Someone—perhaps a tenured scholar with at least some acquaintance with Bourdieu—should write a brief paper on Variorum's forbiddingly priced Collected Studies Series and the like. At their best, they assemble high-quality and difficult to access articles in convenient, coherent, and well-indexed volumes. The economics of interlibrary loan and serial subscriptions are beyond me, but such volumes must make good financial sense for libraries with tight budgets: a state university can hardly be expected to have all the supplements to the Journal of Semitic Studies, much less the full run of Quaderni di Studi Arabi. However, at their worst, the volumes are incoherent collections of relatively accessible and undistinguished pieces that make their publisher some money and lengthen the CVs of their well-published authors. The Quaderni website is currently out of date, and in any case it gives summaries rather than full text versions of its articles, but one wonders how long it will be before digitization and online access make a series such as this obsolete. I cannot be the only reader of IJMES with Athens Options on his toolbar.
In the case of the volume under review, we happily have an example of this Variorum series at its best. The publication of God's Rule means that at least some of those who knew Crone only as either the dajjāl or a mujaddid of the study of early Islamic social and political history will now know her as a historian of Islamic political thought. (A second volume that collects articles on Umayyad and Abbasid history is promised in the preface.) This volume, which republishes twelve articles that originally appeared between 1980 and 2001, includes six that fall loosely under the same rubric (they range from ʿUmar's Shura to Ghazali's Nasiha), but together these occupy less than half of the volume's pages. Of the remaining and sometimes lengthier six, three address the religious history of what is called the “Non-Islamic Near East” (a curious title given that “Islam, Judeo-Christianity, and Byzantine Iconoclasm” says a great deal about Islam and Islamic lands), and three address the law. It is here that the reader will find two pieces that have perhaps the most far-reaching implications for the study of early Islam: “Jahilī and Jewish Law: The Qasāma” and “Two Legal Problems Bearing on the Early History of the Qurʾan.” The former explains the origin of this oath by arguing for a “deuteronomic institution modified by rabbinic ideas,” a position taken in the 1984 original and from which, in a postscript, the author distances herself; the latter argues for a post-ʿUthmanic codification for the Qurʾan.
The impression created throughout the volume is of Islam's great creativity: early Muslims inherited, appropriated, and transformed Arabian, Jewish, and Christian (the categories do not really work) cultural legacies and traditions on offer. In addition to receiving, Muslims also gave, and thus Byzantine iconoclasts owe a debt to Muslims. Of course, for every reader interested in early Islam there are many, many more interested in early modern or modern Islam, at least some of whom may be surprised to find among studies on Najdiyya Kharijites (Article ix) and 9th-century Muslim anarchists (Article x) a thorough garroting of methodological grounds of the view, widely held especially by neoconservatives, that Islamic law impedes economic rationalism (“Weber, Islamic Law, and the Rise of Capitalism,” Article vi).
It might be thought that a volume that begins with a reconstruction of a politico-religious movement of the Sasanian period (“Kavād's Heresy and Mazdak's Revolt,” Article i), then passes through Sunni, Kharijite, and Muʿtazilite views on the imamate, and ends with the deconstruction of a Mirror for Princes of the Saljuk period would cover a lot of ground. Indeed it does—not just in terms of geography and chronology but also in genre. The method is fairly consistent, however. First, a problem, such as a contradiction, an exception, or anomaly, is identified. Second, the evidence, both primary and secondary, is carefully (and usually pointedly) surveyed so as to identify fresh paths and new leads. Third, the reader is led—perhaps one should say pushed and prodded—to a solution, which is frequently qualified by an honest admission of a difficulty of understanding or the need for further research. Evidence is accumulated and admitted, rejected, or accommodated by an argument grounded in a model; the obscurity of it all is readily admitted. “We are never going to produce that magic constellation in which all the pieces have fallen into perfect order,” Crone writes of Weber and Weberians (p. 264). Not every reader will be happy about where he or she ends up in a given article, but the trip is always exhilarating because the scenery is so fascinating and the driving so skilled.
