of the director of the RFP), I read a number of foundational texts on antiracism and critical pedagogy including Paulo Freire's Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1968), bell hooks's Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom (1994), and Beverly Daniel Tatum's “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?”: And Other Conversations About Race (1997). As a white woman with no prior experience in Mississippi, I also read Nan Elizabeth Woodruff's history of the Delta region, American Congo: The African American Struggle in the Delta (2003) and Jesmyn Ward's novel Where the Line Bleeds (2008), among other texts, and reflected on how to design a course that would further the RFP's mission of “supporting the Mississippi Delta's young leaders in the development of critical consciousness and the practice of justice.”Footnote 2
My experience working with high school students in this antiracist grassroots educational organization—twice in person (2016 and 2019) and once online (2020)—continues to impact my work in the US university in a number of ways. I teach at a public liberal arts college in western New York. Like many departments of music, mine recently committed to reforming its required undergraduate music history survey. I believe in the importance of periodic curricular reforms, particularly those that are student centered. Thus I believe that as we seek to create curricula that require our students to engage with more than a whitewashed history of music, we can also consider how to teach our students to be active agents of change, adept at identifying and working to dismantle the racist policies and ideas that they encounter at their and our institutions. As Ibram X. Kendi argues, the project of striving to be antiracist “requires persistent self-awareness, constant self-criticism, and regular self-examination.”Footnote 3 In what follows, I outline some of my work with the RFP, illustrating how it has spurred my efforts to address curricular reform through a culture of listening within my college's department of music.
The Rosedale Freedom Project
The RFP was established in 2015, but the roots of the organization stretch back much further. In 1998, three alumni of Teach for America founded the Sunflower County Freedom Project (SCFP) in Sunflower, Mississippi. Located just down the road from Ruleville, birthplace of civil rights activist Fannie Lou Hamer, the SCFP seeks to build on the history and spirit of the 1960s freedom struggle.Footnote 4 The SCFP served as the model for the RFP, as well as for the Meridian Freedom Project (MFP), founded in Meridian, Mississippi, in 2014. The three projects joined to form the Freedom Project Network (FPN) in 2016. Each project offers summer classes, year-round tutoring in core academic subjects and ACT preparation, year-round clubs for students interested in subjects often not taught in Mississippi's public schools (gardening, art, film, and poetry, for example), and an Alumni College Success Program.Footnote 5 All of this work is crucial because for years, Mississippi has been in the midst of a massive teacher shortage, a problem that is acutely felt in the state's predominantly Black public schools.Footnote 6
I discovered the FPN through Freedom Summer Collegiate (FSC), a program founded in 2016 to work directly with the FPN to “provide transformative summer seminars to college-bound high school students.”Footnote 7 FPN students who successfully complete FSC summer classes earn college credit from Millsaps College, thereby gaining an important leg up not only on college preparation but also credit toward their degree. In the summer of 2016, my first time teaching an FSC course at the RFP, I was a graduate student; in 2019, as I finished my first year on the tenure track, I applied to teach with FSC again.Footnote 8 I was in the midst of teaching an upper-level undergraduate seminar in which students were grappling with notions of music about/and/as violence. Throughout the semester, I had been thinking about ways to make my teaching more equitable to students from a variety of backgrounds, and thus I was eager to learn what it would mean to transform my upper-level seminar for underserved high school students. Could the students engage with the same difficult material? The answer to this question proved to be a resounding yes. Would I have to scaffold the material differently? Once again, yes. Would I have to account for a greater potential of overlap between lived experience and the material?
I pondered this last question because Mississippi has such a long history of racial violence targeting Black communities. Data gathered by the Equal Justice Initiative shows that from 1877–1950, Mississippi had the highest number of reported lynchings of any state in the United States.Footnote 9 Audre Lorde recalled that in 1968, she spent a “pivotal” year as writer-in-residence at Tougaloo, “a small Black college in Mississippi, where white rowdies shot up the edge of the campus every night.”Footnote 10 Thus the legacy of lynching persisted (and persists) beyond the 1950s. In 2017, the Equal Justice Initiative noted that “lynchings occurred in communities where African Americans today remain marginalized, disproportionately poor, overrepresented in prisons and jails, and underrepresented in decision making roles in the criminal justice system.”Footnote 11 A few weeks prior to my arrival in Rosedale in 2016, a federal judge ordered the school district in nearby Cleveland, a twenty-minute drive from Rosedale, to desegregate its middle and high schools—62 years after Brown v. Board of Education, a stark reminder of this legacy of marginalization.Footnote 12 Of course, in Rosedale (as in many communities across the United States), de facto segregation continues to exist.
As I prepared to teach “Music and Violence” at the RFP in 2019, I considered this particular context of violence and worked to explicitly align my course with the RFP's mission of supporting young leaders. I structured my course around student-led discussion. One of the most powerful discussions occurred in the midst of our examination of music and the Black Lives Matter movement. When a student chose to lead discussion on Janelle Monáe's “Hell You Talmbout” (2015), three of the questions she asked inspired a particularly rich exchange. In response to her first question, “How does it feel listening to this song and knowing that you could be the victim of this kind of violence?” almost every single student in the room had something deeply personal to say. Every student also listened intently as their classmates articulated their answers to this question, which I would never have presumed to ask. Later, the student asked, “Do you feel unwanted in America or in Mississippi because of your race?” Students answered this question by building on the material they had discussed earlier in the week. One student referenced Ta-Nehisi Coates's Between the World and Me (2015) and the danger of being in a Black body in the United States. Another looked to the lyrics of Gary Clark Jr.'s “This Land” (2019), explaining that he did not necessarily feel wanted in the United States but that he felt he belonged (“this is where I come from”). Finally, the student leading discussion asked, “What would you like white listeners to get out of listening to this song?”Footnote 13 The students began talking about how much racist violence hurts, and they pointed to the timbre of Monáe's voice. She shouts and at times, her voice breaks. Listening to “Hell You Talmbout” is a visceral experience. Students asserted that they could hear the pain in Monáe's voice, and they expressed their hope that white listeners might hear, feel, and acknowledge this pain as well.
