I. INTRODUCTION
In modern debates about the interpretation of David Ricardo’s capital accumulation model (1817), based on the distinction between natural and market variables, one of the most controversial points involves the question of the natural wage. On this topic, for example, Annalissa Rosselli (1985, p. 239) highlights that “the signification given to [this concept] has become the touchstone for discriminating between the various interpretations.”Footnote 1 This paper aims to show how the first edition of Robert Torrens’s External Corn Trade (published in 1815) allows us to better understand the stumbling blocks in Ricardo’s analyses caused by his reference to the concept of natural wage.Footnote 2
It is generally accepted that Torrens’s contribution to the Ricardian theory of natural wage can be found in the emphasis placed on the role of custom in determining the natural wage. Indeed, in the second edition of On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1819), Ricardo cites Torrens’s essay to illustrate the idea that the natural price of labor is not “absolutely fixed and constant” and varies “at different times in the same country, and very materially differs in different countries” (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, p. 96). On this basis, we can wonder whether Ricardo’s praise for Torrens did not, paradoxically, cause a misunderstanding of the latter’s natural wage theory, made public in 1815.
While many historians of economic thought mention Torrens’s contribution to the Ricardian theory of natural wage,Footnote 3 most of their comments are aimed mainly at minimizing this contribution. Edwin Cannan contrasts the definition of the natural wage in Torrens, which he characterizes as containing “considerable vagueness” (Cannan Reference Cannan1903, p. 323), for example, with that of Ricardo, which he calls far “plainer” (ibid., p. 326) and possessing a “definite sense” (ibid., p. 323). This position is also shared by Lionel Robbins and Giancarlo De Vivo. They both lament an absence of truly original elements in Torrens’s essay. After suggesting that “the first edition of the Essay on the External Corn Trade contains an admirable account of the way in which the natural price of labor … may vary from place to place and from time to time,” Robbins adds that “of course the position is not original” (Robbins Reference Robbins1958, pp. 48–49). De Vivo, editor of the collected works of Torrens, offers a commentary that is quite similar to that of Robbins when he states that “this idea of the natural wage as given … was not a novelty introduced by Torrens, but he spelled it out more clearly than any of his contemporaries” (De Vivo Reference De Vivo and De Vivo2000, p. xvii). Following Robbins, De Vivo underscores that Torrens’s conception of the subsistence wage lacks in originality, but praises the strong emphasis placed on the exogenous nature of the division of net product between wages and profits. This unoriginality imputed to Torrens goes a long way to explaining why the work dedicated to this author within the classical school, such as that by Joseph Schumpeter (Reference Schumpeter1954), Bernard A. Corry (Reference Corry, Eatwell, Milgate and Newman1987), and Carlo Benetti (Reference Benetti, Kurz and Salvadori1998), does not address his theory of the natural wage.
The notion that Torrens’s influence on Ricardo was limited to the weight he gave to custom in the determination of the natural wage may seem surprising, for in the preface to his 1815 essay, Torrens claims that his analyses of the natural price of labor and the market price of labor are entirely novel: “The principles of the natural and market price of labor, he [Torrens] does not remember to have seen previously developed, and, he conceives, they throw a new and important light on the manner, in which the price of subsistence influences wages and production” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, pp. xiii–xiv).
Torrens fails to elaborate on this matter. De Vivo considers this to be in reference to the idea that the natural wage must be considered “as very nearly stationary,” though it may vary “under different climates, and with the different stages of national improvement” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, pp. 64–65). De Vivo’s remark is consistent with Ricardo’s acknowledgment of Torrens’s contribution. Hence, it covers only one specific aspect of Torrens’s analyses (the one mentioned by Ricardo) and pays little attention to Torrens’s overall thesis or the main characteristics of his theory. Therefore, the question is to know to what extent the current evaluation of Torrens’s contribution, inspired by Ricardo’s own opinion, may neglect a portion of the influence that Torrens had on Ricardo.
