If one disregards author Daniel Varisco's first aim in this book, namely, critiquing Edward Said's paradigm-busting Orientalism, then one can affirm that his second aim is ably fulfilled, for his book indeed presents a colorful and often enjoyable compendium of what might be called pretheoretical writing on the Middle East. The book's principal goal is to defend individual Orientalists from what Professor Varisco takes to be Said's attack upon their scholarship. Offering to place “what Said labeled ‘Orientalism’ in a more soundly recovered historical context” (p. 22), he neglects Said's own dense context, which is imbued with poststructuralist writing and the desire to break away from humanist myths of authenticity. Varisco tends toward the opposite direction. He delves deep into the biographies of individual Orientalist scholars and sometimes presents fascinating accounts of their individual oeuvres. Thus, denying the essential point of Orientalism and rejecting its method provide Varisco with an enabling blindness that allows him to develop something like a late medieval florilegium of fanciful and delightful quotations and summaries. This is a project for which he is well equipped as an anthropologist and for which, one suspects, the Said angle is a pretext.
Varisco's scholarly apparatus reinforces the feeling that this is primarily a survey or reference work. The introduction alone includes 230 footnotes, and the book in toto has 1,672 footnotes covering 115 pages at the back. The works cited section extends to 55 pages. The text itself offers sharp observations. Varisco notices that Said tends to assert a claim as absolute and then qualify it so as to avoid the impression of dogmatism (p. 99). He is attentive to the margins of Said's text, noting uncorrected typos (p. 220) and egregious mistranslations (p. 219). The author's propensity for puns confirms the playfulness of this book: “the catachresis has been let out of the bag” (p. 103), “the straw man that most breaks the critic's back” (p. 108), and “if the devil is indeed in the details, then Said would have a devil of a time” (p. 123). The puns are often acute. Varisco names Said's distrust of experts and their guilds “the guildy-until-proven-innocent trope” (p. 140). Other witticisms are cruder: “a horrid Orientalist whoredom of callous colonialists” (p. 301). Undeniably, the book can be fun to read.
If one seeks a coherent understanding of Orientalism, however, Varisco's lively and engaging book is frustrating. A measure of his misprision is the repeated question, “How has Said managed to get away with writing intellectual history?” He thinks that Said is doing intellectual history all wrong. But intellectual history, the faith that ideas exist and may be studied apart from practices, is exactly what Said was trying to defy and correct. In Said's seminars during the years before Orientalism appeared, we students were handed not A. O. Lovejoy but Michel Foucault's Archaeology of Knowledge and Gramsci's essay “The Intellectuals.” One spoke not of ideas but of discourses. You didn't just read the 100 greatest books on Egypt or penitentiaries. Instead, you dug down into a larger, more various formation of intellectual and material objects that had evolved internal rules, fused together, and solidified as unities. An investigator worthy the name bored into layers of texts, handbooks, and repetitive practices such as army drill patterns, anonymous lower-court rulings, or the daily round of homeroom and detention in schools. Foucault had recently produced such an archaeology of what he termed “discipline,” a 175-year accretion of theories and practices devoted to controlling the behavior of bodies in a vast assortment of settings. Said produced a similar archaeology of Orientalism. Whereas Foucault compared his strange objects of study to geological outcroppings, Gramsci imagined them more as coral formations, fragile and slow to develop. But both of Said's methodological touchstones, Foucault and Gramsci, roundly rejected any shrunken history of ideas divorced from practices.
Varisco does not attend to these revolutions in method. As a consequence, he flattens any passage of Orientalism that rises above the banalities of intellectual history. The result is comical:
We learn little about what Renan actually said about the Orient, or how others responded to what he said, but rather encounter him as “a figure who must be grasped, in short, as a type of cultural and intellectual praxis, as a style for making Orientalist statements within what Michel Foucault would call the archive of his time” (p. 112).
Flummoxed by what seems to him to be Said's incomprehensibly eccentric phrasing, Varisco typically gets defensive and reads the passage as an ad hominem attack on Renan himself: “what comes out of this is a portrait of Renan the rabid racist “(p. 113). But Said is striving in the passage precisely to get away from blaming individuals. Instead, he is indicting“ a type of praxis” and “a style for making statements.” By anthropomorphizing Said's rigorously impersonal concepts, Varisco saps the passage of all its provocation and juiciness.
Said's premises in Orientalism repel and anger Varisco. “Because of what Said chooses to highlight in texts, the ability of individual scholars to think, reflect, and reform is negated” (p. 300). Yes, exactly. Foucault's Archaeology puts it bluntly: “The authority of the creative subject, as the raison d’être of an oeuvre and the principle of its unity, is quite alien to [archaeology]” (The Archaeology of Knowledge, trans. A. M. Sheridan Smith [New York: Harper Colophon, 1972], 139). But because Varisco does not accept what Said is doing, he is reduced to complaining about what Said has not done. Said has failed, we learn, to engage “the numerous Muslim intellectuals who have leveled broadsides in Arabic against earlier Western Orientalism” (p. 150) and “ignore[d] the large literature of resistance from India, Central Asia, China, and Japan” (p. 148). Further, he notes that: “Said excludes this text from his analysis” (p. 114), “a glaring omission in Orientalism is . . .” (p. 137), “I am concerned with the many kinds of travel texts Said passes over” (p. 226), and “there is no discussion in Orientalism of The Travels of Sir John Mandeville” (p. 226). Said has not, in other words, written the book that Varisco would have written. Noted.
While lively and well written, the book's flawed theoretical framework renders it unpersuasive. Its stated goal of restoring the historical context of Orientalism turns out to mean erasing what was innovative in Said's method. Perhaps this backward slide is inevitable, given that, as Varisco admits, he is “clearly interloping as a literary critic” (p. 22). When he forgets about his chosen adversary, however, and delves happily into the careers and insights of the Orientalists he has studied so well, and written of so clearly, there is no virtue he cannot claim. As an animated, detailed, and witty rendition of the Orientalists’ neglected insights and charms, the book is of value to anyone who wishes to read an exhaustive and deeply affectionate survey of Orientalist achievements.
