This book does exactly what it says on its cover, presenting the results of the work at Chagar Bazar in northeastern Syria between 1999 and 2002. The fieldwork was carried out by an international team involving the British School of Archaeology in Iraq (as it then was), the University of Liege and the Syrian Directorate General for Antiquities and Museums. The aim of the project was to investigate the settlement layout and material culture of the site over the whole length of its occupation and to reconstruct the role of the site in its regional context. Evaluation of environmental and climatic parameters constitute a component of this agenda. It has to be said straightaway that these aims were achieved resoundingly and that the project – and publication – have made a genuine contribution to the archaeology of northern Mesopotamia.
The background to all this is the work carried out by Mallowan at Chagar Bazar between 1934 and 1937. His work established the basic parameters of the site and the fact that it was occupied, with breaks, from the late sixth to the mid-second millennium bce. Although there still appears to be genuine breaks in the occupation, the renewed work has demonstrated that the site was indeed in use during two of Mallowan's supposed “occupational hiatuses” (during the late-fifth to early-fourth millennium and the late-third millennium bce). Indeed, the material recovered from the late Chalcolithic (early-to-mid-fourth millennium bce, i.e. contemporary with the early-Uruk period in southern Mesopotamia) is an important addition to our knowledge from this period. On the other hand, the absence of Ubaid occupation and the break in occupation at the turn of the third to second millennium appears to still be correct. In the third millennium levels it is striking that both Ninevite 5 and Metallic Ware are present: as noted by the author (p. 21), this may be taken as an indication that Chagar Bazar was to some extent at the point of crossover between the material cultures of the western and eastern Jezirah. After the break in occupation starting in the very late-third millennium the site was then reoccupied ca. 1850–1800 bce and remained under occupation until somewhere around the middle of the second millennium. A historical outline (p. 24f) suggests how Chagar Bazar fits into the (Old Babylonian) political history of the second millennium, specifically in the context of the rise and fall of the empires of Yahdum-Lim of Mari (Tell Hariri) and the actions of Shamshi-Adad after he had consolidated his power base in Ekallatum and Assur and gone on to found a new capital at Shubat-Enlil (Tell Leilan).
Although Chagar Bazar is of only moderate size (12 ha.), the attention given to it first by Mallowan and now by McMahon et al has demonstrated that it merits its important place in archaeological scholarship. New approaches have led to fresh insights: for example, the utilisation of GIS data to reconstruct the local pattern of radial hollow ways, together with an understanding that the ends of these ways correspond to the limit of a centre's agricultural activity (in the case of Chagar Bazar, 2.5–3 km from the site), lead to a calculation that the area of land under cultivation must have been in the range of 20–28 km2 which would in turn have supported a population of the order of 1,000 people.
The project was designed to approach its aims through combining methodical surface survey with the re-exploration and re-evaluation of areas previously explored by Mallowan. This entailed the excavation of new trenches in a number of areas, of which the most significant were Area A and Area G. The focus of these operations was very much on the second millennium occupation although substantial evidence from earlier periods was also recovered.
Area A was sited on the north mound near Mallowan's Area EH. Excavations in this area revealed three phases. The uppermost Phase I only yielded ephemeral remains and Phase III was only explored in soundings, but the remains recovered in Phase II were substantial and interesting, a complex of five buildings of which one, Building 3, was clearly a “community building”. It seems certain that this part of the site oversaw administrative activities (among others) as it is in this area that the few artefacts of administration recovered – seals, sealings, numerical tallies, a weight – were found (they did not however come from Building 3 itself). The average size of bricks in Area A was 36–38 × 36–38 × 8–10 cm, and thus substantially larger than the standard Old Babylonian (baked) brick which measures an average 33 × 33 × 8 cm (p.49).
Area G was sited on the northern mound in a series of four squares in a row immediately adjacent to Mallowan's Area BD and was designed to make better sense of both the plan and stratigraphy published by Mallowan. Area G was an exceptionally well conceived operation which succeeded in its aims brilliantly. The results of the new excavation allowed a coherent reinterpretation of Mallowan's work. Of the five phases identified, the most striking is Phase II where the results of both excavations could be combined to produce a plan showing numerous small buildings crowded onto each side of an alley. This was traced for a length of over 40m and as such gives an exceptional insight into the urban configuration of a provincial town in this period. The single ‘long-room’ houses lining the alley are typical of the region and McMahon documents the parallels from other sites such as Tell Mohammed Diyab, Tell Leilan, Tell Barri and Tell Mozan.
Turning to the diachronic aspect, it would seem that Chagar Bazar was host to significant administrative facilities through the greater part of its history. Although this cannot be demonstrated for the remains of the Halaf and Uruk periods (in which context it may perhaps be significant that the site appears to be devoid of bevel rim bowls), the presence of a substantial building (walls up to 1.5 m thick) in the area exposing Early Jezirah III remains (Area B) clearly hints at a major public building in the late Early Dynastic period. It must be highly likely that there will also have been an administrative centre at Chagar Bazar in the Akkadian period though there is as yet no direct evidence of this. The collapse of the Akkadian empire however led to major changes. The presence of a post-Akkadian administrative building (Area D) at Chagar Bazar demonstrates that the area cannot have been completely abandoned. Nevertheless, the occupation at this time was restricted to the top of the southern mound and it is clear that the region did at any rate undergo a substantial de-urbanisation. As McMahon suggests (p. 23), the rural settlement pattern may have fragmented into small villages at this time.
As mentioned, there does appear to be a genuine break in the sequence at the end of the third millennium, with occupation resuming in the Old Babylonian period when Chagar Bazar once again became a site of local importance. The evidence of the texts excavated in 1937 – unfortunately no more came to light in the recent fieldwork – makes it clear that the site had a place in the regional government of Shamshi-Adad. An estate of the House of Shubat-Enlil was located in the vicinity and in the later part of his reign preparations were being made for a census of both the sedentary and nomadic populations. Further indication of the impact of the military administration on the town may be evinced from the regularity of plot size in Area G, which McMahon plausibly suggest might have been due to the parcelling out of land at a state level, a possible explanation for which could be Shamshi-Adad settling the local nomadic population. Following the death of Shamshi-Adad in 1775 the site probably passed into the control of Zimri-Lim and subsequently back and forth among the various successor kingdoms that emerged in the region following the demise of the Mari Empire.
The volume is well designed and well presented, although it has to be admitted that the cover is somewhat clashing. Features which stand out are the loci marked on plans and labelled digitally on photographs. The tables summarising the key data from each locus are also an excellent inclusion. Specialist chapters deal with burial practices, human bones, ceramic assemblages and small finds. The work concludes with an extensive bibliography and numerous plates. In sum this is a comprehensive presentation of a model project, clearly conceived on both a theoretical and a practical level and carried out with thoroughness and intelligence. Students of both the prehistory and historical archaeology of Mesopotamia are in debt to McMahon and all those involved in this important contribution to the field.