Thus, it appears that the fact that Torrens’s text has been substantially ignored, aside from the passage quoted by Ricardo, raises some doubts regarding his contribution to natural wage theory. Section II of our paper reveals the reasons that led Ricardo to discount some elements of Torrens’s theory. Section III presents the issue confronting Ricardo with regard to introducing the notion that a natural price of labor exists and is distinct from the market price. Section IV develops the thesis defended by Torrens and identifies the key elements of his reasoning. Section V demonstrates that the definition and the role of the natural wage in Ricardian analysis provides grounds for reconsidering the anteriority of Torrens to the author of the Principles.
II. RICARDO’S CRITIQUE OF TORRENS
Albeit not the first to cite the role of custom in determining the means of laborers’ subsistence, Ricardo praised Torrens for having illustrated this issue remarkably well.Footnote 4 At the beginning of Chapter 5 of the Principles, entitled “Of Wages,” Ricardo writes that the price of a basket of goods required for the subsistence of workers and their families represents the “natural price of labor”:
The natural price of labor is that price which is necessary to enable the laborers, one with another, to subsist and to perpetuate their race, without either increase or diminution. The power of the laborer to support himself, and the family which may be necessary to keep up the number of laborers, does not depend on the quantity of money which he may receive for wages, but on the quantity of food, necessaries, and conveniences become essential to him from habit, which that money will purchase. (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, p. 93; emphasis added)
This quote reveals that the classical economists rejected the concept of the physiological minimum to explain the sharing of the net product between wages and profits, but they did not reject the subsistence wage, which Ricardo defined as the real wage at which the population remains steady. The notion that necessities are determined by “habits and customs” (Ricardo 1821, p. 118) is subsequently illustrated in a footnote containing an extract from the first edition of Torrens’s External Corn Trade (1815):
The shelter, and the clothing which are indispensable in one country, may be no ways necessary in another; and a laborer in Hindostan, may continue to work with perfect vigor, though receiving, as his natural wages, only such a supply of covering, as would be insufficient to preserve a laborer in Russia from perishing. Even in countries situated in the same climate, different habits of living, will often occasion variations in the natural price of labor, as considerable as those, which are produced by natural cause. (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 63, quoted by Ricardo 1951–73, 1, pp. 96–97n)
After reproducing this citation, Ricardo adds, “The whole of this subject is most ably illustrated by Colonel Torrens.” We noted above that this footnote did not appear in the first edition of the Principles in 1817, but in the second edition two years later.Footnote 5 Yet, the fact that this reference to Torrens’s essay did not appear in the first edition of the Principles cannot be attributed to the fact that Ricardo was unaware of the essay. In fact, Ricardo was familiar with Torrens’s essay as soon as it was published.Footnote 6 Soon after the publication of the Principles in 1817, Ricardo mentioned Torrens’s displeasure in a letter to Hutches Trower: “I presented Torrens with one of the first copies of my book: he was disappointed that I had not mentioned his name in it, and wrote to me to that effect, claiming some merit as the original discoverer of some of the principles which I endeavored to establish” (“Ricardo to Trower,” 23 Aug. 1817, in Ricardo 1951–73, 7, pp. 179–180).