RFP students found “Hell You Talmbout” so compelling that they brought the song into “Circle Up.” Each day of programming at the Freedom Projects begins and ends with Circle Up, an activity during which students and staff outline goals and “shout out” one another's accomplishments. Students conclude Circle Up by singing a freedom song. At the RFP, students often sing “Woke Up This Morning,” “Oh Freedom,” “Paul and Silas,” and “Which Side Are You On?” At the end of the second week of classes, however, students added “Hell You Talmbout” to their repertoire, the students from my class teaching the song (and its significance) to the other students at the RFP. Thus the RFP students centered themselves and situated “Hell You Talmbout” within the history of the freedom song.
The “Hell You Talmbout” discussion and the action it incited reminded me how important it is for students to build and demonstrate their knowledge in a variety of ways. It also reminded me how important it is for students to believe that they are seen and heard in the classroom. For the most part, RFP students felt they could be vulnerable with one another. Many of the students had lived all their lives in or around Rosedale; they knew one another well, and as Black Mississippians, they had many shared experiences that they wanted to examine together. RFP students were also eager to think beyond their experiences and identities—and to challenge others to do the same.
The US University
In part because of COVID-19, I have not been back to Rosedale since the summer of 2019. I remain connected, however, to many of the students there, and I taught virtually during the summer of 2020.Footnote 14 I also remain committed to the RFP's mission, and lately, I have been seeking to find ways to translate that mission into my work in the US university. How can I, a music history professor, support my students “in the development of critical consciousness and the practice of justice”? In the summer of 2020, my college announced its commitment to “becoming an antiracist college.”Footnote 15 Each department on campus was asked to submit an action plan for the 2020–21 academic year. My department's action plan included convening a commission of music majors, minors, and concentrators “to work together with Music Department faculty on issues of equity and racial justice.”Footnote 16 I was asked to lead the commission. Ten students, five of whom were students of color, volunteered to serve, and over the course of the academic year, they met regularly with me and two other music faculty members.
Our top priority in these meetings was to create a space for students to listen to each other, with faculty shaping and advising the discussion only when necessary; our secondary priority was to create a space for faculty to listen to students. Meetings were always illuminating and always challenging. Sometimes students were willing to open up during discussion; other times they were more guarded. Yet over the course of the year, students asserted the need for structural changes within the department such as curricular reforms and the hiring of faculty of color. Students advocated for an increased awareness of the role of race in the department, expressing their belief, for example, that a student of color from the commission should be guaranteed a seat on the Play Selection Committee for the Musical Theatre Program.
Students also used the commission as a space to address bias-related incidents on campus. In November 2020, someone painted over a campus memorial to George Floyd (1973–2020); the following April, as Derek Chauvin's trial began in Minneapolis, someone painted over the memorial again, identifying himself and boasting about his act on social media.Footnote 17 As students on the commission worked together to process their anger and frustration and discuss their positions on various modes of action, faculty members like myself gained important insights into the issues impacting students’ educations outside the (virtual) walls of our classrooms. I was able to adjust a lesson plan for one of my music history classes so that students could discuss the music and activism of Sweet Honey in the Rock. One of the group's longtime members graduated from SUNY Geneseo, and in April 2021, it seemed important to have students engage this musical, political, and institutional history. Yet without the benefit of student/faculty discussion, I would not have been as poised to respond in this way. It was by drawing on my experience in Rosedale, moreover, that I was able to apply my understanding of listening best practices to a space outside the classroom and then use that understanding to shift the space inside the classroom.
All of this is not to suggest that faculty members like myself do not have their own responsibilities. We cannot expect students, and particularly students of color, to do our work for us. What I mean to suggest is that as we scrutinize and reform curricula, we need to keep in mind the perhaps obvious notion of coupling what and how we teach. When we make space in our teaching to really listen to our students, we are more likely to shape students who are capable of listening to each other and to themselves—and it seems to me that fostering a culture of listening is crucial if we truly seek to dismantle racist policies and ideas.
For years, I have considered leaving a week or two of the schedule in my music history syllabus blank, the idea being that students would help me to determine the content of those weeks. When I taught the standard western music history survey—which at my institution was a two-semester sequence involving History of Music in Western Civilization to 1750 and History of Music in Western Civilization Since 1750—I was never bold enough to do this. I already felt as though I had failed in terms of coverage, and I was afraid of losing control over what semblance of coverage I felt I had managed to attain. Yet my experience teaching in Rosedale, combined with my experience teaching during the tumultuous 2020–21 academic year, has prompted me to rethink my attachment to control in the classroom. Relatedly, it has prompted me to consider more seriously the value of challenging my college students to shape the music history classroom for the moment(s) through which we are living. What if, in April 2021, I had asked my students to research and present on an aspect of music history that they thought we might use to resist racism on our campus? What if I had asked my students to propose an action for our campus, informed by their study of music history? I could still have brought Sweet Honey in the Rock into discussion, but I could have given my students the chance to lead the way. In other words, I could have supported my students “in the development of critical consciousness and the practice of justice,” teaching them to see how their study of music history might help them (and us) to transform our campus and institution and perhaps even the world beyond.
