Recently there has been a welcome spate of publications concerning early modern alchemy and chymistry. Though alchemy was formerly dismissed as irrelevant to the development of science, historians including Larry Principe, William Newman and the late Betty Jo Teeter-Dobbs have demonstrated that major figures such as Robert Boyle and Isaac Newton were deeply engaged with alchemical study. Some of these historians have also more clearly defined the nature of chemical practice, using the term ‘chymistry’ to remind us that it is anachronistic to make clear distinctions between alchemy and chemistry in this period. For instance, early modern ‘chymists’ attempted to transmute metals into gold – considered an ‘alchemical’ practice – yet also performed experiments involving mass balance or crystallographic analysis that today would be considered ‘chemical’. Tara Nummedal and Bruce Moran continue to deepen and broaden our understanding of these themes, as both scholars have moved away from the study of the still-famous to understand, in Nummedal's phrase, the ‘lives and labor of the vast majority of alchemical practitioners’ (p. 9) and lesser-known alchemical theorists. Nummedal and Moran have elucidated the interaction of alchemy with economics and the mining industry, as well as the perceptions of early modern humanist scholars and noble patrons about chymistry and its authority as a scholarly discipline.
As the basis of her gracefully written study of what she calls the ‘entrepreneurial alchemist’ in the Holy Roman Empire, Nummedal utilized archival records of noble courts. Building on the work of Pamela O. Long and Bruce Moran, she found that alchemists seemed to offer a solution to the financial woes of early modern princelings in the Germanies. By the end of the sixteenth century, the stagnation of metal productivity in European mines, the decline in American silver imports, and a booming economy meant that more specie was required. German princely entrepreneurs employed alchemists not only to make metals via transmutation, but also to provide new techniques to increase the productivity and profitability of their mines. Alchemy was looked to as a ‘panacea for a troubled economy’ (p. 175).
But how did the prince know which alchemists were legitimate practitioners, and which were committing fraud, or Betrug? Although today we would believe all transmutations were Betrug, Nummedal expertly delineates an early modern world view in which transmutation was thought to be possible in theory. Base metals were thought to ripen into gold while ‘maturing’ in the mines, and the ‘isolation of precious metals from an alloy or a mixture of compounds’ was thought to be the creation of gold out of lesser metals (p. 109). But even if they could bring about transmutation, alchemists were not in a guild, nor was alchemy integrated formally into the scholastic university curriculum. Rigorous screening procedures at court, and contracts in which princes made alchemists entirely responsible for all the expenses incurred in case of failure, lessened the capital risk. In exchange, alchemists received the laboratory materials they needed and a huge profit if the ‘transmutation’ worked.
Despite these precautions, alchemical projects did fail, and princes had to determine if Betrug had been committed. Nummedal analyses how the princes did it. Sometimes they turned up intentional swindle – for instance, one poor soul named Nüschler was caught mixing gold into the mixture that court officials were to test for quality. The alchemist George Honauer simply skipped town; his princely employer hunted him down with ferocity as he was convinced Honauer could transmute metals and was deliberately withholding his secrets. If the fraud was thought to be deliberate, as in the above cases, it was seen as a crime against the state, and the public executions were ruthless and spectacular. Honauer's iron gallows was gilded, and for his execution he had to wear a golden garment. If, however, there was a finding of general incompetence – bad enough to occasion the breaking of the contract – it might land the hapless alchemist in debtor's prison, but alchemists were unlikely to be killed; one generous prince even forgave the debts if the alchemist in question would become a tutor for his children. Princes had a good deal at stake in their pursuit of entrepreneurial alchemy, as their power and authority was increasingly pinned to their economic projects.
Bruce Moran's work also examines issues of alchemical legitimacy, fraud and authority, but does so within the context of the humanist writings of the alchemist, physician and philosopher Andreas Libavius (1550–1616). Moran's cogent and detailed analysis of the Libavian corpus demonstrates to what extent this scholar used the often contentious republic of letters to define the disciplinary boundaries of chymistry and give it a legitimate place in the scholastic curriculum.
Libavius attempted to rehabilitate alchemy's reputation with a rhetorical ‘program of cultural deliverance’ with some surprising parameters (p. 9). Historians have generally assumed that Paracelsianism and alchemy were natural allies, with Paracelsus's embrace of iatrochymistry a boon to chymistry's development. Paracelsus has also been perceived by historians as an iconic reformer who subjected alchemy to empirical rigour. On the other hand, Libavius argued that ‘many of Paracelsus’ ideas had been seized from earlier alchemical sources' (p. 155), and that the Paracelsian rejection of ancient philosophy and Galenism was positively dangerous to his campaign to find a place for alchemy in the realm of natural philosophy. Although Libavius acknowledged that some of the Paracelsian chymical medicines were useful (and even advocated their use among Galenic physicians), he saw Paracelsianism as a subversive preserve of alchemical frauds. Contrary to Paracelsus's claims, alchemy did not grant ‘universal knowledge’, it was not a metaphysical art, nor was the alchemist a theologian. Rather, for Libavius, chymistry was part of academic philosophy, and he subjected it to scholastic method, clarified its terminology, and argued that its practice should not be in the secret chamber of an adept but in a ‘chemical house’ where a respectable burgher plied his art. Alchemy, Aristotle and humanist erudition would work together to ‘make a place for the subject of chymia among the didactic arts’ (p. 6).
As Moran states, ‘in taking chymia out of the hands of the Paracelsians while, at the same time, convincing Galenic doctors of the value of chemical therapies, [Libavius] knew that he would have to sail between the Scylla of conservative Galenism and the Charybdis of Paracelsian magic’ (p. 158). The middle course that Libavius took is indeed entirely outside the usual classifications of chymists that historians have traditionally utilized when contextualizing early modern scientific practice. It is also reminiscent of the tricky course that Moran took in his argument that Paracelsus often looms too large in historical considerations of chymistry. Although the assertion is not new – using different evidence, Principe and Newman have claimed that Johannes van Helmont's influence upon the development of chymistry was underrated compared to that of Paracelsus – it is worth asking to what extent Libavius's attitude about Paracelsus was unique. After all, Libavius's intentions and intellectual allegiances themselves were often misunderstood by his colleagues. While Moran is correct to say that historians must take a more nuanced approach when placing the messy business of chymistry in historical context, a larger consideration of Libavius's influence and legacy in the chymical community would have been welcome. These quibbles aside, both Nummedal's and Moran's books are fair illustrations of the high calibre of work presently being done in the history of early modern chymistry.