Since the correspondence between Ricardo and Torrens has not yet been found,Footnote 7 we do not know the exact content of these claims. However, since Ricardo added a reference to Torrens when defining the natural price of labor in the second edition of the Principles, we may safely infer that this latter’s protests were, at least in part, related to the subject of wages.Footnote 8 In the rest of the letter addressed to Trower, Ricardo gives his reasons for initially neglecting to mention Torrens’s work. After protesting that he had no intention of dismissing its value, Ricardo justified this omission as follows:
In the correspondence which ensued between him [Torrens] and me [Ricardo] I endeavored to show ... that on all those points which I had as I thought for the first time brought forward, his published opinions were in fact in opposition to mine, and on those which he said we agreed upon for which he claimed the merit of originality they were all to be found in Adam Smith or Malthus, and therefore neither of us could be called discoverers. (“Ricardo to Trower,” 23 Aug. 1817, in Ricardo 1951–73, 7, p. 180)
In this passage, Ricardo formulates two criticisms of Torrens. The first is a rejection of some of his theory. In fact, like Ricardo, Torrens develops a defense of free trade. However, in contrast to Ricardo, he bases his demonstration on Adam Smith’s additive theory of value, which Ricardo is contesting at that time.Footnote 9 Torrens’s acceptance of this theory is particularly clear when he writes that “every rise in the money price of corn, raises the price of labor; and, through labor, the price of the other necessaries of life” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, pp. 83–84), or that “a rise in the price of corn raises the price of labor, and the rise in labor is communicated to all commodities” (ibid., p. 88). Ricardo believed that an accurate description of the capital accumulation process and its incidence in the distribution of income can be obtained only by abandoning the idea that the price of corn determines the price of other goods.Footnote 10 Thus, at the time of the publication of the first edition of the Principles, it is highly likely that Ricardo found Torrens’s protests all the less convincing in that the latter had since adopted his own ideas:
Have you seen Torrens’ Letter to Lord Liverpool? He appears to me [Ricardo] to have adopted all my views respecting profits and rent; and in some conversation which I had with him a few days ago, he unequivocally avowed that he was now of my opinion, that the price of labor, arising from a difficulty in procuring food, did not affect the price of commodities. He confessed that his former view on that subject was erroneous. (“Ricardo to Malthus,” 23 Feb. 1816, in Ricardo 1951–73, 7, p. 25; emphasis added)
In the preface to the second edition of External Corn Trade (1820),Footnote 11 Torrens acknowledges that he has been converted to Ricardo’s position.
The second type of argument advanced by Ricardo to play down the contributions of Torrens emphasizes that, in those areas in which their opinions converge, the latter cannot be credited with having discovered anything. This is because Torrens’s theory was (allegedly) a mere compilation of the ideas of Smith and Robert Malthus. It is true that Torrens, himself, testifies to the influence of these authors.Footnote 12 Citing this influence, Ricardo thus does not appear to attribute any originality to the analysis of Torrens. A discussion of this second criticism is found in the next sections.
III. THE ORIGIN OF THE NATURAL WAGE IN RICARDO
With regard to the origin of Ricardian theory of the natural wage, Rosselli (1985, pp. 241–244) points out the key role played by the correspondence between Ricardo and Malthus.Footnote 13 During the exchange of letters on the controversy surrounding declining profit rates, Malthus asked his correspondent about the famous Ricardian saying that the price of necessities is the grand leveler of wages:Footnote 14 “When however the rise in the price of corn is occasioned solely and exclusively by the necessity of cultivating poorer land I am now convinced that … the real price of labor must fall, I see no reason why the nominal price of labor should rise” (“Malthus to Ricardo,” 22 Dec. 1815, in Ricardo 1951–73, 6, p. 341; emphasis added).Footnote 15
Malthus’s misunderstanding may be due to how Ricardo proceeded in his Essay on Profits (1815). At the beginning of this paper, Ricardo adopts the assumption that real wages remain constant: “We will, however, suppose that no improvements take place in agriculture, and that capital and population advance in the proper proportion, so that the real wages of labor, continue uniformly the same” (Ricardo 1951–73, 4, p. 12). Thus, when Malthus expresses reservations regarding Ricardo’s position on the impact a rise in the price of corn has on nominal wages, the latter appears to run into difficulties explaining himself. These difficulties are noted by Rosselli (1985, p. 242) when she observes that Ricardo’s responses to Malthus are not accompanied by detailed explanations. Two letters written in 1816 attest to Ricardo’s doubts. The first letter reveals that, in light of the criticisms expressed by Malthus, Ricardo pursues a parallel line of reasoning that is less concerned with justifying the existence of a link between the monetary price of necessities and the nominal wage than with showing that the functioning of the labor market does not nullify the impact of the higher price of wheat on the nominal wage:
[T]here are two causes which raise the wages of labor, one the demand for laborers being great in proportion to the supply, the other that the food and necessaries of the laborer are difficult of production, or require a great deal of labor to produce them. The more I reflect on the subject the more I am convinced that the latter cause has an incessant operation. (“Ricardo to Malthus,” 9 Aug. 1816, in Ricardo 1951–73, 7, p. 57; emphasis added)
Several months into this debate over wages, a second letter to Malthus seems to be particularly revealing of Ricardo’s state of mind. After having asserted that the low price of food may be accompanied by high wages if capital grows at a greater rate than the population—“in which case profits would fall and not rise”—he claims, though without explanation, that this situation results from “peculiar circumstances” that have left wages in an “unusual state” (“Ricardo to Malthus,” 11 Oct. 1816, in Ricardo 1951–73, 7, p. 78). Though ignored by Rosselli, the remainder of the letter contains interesting clues regarding the degree of advancement of his thinking.
