Historians of science have lavished a tremendous amount of attention on the role of science, technology and medicine in the Third Reich. But the lion's share of the historiography of the post-war period has followed those Germans who emigrated, either before the war or after, and traced their paths in their new adoptive countries. The bulk of such work has focused on the United States and Great Britain, where the majority of émigrés ended up; a smaller share has recently excavated the paths of those who headed to Soviet-controlled territory. What is missing, Klaus Hentschel points out in this slender but informative monograph, is detailed study of what transpired among those who remained in the ruins of Nazi Germany. Hentschel's The Mental Aftermath concentrates on the fate of the community of German physicists as they adapted to this new state of affairs, living in conditions of utter destruction while reflecting on the memories of their global superiority in elite physical science during the Weimar years.
But Hentschel does not wish merely to bring to light a time period and a discipline that have escaped detailed historical scrutiny. Building on the work of Bielefeld historian Frank-Michael Kuhlemann, Hentschel also wishes to reinvigorate the now-dormant historiographical category of ‘mentality’ as a way to recover a shared set of assumptions, aspirations and fears among this geographically dispersed but still rather cohesive social unit. Unfortunately, it is difficult to gauge from this book the uniqueness of this post-war mentality, because we do not have before us the worked-out prior comparison of the Nazi or Weimar mentalities. Hentschel does, however, assure us that the
professional homogeneity after 1945 is a striking contrast. The potent unifier with the postwar physics community in Germany was a common sense of injustice. Unequal governance among the Allied occupying forces, debilitating restrictions on research, and bewildering denazification policies fed indignant rejection of all forms of foreign interference. (p. 170)
All histories of mentalities are at least implicitly comparative, and the comparisons here with the wartime, pre-war or international communities are not fully developed within this volume.
Nonetheless, we learn a great deal in Hentschel's quite useful book. From a documentary base of personal correspondence (both internal to occupied Germany and with émigrés), archival records such as denazification proceedings, trade journal editorials and other sources, Hentschel isolates a series of common tropes which mark out an emergent collective mentality across sizable geographical distances and diverse socio-economic circumstances. The best chapters chronicle German physicists' growing hostility to the notion of denazification and the way in which the process was implemented, as well as rising Russophobia. The evidence here is overwhelming: case after case produces similar language and notions that mark the outlines of a new way of perceiving the world. In this new world view, the German physics community was still isolated both internationally and within Germany, but instead of being isolated by virtue of its superiority, it was now so by virtue of being besieged by insolent émigrés, crude Allied officers and existential threats (hunger and war). In this new context, disavowals of any political interest took on new connotations: ‘After 1945 political aloofness received an additional positive connotation: being apolitical signaled that one was also “politically uncomplicated” (in the sense of denazification) – whether or not it agreed with the facts. Spontaneous avowals of this stereotype were very rarely challenged’ (p. 138). The extensive quotations in the substantive chapters of this book are striking and open a hitherto closed window for the non-germanophone into a scientific community in self-identified crisis. Hentschel has provided a very useful bibliography and a solid name index, but sadly not a subject one, which would have helped orient readers more precisely to the themes that he has so carefully identified in the post-war mentality.
In a volume this compact, there are bound to be omissions. Although the process of historical amnesia whereby German physicists began systematically to forget their involvement with the Third Reich is addressed by Hentschel at some length, the treatment of this topic is less compelling than the discussion of their hostility to the Allies, in large part because it is difficult to isolate an absence through the positive data offered in his documentary sources. Other themes would have benefited from expansion into the broader, truly global, German physics community. The émigrés, for example, are represented here in their interactions with those who remained behind. (The staggering insensitivity of those who stayed to the horrific personal losses of those who left makes for sobering reading.) But how did these émigrés react to the world they found in 1945? Their having left German physics presents a natural experiment; it would be fascinating to follow the evolution of a mentality among those who moved to Great Britain, for example, as they adapted to their own sense of themselves as perhaps no longer ‘truly German.’ There would also be considerable interest in extending the story forward in time a few years, to the point where, after the partition of Germany, the post-war German physics community became two separate national physics communities. To identify these further opportunities is not to fault Hentschel for writing a different book than the one he might have written, but merely to point out that he has opened an avenue of inquiry that scholars would be well advised to develop in multiple different directions (for post-war Japan, for example, or post-Soviet Russia).