All I [Ricardo] meant to contend for is that profits depend on wages, wages, under common circumstances, on the price of food, and necessaries, and the price of food and necessaries on the fertility of the last cultivated land.
In all cases it is perhaps true that ... wages [will depend upon] the demand compared with supply of labor, if it be allowed that the price of necessaries influence the demand and supply of labor. (Ricardo 1951–73, 7, p. 78; emphasis added)
In this last quotation, the existence of two types of price for labor is not yet clearly specified. Only with publication of the Principles do we find the two factors that, according to Ricardo, determine the wage—(1) the supply of, and demand for, labor; and (2) the price of the goods that wages serve to buy (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, p. 97)—leading us to distinguish between the study of the subsistence wage (or the natural price of labor) and the prevalent wage rate (or the market price of labor). When addressing the role played by natural wage theory in the Principles, Rosselli (1985, p. 244n7) mentions that Ricardo credits Torrens. In developing this point she mentions, but does not elaborate on, the fact that the first pages of Chapter 5 of the Principles draw extensively on the first edition of Torrens’s External Corn Trade.
IV. THE ROLE OF THE NATURAL WAGE AND ITS DEFINITION IN TORRENS
In an article titled “On Some Neglected British Economists,” Edwin R. A. Seligman claims that Torrens “advanced a theory of wages which was adopted by Ricardo” (Seligman Reference Seligman1903, p. 341). According to Seligman, the credit given by Ricardo is enough to prove that the latter “never thought that he was advancing any new doctrine” (ibid., p. 343). This comment was subject to a scathing critique by Paul Vidonne (Reference Vidonne1986), because it does not account for correspondence from Ricardo that describes Torrens’s protests that he was not cited in the first edition of the Principles. Drawing on this correspondence, Vidonne concludes that the citation of Torrens in the Principles is “more attributable to the protests Torrens lodged with Ricardo than with this latter’s recognition of the importance of the former’s contribution” (ibid., p. 151; our translation). In other words, Seligman’s attempt to rehabilitate Torrens’s reputation runs up against the position expressed by Ricardo himself. Without contesting his finding, it is unclear whether the flaws in Seligman’s thesis are more indicative of the position he defends or the arguments he uses to that end.
Torrens’s essay aims to describe the negative effects that wheat import restrictions would have on grain prices, money wages, profits, etc. The structure of the essay reveals the attention paid to the wage question. Indeed, of the three components of income (wages, profit, and rent), only compensation to labor is accorded its own section head in two chapters (Chapter III, “On the Influence of the Price of Corn”; II, “On the Wages of Labor, and on the Prices of Commodities”). In this part of the paper, Torrens seeks to demonstrate that deteriorating conditions of agricultural production caused by capital accumulation trigger an increase in nominal wages without actually improving the real standard of living.
Thus, the thesis that Torrens wishes to defend requires a theory of wages. For this purpose, the author appropriates Adam Smith’s concept of the natural wage. This notion is introduced by Smith in the framework of his work on exchanges that reflect the distinction between natural and market prices ([1776] 1822, 1, ch. 5). Consistent with the analysis by Smith, Torrens begins by stating that the market price of a good presupposes its natural price, since this latter constitutes “a centre, towards which it has a perpetual tendency to approach” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 61). After having settled for a brief summary of Smith’s work on market price fluctuations around the natural price,Footnote 16 Torrens emphasizes that “in their application to labor, however, the principles of market, and natural price, may require some farther explanation” (p. 62). This deeper look at the wage question requires Torrens to treat labor “as a commodity in the market,” which he considers to be “[the] proper way of regarding labor” (p. 62).Footnote 17 On this foundation, the author logically deduces a methodical distinction between the natural price of labor and its market price, together with two distinct wage determinants: “It [labor] therefore has, as well as every thing else, its market price, and its natural price. The market price of labor is regulated by the proportion which ... may exist between the demand and the supply; its natural price is governed by other laws” (p. 62; emphasis added).
In short, Torrens’s theory of the natural wage appears as a special case of Smith’s theory of the natural prices of goods. There is, however, a fundamental difference between the natural prices of commodities and of labor. While the natural price is clearly defined as the sum of the constituents of income—“wages, profit, and rent, may be considered as constituting the … natural price of things” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 57)—Torrens unambiguously associates the natural price of labor, measured in physical terms, with an exogenous variable:
[The] natural price [of labor] ... consists, in such a quantity of the necessaries, and comforts of life, as from the nature of the climate, and the habits of the country, are necessary to support the laborer, and to enable him to rear such a family as may preserve, in the market, an undiminished supply of labor. (p. 62; emphasis added)Footnote 18
In the above quotation, Torrens clearly distinguishes between the two determinants of the natural price of labor, as measured in physical terms: the natural factor, which depends on climatic conditions; and the cultural factor, i.e., lifestyle. While the climate explains divergences in subsistence modes between countries, customs and traditions provide the rationale for these differences, not only across countries but also over time. On the basis of this distinction, Torrens concludes “that part of this price [of labor] which depends upon climate, is unchangeable” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 64). As is the case for the technical conditions for manufacturing goods, the conditions for reproducing experienced workers by their lifestyle habits change slowly over time. Notwithstanding the account taken of socio-cultural factors in the determination of the subsistence mode of workers, Torrens is able to conclude that “the natural price of labor is thus steady” (p. 65).
It is not the same for the market price of labor because, as Torrens states, this “fluctuates perpetually according to the proportion between supply and demand” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 65). These fluctuations are interpreted as the result of population adjustments in the presence of labor market disequilibria:
When the market price [of labor] falls below the others, … deaths are increased; while, the increasing difficulty of maintaining a family, increasing the prudential check on marriage, births are diminished; and thus, by a double operation, the level between the natural, and the market price of labor, is restored. (p. 65)Footnote 19
In short, labor market disequilibria are absorbed by fluctuations in the supply of labor, which he proceeds to explicitly associate with two operations that are quintessentially Malthusian. When the demand for labor is too low, the simultaneous action of these two mechanisms (a decline in the birth rate and rise in mortality) returns the labor market to an equilibrium so that the natural wage is restored.
Having presented the unique features of his theory of wages, Torrens next seeks to demonstrate how this theory provides a rationale for the existence of indexation of the money wage to the money price of subsistence goods. This reasoning, conducted in both real and monetary terms, is presented as follows (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, pp. 76–77). Torrens begins his explanation with the fact that a rise in the money price of corn (all other things being equal) results in a decline in the real wage of labor. Indeed, “the class of laborers, being obliged to give a greater portion of their wages for bread, will have less to bestow on other necessaries and comforts of life; and though the nominal, or money price of labor, may remain unchanged, yet its real, or commodity price, will be reduced.” However, this situation cannot persist, since “where custom has introduced bread corn, as the basis of the laborer’s food, the money price of corn will have an irresistible effect on the money price of labor.” Indeed, a decline in the real wage undermines the living conditions of workers, leading to a reduction in the labor supply. Now, in the presence of a labor shortage, “the competition of those who derived a profit from employing [the supply of labor], would restore wages to their natural rate; that is, to such a sum in the currency, as would suffice to purchase subsistence of the customary quality, and in the customary quantity” (p. 77; emphasis added). It may seem surprising that this citation did not attract the attention of commentators on Torrens (in particular, Robbins and De Vivo). In fact, to a remarkable extent this theory captures the exogenous character of the natural price of labor, as measured by a basket of goods.
It appears that Torrens’s analysis constitutes a unprecedented attempt to combine Smith’s concept of a natural wage with the Malthusian Law of Population in order to explain why an increase in the price of food must, necessarily, result in higher money wages. Throughout the adjustment process the market price of labor serves to correct variations in the real wages, so as to constantly restore it to a level set outside of the market.
We would add one last precision about the differences between Torrens’s analyses and Smith’s theory. In his long comments on wages ([1776] 1822, 1, ch. 8), Smith explains how a variation in the demand for labor is always accompanied by an adjustment in the population. To Smith, the natural wage thus appears as something that is ultimately regulated by “the increase of the national wealth” ([1776] 1822, 1, p. 104).Footnote 20 Torrens does not seem to dismiss this definition when he writes that the natural price of labor is the one that maintains “an undiminished supply of labor” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 62). However, Torrens completes this definition by adding a new analysis that endeavors to reconcile the idea of an indexation of the money wage to the monetary price of subsistence with the competitive mechanism of the labor market.
V. THE ANTERIORITY OF TORRENS TO RICARDO
The theory of the natural wage contained in Chapter 5 of the Principles constitutes the means by which Ricardo answered the reproach that he took for granted “that money wages would rise with a rise in the price of raw produce, but that this is by no means a necessary consequence, as the laborer may be contented with fewer enjoyments” (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, p. 118). In this respect, Ricardo reuses the same argument as Torrens (ibid., pp. 93–94): on the one hand, the need to treat labor like any other good,Footnote 21 and thus to distinguish between the factors that determine the natural wage (the habits of daily life) and those that determine the market wage (the labor supply and demand), and, on the other hand, the trend for the market wage to coincide with the natural wage.
On this basis, chapters 5 and 6 of the Principles describe the process of capital accumulation and its impact on wages, using an approach that is in both real and nominal terms. Ricardo’s main points can be grouped and summarized as follows.Footnote 22 Starting from an initial state in which the variables are in their natural state, an increase in capital stimulates the demand for labor. On the labor market, competition between capitalists drives up the money wage. All other things being equal by assumption,Footnote 23 real wages must necessarily increase. On the labor market, the current wage rises above the natural wage. Owing to this increase in the real wage, “the condition of the laborer is flourishing and happy, that he has it in his power to command a greater proportion of the necessaries and enjoyments of life, and therefore to rear a healthy and numerous family” (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, p. 94). This increase in the population in turn stimulates the supply of labor, undercutting the money wage.
Nonetheless, the possibility of the money wage’s returning to its initial level materializes only in the specific case in which the accumulation of capital benefits the production of goods, which can increase “without limit” (ibid., p. 119). In fact, this population increase will stimulate a concurrent growth in demand for agricultural goods, which will, in the presence of import restrictions, be increasingly difficult to satisfy.Footnote 24 The rise in the production cost of agricultural goods increases their money price and induces a decline in the real wage of labor. In this case, if money wages were to fall back to their initial level—i.e., the value that prevailed before the onset of the process—the worker “would be soon totally deprived of subsistence” (ibid., p. 101). On the basis of this assertion, it is possible to follow Ricardo and deduce that re-establishing equilibrium on the labor market must necessarily involve a higher natural price of labor, expressed in terms of money:
Thus, then, with every improvement of society, with every increase in its capital, the market wages of labor will rise; but the permanence of their rise will depend on the question, whether the natural price of labor has also risen; and this again will depend on the rise in the natural price of those necessaries on which the wages of labor are expended. (ibid., p. 96)
This description of the effects of capital accumulation on the money wage brings out two similarities between the approaches of Ricardo and Torrens. A first shared point concerns the incidence of the capital accumulation process on the price of labor in the presence of restrictions on corn imports. Both authors emphasize the necessity of distinguishing between the natural wage measured in pound sterling and the natural wage measured by a basket of goods. In terms of money, the natural price of labor increases; in real terms, the natural price of labor remains constant. A second shared point addresses the endeavor to reconcile the competitive functioning of the labor market with the idea of a given real wage in order to justify this result. When the money price of necessities rises, it is the existence of a stable adjustment mechanism based on variations in the supply of labor—the market price of labor—that produces an equilibrium on the labor market to which the natural wage level is restored.
However, this mechanism for indexing the money wage to the money price of necessities may prove to be disputable. For example, it requires that the natural level of the real wage does not change as supply and demand on the labor market adjust. When the money price of corn increases, Torrens considers that “a single season will, probably, be sufficient to reduce the population, so as to force the money price of labor up to the level of the money price of corn” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 79). Indeed, the dual effect of a lower birthrate and higher mortality implies that the reduction in the labor supply “will be more rapid than might, at first sight, be imagined” (p. 78). However, this argument is not very persuasive, because such a process is based on population variations and thus would take more time than Torrens supposes. Hence, when Ricardo concedes that the gap between the market price and the natural price may persist “for an indefinite period,” particularly “in an improving society” (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, pp. 94–95), there is no longer any factor to justify the continued exogenous character of the natural wage, given the influence of the prevailing wage on laborers’ customs and lifestyles.
Moreover, this remark by Ricardo must certainly be viewed as a consequence of his definition of the natural wage. While Torrens writes that the natural price is the one that maintains “an undiminished supply of labor” (Torrens Reference Torrens1815, p. 62), Ricardo defines the natural price of labor, measured in terms of a physical basket, as the price that precisely maintains the population “without either increase or diminution” (Ricardo 1951–73, 1, p. 114). To summarize, both authors assimilate the notion of the natural wage to the subsistence wage, but, for Ricardo, this obtains only when the accumulation rate is nil. What significance should we attribute to this distinction? Both Malthus (1820) and Karl Marx ([1861–63] 1975; [1867] 1906) emphasize the difficulty in reconciling Ricardo’s definition of the natural wage with accounting for capital accumulation, and thus side with Torrens.Footnote 25 But these two authors do not come to the same conclusions. Malthus concludes that it is impossible to assume a constant real wage because the accumulation process leads to a drop in the profit rate and, by extension, the demand for labor.Footnote 26 Marx, in turn, rejects the dynamics of the Malthusian justification for maintaining the real wage at the subsistence level and replaces it with class warfare.Footnote 27
In summary, neither the definition provided by Torrens nor that of Ricardo provides a consistent and unambiguous description of the accumulation process. In his Notes on Malthus, Ricardo recognizes the problem created by his definition of the natural wage. However, he stands by his definition in the Principles, owing to the need to treat labor the same as any other good (cf. Ricardo 1951–73, 2, pp. 227–228n).Footnote 28 These equivocations should perhaps be understood as the upshot of the challenges he faced attempting to integrate, into his system, elements of a theory with which he, in fact, disagreed (cf. section II above).
VI. CONCLUSION
Torrens proposes an initial version of the theory of the natural wage that Ricardo subsequently develops in the framework of his demonstration based on the profit rate.Footnote 29 This initial version contains a mechanism for indexing the money wage to the money price of necessities used by Ricardo to justify, in opposition to Malthus, that the price of food is the grand regulator of wage levels. This mechanism assumes a constant real wage that is pegged to the natural price of labor—though its definition is modified by Ricardo in order to retain consistency with the rest of his analysis.
Despite this influence, Torrens was unable to convince Ricardo of the anteriority of his theory. It may be that this failure was, at least in part, attributable to the fact that by then Torrens had abandoned this theory himself. After reading Ricardo’s Principles, Torrens pursued development of his theory of wages in new directions. In the second edition of External Corn Trade (1820, pp. 374ff.), the notion of a natural wage has been dropped. It is only in the fifth, and final, edition of this essay that Torrens examines, in any detail, “the principles which regulate the wages of labor” (1829, p. 451). In this text, the notion of a natural wage is replaced with the idea that the wage is determined by “the ratio between population and capital” (ibid, p. 468). Compared with the 1815 essay, only the reference to the socio-cultural nature of the subsistence wage, defined as the “minimum of wages” (ibid., p. 460), remains.Footnote 30
